Well, now, I'd say why on earth, Lumpy, my friend, are you wasting your precious time arguing with a bunch of cretins? Is it too cold to ride where you are, because otherwise i can't see you getting sucked into such an innane (sp?) debate.
What causes more wear and tear on your foot? On a wad of play-doh or silly putty? On a newspaper? On a porcelain plate? Which distorts (obliterates) these items more? A car or a bike? These people are knotheads.
As my Dad would ask before formulating his official opinion on any situation, is there alcohol involved? Meaning durin this on-going debate (ie does it tend to take place after consumption of tasty beverage?).
Experience shows the answer to this question will tell you most of what you need to know.
They're idiots, spring is almost here, you'll forget this very soon, you'll be back in the saddle again...
Sara