AndyP wrote:
> From the tents I've used it seems to me the one advantage of outer first
> pitching, ie keeping the inner tent dry when it's tipping down, is of use
> only rarely because with a quick pitching inner first tent it'll stay dry
> enough to not be a problem even in moderate rain.
That's one. Another is being able to take down the inner and get twice
as many muddy people inside for a chinwag without your gear getting
filthy. Another is the option of leaving the inner behind and using the
outer alone as a ground hugging tarp with its own poles and guys.
Another is taking the tent down and packing all your gear in the dry
over as long as you want if it's raining when you want to strike.
> The advantages of inner
> first pitching on the other hand are apparent every time you use the tent.
> The advantages of inner first pitching for me are being easier to put up
> because you don't have to crawl under the flysheet and mess with fiddly
> attachments and producing a more pleasant living environment because the
> inner is held taut by the poles and doesn't sag all over the place.
This rather misses the point that the Akto is a fly and inner pitch
/together/ tent though, so the above "problems" are moot in any case.
My Tarra pitches both together and I spend zero time clipping up the
inner and the inner is nice and taught. So once again, how would it be
better if it pitched inner first?
My Snowcat has to have the inner clipped up separately, but I don't go
"crawling under the flysheet", I just sit inside the spacious flysheet
once it's been pitched and clip some clips. And since the clips are
along the pole sleeves the inner is held taught and doesn't sag all over
the place.
> you were mystified. Generally I'm pretty sceptical about "all in one"
> pitching. I had use of one that you could do that with but figured
> separating the inner and outer was less hassle and better to pack that way.
Works very nicely on the Tarra, which is much quicker and easier to
pitch than a Quasar btw. Especially on those occasions where people are
trying to thread the poles while the flysheet's piled on top of
everything so it stays out of the rain, but even without that the
external poles and clip system are much easier to use than the sleeve
system used on most inner pitch tents.
Most of the issues raised aren't fundamental to the fact the tent
pitches fly, inner or both first, it's design touches beyond that. And
since you /can/ have non-saggy space in a fly first or both together
pitch, and more flexible use of inner space too, I'm still mystified as
to why people think inner first is a fundamentally better idea...
Pete.
--
Peter Clinch Medical Physics IT Officer
Tel 44 1382 660111 ext. 33637 Univ. of Dundee, Ninewells Hospital
Fax 44 1382 640177 Dundee DD1 9SY Scotland UK
net
[email protected] http://www.dundee.ac.uk/~pjclinch/