Handlebar bags vs. frame bags vs. saddlebags – best setup for gravel?



WishIhadthelegs

New Member
Dec 25, 2003
48
0
6
As a cycling enthusiast, Ive always been fascinated by the various ways to optimize my gravel riding experience, specifically when it comes to luggage setup. Ive seen many cyclists use handlebar bags, frame bags, and saddlebags, and Im curious to hear your thoughts on the best setup for gravel riding.

Before we dive into the specifics, lets define each type of bag:

1. Handlebar bags: These bags are mounted on the handlebars and provide quick access to items like snacks, tools, and maps.
2. Frame bags: These bags are inserted inside the main triangle of the frame and are great for carrying heavier items like water bottles, extra tubes, and pumps.
3. Saddlebags: These bags are mounted under the saddle and are useful for carrying lighter items like clothing, shoes, and valuables.

Now, lets explore the pros and cons of each type of bag for gravel riding:

1. Handlebar bags:

Pros:
- Easy access to items
- Can be used to store frequently used items
- Relatively inexpensive

Cons:
- Can interfere with braking and shifting
- Can affect bike handling, especially on rough terrain
- May not be suitable for larger items

2. Frame bags:

Pros:
- Can carry heavier items
- Low center of gravity helps with bike handling
- Protects items from dirt and debris

Cons:
- May be difficult to install and remove
- Limited space, depending on the frame size
- Can be expensive

3. Saddlebags:

Pros:
- Low center of gravity helps with bike handling
- Can carry lighter items like clothing and valuables
- Easy to install and remove

Cons:
- Limited space
- May affect saddle comfort on longer rides
- Can be difficult to access while riding

With the above considerations in mind, Im curious to hear your thoughts on the following question:

What is the ideal setup for gravel riding when it comes to handlebar bags, frame bags, and saddlebags? Is there a specific configuration that youve found to be most effective for carrying items while maximizing bike handling and performance?