Campag with Sram RD

Peter@vecchios

Lennard Zinn came in yesterday with something interesting..Centaur levers, Sram Force front and rear derailleurs and Sram 10s cogset, shimano chain and it shifted..just fine. So it appears Campag ERGO(including 2007/8 Centaur and below) shifts shimano/sram 10s spacing with a Rival/Force/Red RD..The 'limited' left Centaur shifter seemed to shift the Force FD fine also, with less effort than Sram...


" the sram engineer takes the long walk in the woods, alone, afraid...a single shot is heard.....he thought noncompatibility was assured but........."

sogood

Was that bike called Frankenstein?

__________________
Morphed Bianchi Camaleonte IV 2006, Ridley Damocles 2006, Garmin, Mac

alfeng

Well, THAT is definitely interesting ...

Was the rear derailleur cable hooked up "normally" OR at 9 o'clock (i.e., akin to Shimano's alternate anchor position)?

Regardless, it just proves that the 10-speed Campagnolo ERGO shifters may be the "perfect" shifters because they are apparently universally compatible with ALL indexed drivetrains!

Phill P

how does this work when sram has a different cable pull requirement to shimano and campy, and because of spacing and rear geometry shimano and campy don't work together.

front is easy, campy have the best design here, works with anything.

rear the brifter would pull too much cable surely!

__________________
******BLATANT ADVERTISING ALERT******
I have ceramic bearings for:
Campy/Fulcrum high end hubs/wheels
Shimano hubs and pedals
check out my ebay items here

alfeng

Au contraire, mon ami ... 10-speed Campy shifters work very well with Shimano drivetrains ... 8-and-9-speed.

And, my previous reckoning was that the 10-speed Campagnolo shifter should be able to mate with a 10-speed Shimano shifter to index with a 10-speed Shimano cassette IF the rear derailleur cable were hooked up using the hubbub.com alternate anchor position which was originally described to allow a 10-speed Campagnolo shifter to mate with a 9-speed Shimano rear derailleur & cassette.

So, based on Zinn's demonstration, I presume that the attachment point for the SRAM rear derailleur, directly-or-modified, equates to the 10-speed Shimano rear derailleur with the hubbub.com attachment.
Yes.
I would have thought the same thing (and, I certainly had zero-intention of buying a SRAM rear derailleur to find out its limitations), but APPARENTLY NOT!

Peter@vecchios

Actually, for Sram, it goes around a l;ittle ramp and then on top of the fixing bolt. Cable hooked normally.

Peter@vecchios

Don't call me Shirley(teeny joke)..saw the bike shifted it and it worked fine. Don't know why but there has always been lots more intercompatibility than the manufacturers let on or even know.