Battle of the cheap forks



CraneCamsOU

New Member
Aug 16, 2003
3
0
0
I have an '03 Rincon, and am looking to replace the ****ty stock RST Cappa.

Background info: I am 6'3" and 200lbs. Therefore, I need a stiff shock. Also, I am a novice (at best) cross country/trail rider, and I do not plan to buy a more competative bike later on.

The rules:
1) Must be less than $300
2) Bang for the buck is a big deal for poor folk like me.

I have found three forks to compare, if you have another suggestion please let me know.




-----Manitou Black Sport----
These 100mm travel Manitou Black Sport forks are ideal for use on your long-travel cross-country or trailbike. Coil springs in tandem with Manitou's Fluid Flow damping produce silky smooth travel, while the Reverse Arch magnesium cast lowers keep the front end stiff and tracking straight and true.
Features externally adjustable preload and rebound, as well as a lockout knob so you can climb without bobbing then let 'er rip on the downhills.
This fork offers 74mm post mounts for disc brakes. 1 1/8" threadless steerer fits most modern mountain bikes.

Travel: 100 mm
Weight: 4.3 pounds, uncut steerer
Spring: Coil
Adjustments: Preload, Rebound, Lockout
Stanchion Tubes: 30mm Aluminum

$200




----RockShox Pilot XC----
The 2003 Pilot XC from Rock Shox is a sweet cross-country fork utilizing a single sided coil spring with air assist. The positive air pressure is adjustable via schrader valve so you can tune the fork to precisely suit your weight.
The Pilot XC inherits SID inspired magnesium lower legs that are lightweight and stiff. The crown is a lightweight aluminum forging, while the HC2 damping offers a broad linear adjustment range with a dramatic reduction in fade. 28mm chromed steel upper tubes run butter smooth without the need for boots. Chromoly steerer tube is super strong.
Fork features both V-Brake® and international standard disc brake mounts. Max tire size 2.1". 1 1/8" steerer fits most modern mountain bikes.


Travel: 80/100 mm via internal spacer
Weight: 4.38 lbs (uncut steerer tube)
Spring: Coil with air assist
Adjustments: Internal HC2 damping, positive air pressure
Stanchion Tubes: Chromed steel

$149

-




------Answer Manitou '03 Axel Comp ATB Fork-------

This fork is an outstanding value for the sport rider and entry level racer. 28.6mm Cromoly stanchions with Manitou's exclusive Magnesium RA outers and forged aluminum crown with black satin anodized finish. Extras include convertible travel from 80 to 100mm, preload adjustment, externally adjustable Fluid Flow damping and Microlube port. Steel steer tube. 4.2 lbs.
$129




And there you have it.
Thank you all for you time and your help.

Chris.
 
Chris,
I am a Marzocchi ***** so you need to consider the source, but you can find used Marzocchis on ebay or at your LBS. I have seen Z-3 QR 20 Marzocchis sell on there for well under $300. Two years ago I bought a used QR 20 fork for one of my bikes for $225. Worked great until someone stole it (probably still works great for that POS that took it). If stiff is what you want then nothing will beat a 20mm drop-out. Manitou makes the new Sherman line and it kicks much ass! I've ridden one and it made me think about leaving Marzocchi; it was nice. I have not seen them sell for less than $450 though. I would really advise you to stay away from Rock Shox. They have not made a stiff fork for a couple of years (other than the Tulio, which sucked as a fork) (I know, I know, half of you are riding Rock Shox and love them-doesn't make them relatively stiff though).

Bottom line: You can get a great deal on a used fork. You should save 30%-60% (depending on model and age). You will get so much more for your money it's crazy. Even if you need to replace the seals (often you don't have to, but it's always a good idea to overhaul a fork when you buy used) and oil you are only in it for an extra $20 or $30 bucks if you do it yourself. Anyone with even a clue about tools can service nearly any fork out there and both Marzocchi and Manitou have great tech manuals on the web.

Hey, I just checked out ebay and they had at least 10 Marzocchi forks that would work for you and 10 or 15 Manitous. They were all under $300 and would be better bets than the ones you mentioned or were ones you mentioned, but cheaper than the prices you listed. Good luck and keep the rubber side down.

K.
 
Hey, thanks for the advise. I'll check out ebay.

If anybody else has an opinion on this, please let me know.

Thanks

Chris.
 

Similar threads