Go Back   Cycling Forums » Bikes » Cycling Equipment
Cycling Equipment Need some advice on cycling equipment? Do you have a buckled wheel? Problems with your gears? Need help truing a wheel?













customized 10 speed mountain cassette

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1  
Old 07-23.-2009
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Roswell, GA
Posts: 336
Rep Power: 3
rparedes is on a distinguished road
Default customized 10 speed mountain cassette

Now that SRAM has a 10 speed 11/34 cassette (VERY expensive) has anybody tried modifying a 9 speed cassette to convert to 10 speed?
i read somewhere you can take a SRAM 9 speed 11/34, add a 30 tooth cog, customize the spacer width and get a 10 speed mountain cassette for road bike.
Anybody tried?
BTW, I'm also aware of JTEK shiftmate to convert 10 speed shifters to work with 9 speed cassettes, but just curious to know if anybody has tried the 10 speed route.
I have 9 speed 11/34 SRAM with all cogs loose so it would be question of finding a 30 tooth cog (where to buy?) and somehow getting narrower spacers. ( I also already have a mountain shimano LX RD)

Thanks!
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 07-29.-2009
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Roswell, GA
Posts: 336
Rep Power: 3
rparedes is on a distinguished road
Default Re: customized 10 speed mountain cassette

Quote:
Originally Posted by rparedes View Post
Now that SRAM has a 10 speed 11/34 cassette (VERY expensive) has anybody tried modifying a 9 speed cassette to convert to 10 speed?
i read somewhere you can take a SRAM 9 speed 11/34, add a 30 tooth cog, customize the spacer width and get a 10 speed mountain cassette for road bike.
Anybody tried?
BTW, I'm also aware of JTEK shiftmate to convert 10 speed shifters to work with 9 speed cassettes, but just curious to know if anybody has tried the 10 speed route.
I have 9 speed 11/34 SRAM with all cogs loose so it would be question of finding a 30 tooth cog (where to buy?) and somehow getting narrower spacers. ( I also already have a mountain shimano LX RD)

Thanks!
Nobody?
Reply With Quote


  #3  
Old 07-29.-2009
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,828
Rep Power: 7
alfeng is on a distinguished road
Default Re: customized 10 speed mountain cassette

Okay ...

The few times I've restacked a cassette it was to add a bigger cog onto an existing cassette ...

For example, I added a 28t to someone's 8-speed 12-24 stack ...

I added a 32t to one of my 12-27, 9-speed Ultegra cassettes.

I added a 26t to a 12-23, 9-speed Chorus stack that I have. On this particular cassette, I also changed the smallest cog to an 11t.

In all cases, I found it was easier to simply add the "appropriate" cog onto a given stack and then subtract one of the intermediate cogs in the 14-to-17 range.

THAT's my way of saying that if I were looking for a DIY 10-speed MTB cassette (vs. using a 10-speed IRD cassette) that I would start with a 10-speed Shimano ROAD cassette & piggyback a 9-speed 32t-or-34t LX cog onto the back end rather than trying to take a 9-speed MTB cassette & shave the spacers to the smaller width.

N.B. I found that an 8-tooth difference in tooth count in adjacent cogs was easily managed with Shimano rear derailleurs ... and, apparently, based on SRAM's gappy MTB stack & Shimano's MEGA-stack cassettes, my observation is not unique ...

I've only piggyback ONE cog onto the end of a stack; but, I guess I wouldn't have too many qualms about stacking a 30t + 34t on a xx-24/25/26/whatever 10-speed cassette.

Either a 'lone' 32t or a 'lone' 34t stacked on a 11-27 cassette would definitely work if it is just a bailout cog.

Of course, you need to decide which of the intermediate cogs you want to eliminate ... the 'extra' 10-speed spacer will be sandwiched between the "regular" cassette & the piggybacked 9-speed cog.
Reply With Quote


  #4  
Old 07-30.-2009
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Roswell, GA
Posts: 336
Rep Power: 3
rparedes is on a distinguished road
Default Re: customized 10 speed mountain cassette

Quote:
Originally Posted by alfeng View Post
Okay ...

The few times I've restacked a cassette it was to add a bigger cog onto an existing cassette ...

For example, I added a 28t to someone's 8-speed 12-24 stack ...

I added a 32t to one of my 12-27, 9-speed Ultegra cassettes.

I added a 26t to a 12-23, 9-speed Chorus stack that I have. On this particular cassette, I also changed the smallest cog to an 11t.

In all cases, I found it was easier to simply add the "appropriate" cog onto a given stack and then subtract one of the intermediate cogs in the 14-to-17 range.

THAT's my way of saying that if I were looking for a DIY 10-speed MTB cassette (vs. using a 10-speed IRD cassette) that I would start with a 10-speed Shimano ROAD cassette & piggyback a 9-speed 32t-or-34t LX cog onto the back end rather than trying to take a 9-speed MTB cassette & shave the spacers to the smaller width.

