My son just turned 6 and has outgrown his first bike. Since he's just about 4 feet tall, we've been told that a 20" wheel would be the most appropriate size for him, until he reaches 5 feet. My question is this: Are the bikes that one can purchase from the big box stores -- Wal*Mart, Target, Toys R Us -- significantly enough inferior to or somehow more "unsafe" than what one could buy from an independent bike shop that there would be a concern that the bike would not last long enough for my son to outgrow it? I'm concerned about shelling out money for a product that a 6 year old is going to be using and eventually outgrowing, much the way I would feel about buying a toddler designer label clothes that get outgrown too fast and stained on first use. I'm interested in reading what others have to say, thanks.
Featured Sponsors
Recent Reviews
-
I use this pedal for commuting to work and it's great for all the clipping in and out for traffic lights. But, I also use this pedal on my road racing bike that I use for gran fondos. Versatile...
-
I originally purchased the Red with my kit. I was constantly messing with the front D. Then I purchased the "YAW" derailleur and all my problems went away. Don't get the straight Red..get the...
-
I don't have the 50's but I do have the 35's and I have put them through the gambit of crap...including hitting the top of my garage with the bike on the rack...wheel first. I have not had to do...
-
Amazing. What else can I say to describe something as lifeless and deadshit boring as a simple inner tube? These are exactly what you'd expect. They hold air until you puncture, pinch flat, let...
-
Its great this product is no longer made, it was a complete waste of money and should have been recalled. I no longer trust any products Polar make.
Purchasing Advice -- Kid's Bike
- davereo
- Trader Feedback: 0
- Registered User
- offline
- 1,655 Posts. Joined 6/2010
- Select All Posts By This User
Good question.
If you buy a big box store bike I highly recommend that you double check all the fasteners to insure they are properly tightened. I would also recommend that you select a bike with pedal and hand brakes for a little added safety. Stay away from multiple speed bikes because they generally have very low grade components which wont stand up long to the abuse of a kid.
The LBS (local bike shop) route will give you a higher quality bike for around three times the price. The bike will be better assembled and built with higher quality components. The LBS can also help you select the proper size bike for son.
If your son is indeed tall enough for a 20" bike he could very well be riding that bike until he is old enough to drive. My grandson is six years old and I have him riding a 16" Spyderman bike which he will still be riding for at least two more summers. When he grows into the 20" we will be getting him his first bike from the LBS.
If you have the means involve your son in the bike selection. Kids tend to use things they decide on more than things they don't. And yes kids like having the same and better than their friends.
This is a great age for kids to get into cycling. Good Luck and enjoy.
Cycling is a sport. Bicycles are also very popular as a kids toy. If your trying to introduce the child to one of the "cycling sports" he/she will need the proper equipment. Cycling isn't the most expensive sport... but it ain't cheap ether.
However... if the child is just getting another toy. I think the toy and/or big box stores sell fine toy bikes.
- oldbobcat
- Trader Feedback: 0
- Registered User
- offline
- 1,891 Posts. Joined 8/2003
- Location: Boulder County, Colorado
- Select All Posts By This User

My question is this: Are the bikes that one can purchase from the big box stores -- Wal*Mart, Target, Toys R Us -- significantly enough inferior to or somehow more "unsafe" than what one could buy from an independent bike shop that there would be a concern that the bike would not last long enough for my son to outgrow it?
In a word, yes. Well, if you're looking at cruisers with coaster brakes, some of the big-box bikes aren't all that bad. I got my daughter a 20" Next that she rode pretty enthusiastically, and it held up well enough to bring a few bucks at a yard sale.
But as soon as you get into hand brakes, derailleurs, and shifters, the difference is significant. Bikes that are maintainable and repairable beat something with bolt heads that round or break off, and threads that strip.
At bike shops there are some good buys, though. Raleigh is moving aggressively into family biking, and their products are significantly less expensive than, say, Trek or Specialized. The quality and fit are good, although some of the issues like gearing aren't as well thought out. And they still beat the big box bikes by a mile. Ask shops if there is a kids' bike trade-up program, too. We offer it and it's well used.
