Using 7 speed shifters with 8 speed cassette?

Since 2001, over 90,000 cyclist's have joined Cycling Forums to discuss topics from general cycling to equipment, training, racing and travel or vacation destinations (especially in europe during the tour de france). We also feature an great deals in our online store, 100's of articles, classifieds and product reviews.

Using 7 speed shifters with 8 speed cassette, anyone doing this?

I have lady friend with a Giant Upland. It is fitted with 7 speed EF29 shifters and a 7 speed HG30 14-28 cassette.

The bike is fitted with a TX71 crankset (28/38/48) however it is too slow. I have a spare 8 speed cassette 11-32, the top 7 cogs being 11-28, the overall spacing (7) seems to be the same for both cassettes, 32mm.

This could save buying a new 7 speed cassette and make use a spare 8 speed MTB cassette. Comments? :)

Should work, but chain might not be aligned perfectly in all gears. I've often swapped 7 speed and 8 speed wheels on bikes with 7 speed or 8 speed shifters, and each combination works to a degree. For the last couple of years or so on my commuter, I've been using 8 speed shifters on a 7 speed freewheel and it sounds like some gears are not quite perfectly aligned. I'm soon to upgrade that bike to an 8 speed wheel.

Anyway, it's easy to try it out and see.

Forgot to say that the 8 speed cassette won't fit on the 7 speed freehub. If you remove one cog, you might need a spacer instead. Not sure of the exact numbers, but check Sheldon Brown's site, he has all the details.

Thanks for that info, I will go to his site and have a look. I may have to buy a better 7 speed cassette or dismantle one of the old 8s.

Well, I'm glad I waited. The lady brought the bike over today and surprise, surprise, a 7 speed spin-on 14-34 Mega Range Freewheel!! :eek:

I ordered a Shimano MF HG50 11-28 7speed freewheel from the LBS. :cool:

I decided to offer her a speed option:
a pair of 650c "training wheels",
the Front, a Deep-V with a Conti Gator Skin, 650x23,
the Rear, a road rim on a Deore hub with a Conti GP, 650x23
use the 11-32, 8 speed MTB cassette, the 32 tooth not selectable,
this will make one horny ladies MTB/Tri-training bike! :D