N.B. I found that an 8-tooth difference in tooth count in adjacent cogs was easily managed with Shimano rear derailleurs ... and, apparently, based on SRAM's gappy MTB stack & Shimano's MEGA-stack cassettes, my observation is not unique ...

I've only piggyback ONE cog onto the end of a stack; but, I guess I wouldn't have too many qualms about stacking a 30t + 34t on a xx-24/25/26/whatever 10-speed cassette.

Either a 'lone' 32t or a 'lone' 34t stacked on a 11-27 cassette would definitely work if it is just a bailout cog.

Of course, you need to decide which of the intermediate cogs you want to eliminate ... the 'extra' 10-speed spacer will be sandwiched between the "regular" cassette & the piggybacked 9-speed cog.
Thanks!
I've read a lot about IRD cassettes; they don't work.
The cassettes I have (10 speed) seem to have the last three cogs (biggest ) all in one assembly... so just break them apart?
Reply With Quote


  #5  
Old 07-30.-2009
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,828
Rep Power: 7
alfeng is on a distinguished road
Default Re: customized 10 speed mountain cassette

Quote:
Originally Posted by rparedes View Post
I've read a lot about IRD cassettes; they don't work.
The cassettes I have (10 speed) seem to have the last three cogs (biggest ) all in one assembly... so just break them apart?
Let me try this again ...

Because I wanted lower gearing, I piggybacked a larger cog onto an existing stack ...

So, presuming you have one of the following 10-speed Shimano cassettes:
11-21
11-/12-23
12-25
12-27
Then I would add the following cogs from a 9-speed LX cassette & probably choose the following stacks:
11-21 .~~~~~~26 30 34 --> 11-13-15-17~~~~~~~~~.18-19-21.~~~~~~26 30 34
11-/12-23~~~~30 34.. .. --> 11-/12-13-14-15-17~~~.19-21-23~~~~~~.30 34
12-25~~~~~~~30 34 . ...--> 12-13-15-17-19~~~~~~~21-23-25~~~~~~.30 34
12-27~~~~~~~30 34 . ...--> 12-13-15-17-19~~~~~~~21-24-27~~~~~~.30 34

12-27~~~~~~~32 . ... ~~--> 12-13-14-16-17-19~~~~.21-24-27~~~~~~.32

etc.
You might prefer to omit different intermediate cogs.

You could probably re-stack an 11-21 with just a 30t bailout cog ...

The fewer the number of cogs you piggyback onto the back end, the better the indexing will be -- if you only add one cog, then the shifting should still be perfect ... two cogs, & you may-or-may-not want to reduce the thickness of the last spacer by an infinitesimal amount (draw a flat file lightly across it once-or-twice) OR both by an even lesser amount ... three cogs could become problematic unless the thickness of one-or-two of the spacers is reduced.

I don't know how good-or-bad IRD cassettes actually are since I don't have one; but, I would always presume that a Shimano cassette would shift smoother than any of the others since everyone else is playing catch-up with Shimano's R&D with regard to ramping (and/or pinning when including chainrings in the discussion).
Reply With Quote


  #6  
Old 07-30.-2009
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Roswell, GA
Posts: 336
Rep Power: 3
rparedes is on a distinguished road
Default Re: customized 10 speed mountain cassette

Quote:
Originally Posted by alfeng View Post
Let me try this again ...

Because I wanted lower gearing, I piggybacked a larger cog onto an existing stack ...

So, presuming you have one of the following 10-speed Shimano cassettes:
11-21
11-/12-23
12-25
12-27
Then I would add the following cogs from a 9-speed LX cassette & probably choose the following stacks:
11-21 .~~~~~~26 30 34 --> 11-13-15-17~~~~~~~~~.18-19-21.~~~~~~26 30 34
11-/12-23~~~~30 34.. .. --> 11-/12-13-14-15-17~~~.19-21-23~~~~~~.30 34
12-25~~~~~~~30 34 . ...--> 12-13-15-17-19~~~~~~~21-23-25~~~~~~.30 34
12-27~~~~~~~30 34 . ...--> 12-13-15-17-19~~~~~~~21-24-27~~~~~~.30 34

12-27~~~~~~~32 . ... ~~--> 12-13-14-16-17-19~~~~.21-24-27~~~~~~.32

etc.
You might prefer to omit different intermediate cogs.

You could probably re-stack an 11-21 with just a 30t bailout cog ...

The fewer the number of cogs you piggyback onto the back end, the better the indexing will be -- if you only add one cog, then the shifting should still be perfect ... two cogs, & you may-or-may-not want to reduce the thickness of the last spacer by an infinitesimal amount (draw a flat file lightly across it once-or-twice) OR both by an even lesser amount ... three cogs could become problematic unless the thickness of one-or-two of the spacers is reduced.