I have also made good experience with kids bikes from a department store. My nephew has got one for his birthday last year and he's fine with it. when it comes to safety, I think you can always expect a basically good standard with the products. However, if the bike is used more for a difficult cycling tour, it is a good idea to "pimp" the bike with extra equipment. And I think, it is also important that the child - no matter how you he or she is - should have a say in the decision on the bike to be bought because the child can test whether he or she feels comfortable with it and can handle it.
- maydog
- Trader Feedback: 0
- Registered User
- offline
- 620 Posts. Joined 2/2010
- Location: Minnesota
- Select All Posts By This User
I am of the notion to spend a bit more than average on my kids bikes. When my oldest daughter was 6, I bought her a Specialized Hotrock ($260) with rim brakes and 6 gears. She learned how to use it in a matter of minutes. My oldest son was riding without training wheels before his third birthday, I bought him a performance burnout ($200) when he was 5, he loves it and at 6 can ride circles around older neighborhood boys.
He did have a Trek Jet 16 before that, its an OK bike - but not really and better than the big-box coaster brake bikes.
- oldbobcat
- Trader Feedback: 0
- Registered User
- offline
- 1,891 Posts. Joined 8/2003
- Location: Boulder County, Colorado
- Select All Posts By This User
I used to assemble bikes at Wal~Mart, and now I work for a Trek dealer. I had Huffys that came apart on the bench. Next was actually pretty good brand. The Trek Jet may be overkill, but it's a bike that can be passed down to several little brothers and then sold at a garage sale.
I recommend Mongoose Override 20" Boys' Freestyle Bike. It's a 20" bike. This is made of high tensil steel. Perfect for your little boy. It is a New boys bike in the market.
- Purchasing Advice -- Kid's Bike
Recent Discussions
- › Returning to Cycling After a Lengthy Break (~ 6 months) 11 minutes ago
- › Going out now, because I don't feel like it. 1 hour, 53 minutes ago
- › It's killing me but.......... 2 hours, 14 minutes ago
- › The Thread about Nothing.... 2 hours, 34 minutes ago
- › eBay foibles and follies... 2 hours, 38 minutes ago
- › 2013 Giro d'Italia - stage results 1-21 2 hours, 38 minutes ago
- › First bike buy in 15 years... 3 hours, 18 minutes ago
- › Heartburn while riding didn't have to do with food 5 hours, 47 minutes ago
- › What is the difference in entry level bikes ? 5 hours, 55 minutes ago
- › Shimano best to worst list 6 hours, 10 minutes ago
Recent Reviews
- › Shimano XT PD-M780 Mountain Pedals by OTownRaider
- › Sram Red Front Derailleur by wbkski
- › Shimano WH-7900-C50-CL Wheelset by wbkski
- › Vittoria Inner Tubes by gplama
- › Polar Power Kit by steve
- › Canondale CAAD10-3 Ultegra by Dan McCormack
- › ProForm Le Tour De France (2012 Model) by Fatlands Rider
- › Scott CR1 by San Remo GT
- › VDO X3DW Wireless Computer by pada
- › Specialized S-Works Tarmac SL3 SRAM by Mark 86
New Articles
- › Electric Bike Australia Laws Changing from... by ChrisRider
- › Cycling Forums Facebook Sweepstakes Rules... by mmckay
- › Rules and Regulations for DeathRow Velo... by mmckay
- › Rules and Regulations for Preformance Bicycle... by shawea
- › amgen-a-tour-of-california-host-cities-announced by Born2bWild
- › chrome-introduces-city-series-with-london-tri... by Born2bWild
- › Groups Guidelines by steve
- › 2011 Roster Announced Feat 3 Time Champ Levi... by ranjanis
- › Volunteers Needed For The 2011 Amgen Tour Of... by ranjanis
- › Stage 5 Route Update For The 2011 Tour Of... by ranjanis
About Cycling Forums | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Cycling Forums is powered by Huddler Active Outdoors | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map




