v brakes versus disc brakes????

bluescat

We are thinking of getting a Giant Cypress DX or LX, the difference is whether or not we want the disc or regular brakes? Any suggestions? We will be riding primarily on the paved bike paths in DC and area parks. Any suggestions/reasons for one over the other would be appreciated!
Judi

Telegram Sam

Not being a mountain bike guy, I have to say that I dont like disk brakes. The reason for them (apparently) is that they are out of the muck when you ride in dirt. My problem with them is that I have trouble with the modulation and feedback. With V-brakes...which do a fantastic job of stopping...I feel I have more control of how much pressure I apply to the brakes. I also feel that I can sense how the bike is going to behave better. With disk brakes, there is an "all or none" feeling. This problem is corrected in higher end disks, especially hydraulic ones, but I think for the kind of riding you intend to do, the v-brakes are going to be better.
Of course, ride them both and see what feels better- I tried to like the disks because they look so cool...But when I get in over my head and need to feather the brakes going down a hill, the v's have a better feel (thats why high-end road bikes haven't gone disk yet I'm sure)
Cheers

__________________
may the wind take your troubles away...

bluescat

Thanks, Sam!
I think we are going with the V-brake! The disc brakes do look cool tho!
But I agree with you on the feel! Thanks for your response!
Judi

chispa60

Aside from what's been mentioned, disc brakes also have the advantage of more stopping power. However, they are heavy compared to V brakes and also are a bit harder to maintain.

Meanwhile, V brakes are naturally lighter and can provide adequte braking power for most people.

But all that is mute until you consider what your bike usage is. For instance, disc brakes would be a good choice on full suspension mountain bikes which would be used to go on trails (and off trails) even during the rain season. Being away from the rim means that the braking surface will probably be "cleaner" and thus more effective.

Similarly, disc brakes would be good on heavy duty commuter bikes in big cities where you need to stop very quickly to avoid a car (or the more common car door opening). Besides, some heavy duty commuters load up on panniers to stuff a change of clothes and even business (or study) related materials.

Meanwhile, V-brakes would be suited for touring bikes or even cyclocross bikes. Or even for the everyday user who is more concerned about weight. Note that weight will effect how much more you will be fatigued after a good long ride.