I don't know how good-or-bad IRD cassettes actually are since I don't have one; but, I would always presume that a Shimano cassette would shift smoother than any of the others since everyone else is playing catch-up with Shimano's R&D with regard to ramping (and/or pinning when including chainrings in the discussion).
Thank you! Very clear explanation
This is really easier than what I expected. I'll try it this weekend. I'll be modifying a 12/15... We'll see how it goes.
Reply With Quote


  #7  
Old 08-03.-2009
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Roswell, GA
Posts: 336
Rep Power: 3
rparedes is on a distinguished road
Default Re: customized 10 speed mountain cassette

Quote:
Originally Posted by alfeng View Post
Let me try this again ...

Because I wanted lower gearing, I piggybacked a larger cog onto an existing stack ...

So, presuming you have one of the following 10-speed Shimano cassettes:
11-21
11-/12-23
12-25
12-27
Then I would add the following cogs from a 9-speed LX cassette & probably choose the following stacks:
11-21 .~~~~~~26 30 34 --> 11-13-15-17~~~~~~~~~.18-19-21.~~~~~~26 30 34
11-/12-23~~~~30 34.. .. --> 11-/12-13-14-15-17~~~.19-21-23~~~~~~.30 34
12-25~~~~~~~30 34 . ...--> 12-13-15-17-19~~~~~~~21-23-25~~~~~~.30 34
12-27~~~~~~~30 34 . ...--> 12-13-15-17-19~~~~~~~21-24-27~~~~~~.30 34

12-27~~~~~~~32 . ... ~~--> 12-13-14-16-17-19~~~~.21-24-27~~~~~~.32

etc.
You might prefer to omit different intermediate cogs.

You could probably re-stack an 11-21 with just a 30t bailout cog ...

The fewer the number of cogs you piggyback onto the back end, the better the indexing will be -- if you only add one cog, then the shifting should still be perfect ... two cogs, & you may-or-may-not want to reduce the thickness of the last spacer by an infinitesimal amount (draw a flat file lightly across it once-or-twice) OR both by an even lesser amount ... three cogs could become problematic unless the thickness of one-or-two of the spacers is reduced.

I don't know how good-or-bad IRD cassettes actually are since I don't have one; but, I would always presume that a Shimano cassette would shift smoother than any of the others since everyone else is playing catch-up with Shimano's R&D with regard to ramping (and/or pinning when including chainrings in the discussion).
Running into a problem. I took a 10 speed 12/27 shimano cassette, removed the 13 tooth cog and added a 30 tooth cog next to the 27. I could not make it fit. (Mavik Aksium wheelset with factory spacer for shimano). The new 30 tooth cog is a flat profile whereas the original 27 tooth cog has a slight recess that lets it sit farther into the hub...
Am I doing it right? Do I remove the Mavik spacer? Do I need a longer lock ring?

Thanks!
Reply With Quote


  #8  
Old 08-03.-2009
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,828
Rep Power: 7
alfeng is on a distinguished road
Default Re: customized 10 speed mountain cassette

Quote:
Originally Posted by rparedes View Post
Running into a problem. I took a 10 speed 12/27 shimano cassette, removed the 13 tooth cog and added a 30 tooth cog next to the 27. I could not make it fit. (Mavik Aksium wheelset with factory spacer for shimano). The new 30 tooth cog is a flat profile whereas the original 27 tooth cog has a slight recess that lets it sit farther into the hub...
Am I doing it right? Do I remove the Mavik spacer? Do I need a longer lock ring?
Yes, I think you simply need to remove the MAVIC spacer from the freehub body to get the DIY cassette to fit properly.

The spacer probably/undoubtedly compensates for the slight recess in the cassette's spider ... and, removing it will allow the single cog to 'sit' in the same plane as the 27t cog formerly/(currently) sat/(sits) in.

You should not need a longer lock ring.
Reply With Quote


  #9  
Old 08-03.-2009
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,828
Rep Power: 7
alfeng is on a distinguished road
Default Re: customized 10 speed mountain cassette

BTW. You may need to tweak the stops & indexing because you will have theoretically bumped the cassette outward by a fraction of a millimeter (~0.18mm?) ... it might be fractionally more-or-less because I don't know how thick that MAVIC spacer that you remove is.

The function of the spacer is to ensure that certain cassettes like your 12-27 don't sit too close to the spokes and thereby cause the chain to be too close to the spokes when the chain is on the largest cog.
Reply With Quote


Reply

Bookmarks

Tags
cassette, customized, mountain, speed

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:43 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin Copyright © 2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0
Copyright © 2001 - 2009 cyclingforums.com

Translations (powered by Google):
Bulgarian Croatian Czech Danish Dutch English Finnish French German Italian Japanese Korean Norwegian Polish Portuguese Spanish Swedish