What about just the regular one? Haha, but all in all, I think it just matters if it's padded or not, I'd rather not have my upper thighs on fire because of the friction from pedaling and not being able to get comfortable at the long ride because you are sitting on metal. I got one once, and it gave me lower back pain for two days, and I had to switch it with a pretty soft one with extra padding for the long trips. I think that would fix the problem for most bikes, but then again it costs more money.