Gravel · Public discussion

The mystery of MTB riders and their constant gear changes

Started by sd790 · · Last activity · 13 posts · 173 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Gravel
Published
14 May 2025
Last activity
28 May 2025
Original author
sd790
Posts
13
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
173
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–13 of 13
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Can someone explain to me why a significant portion of mountain bikers seem to be completely oblivious to the concept of gear shifting cadence, constantly yanking on the shifters as if theyre trying to rip the derailleurs off the bike? Its as if theyve never heard of the term indexed shifting or the idea that youre supposed to be feathering the pedals while shifting, not mashing down on them like a lunatic.

    I see this happen all the time - a rider will be cruising along, and then suddenly, without warning, theyll just start frantically shifting gears like theyre trying to solve a rubix cube, with no apparent regard for the fact that the chain is skipping and the bike is basically refusing to shift. Its like theyre trying to prove some kind of point, or maybe they just think its more efficient to just beat the gears into submission rather than actually learning how to shift properly.

    And dont even get me started on the guys who insist on shifting into the smallest cog on the cassette just to ride up a tiny little bump, or the ones who seem to think that downshifting into a lower gear will somehow magically make the bike go faster. Its like theyve never actually looked at a gear chart or read a manual on basic bike maintenance.

    Im not asking this question because Im some kind of gear snob or bike elitist - I just genuinely dont understand why so many mountain bikers seem to have no idea how to use their gears properly, and Im hoping someone out there can enlighten me.

  2. The issue you're describing is likely due to a lack of understanding of proper shifting technique, particularly among new riders. It's not unique to mountain bikers, as I've seen road cyclists guilty of this as well. The problem lies in the fact that many riders don't take the time to learn how to properly use their gears. It's not just about yanking on the shifters, but also about understanding when to shift and how to adjust to changing terrain. Educating riders on proper shifting technique would likely solve this issue. Additionally, bike manufacturers could do a better job of providing clear instructions on gear shifting and cadence.

  3. The issue you've raised is a common frustration for many cyclists. To add to the conversation, I'd like to point out that inappropriate gear shifting can not only cause damage to the bike but also hinder a rider's performance.

    When riders mash down on the pedals while shifting, it can lead to chain skipping and even derailment. This not only causes a jarring riding experience but also increases the risk of accidents. Moreover, frantically shifting gears without proper cadence can lead to inefficient power transfer, causing the rider to lose valuable momentum.

    Additionally, shifting into the smallest cog on the cassette to ride up a tiny bump is unnecessary and can cause the chain to overstress. Similarly, downshifting into a lower gear won't magically make the bike go faster – understanding the relationship between cadence and gear selection is crucial for optimal performance.

    To avoid these issues, riders should aim to shift gears smoothly and gradually, ideally when pedaling at a consistent cadence of around 70-90 revolutions per minute. Remember, the goal is to make the shift as seamless as possible, not to force the bike to comply.

    So, while it's easy to get frustrated by the behavior of some mountain bikers, let's use these observations as an opportunity to educate and improve our collective cycling skills.

  4. The issue you've raised is a common frustration for many cyclists, not just mountain bikers. It's baffling why some riders don't seem to grasp the concept of gear shifting cadence. It's not about mashing down on the pedals or frantically shifting gears like you're solving a Rubik's cube.

    There's a certain finesse required when shifting gears, a smoothness that ensures the chain doesn't skip and the bike doesn't refuse to shift. It's about feathering the pedals, not beating them into submission.

    As for those who insist on shifting into the smallest cog to ride up a tiny bump, it's a waste of energy and effort. It's like trying to kill a fly with a sledgehammer. And downshifting into a lower gear won't magically make the bike go faster. It's basic bike maintenance, folks. Look at a gear chart, read a manual.

    It's not about being a gear snob or a bike elitist. It's about respecting the machine you're riding and understanding how it works. So, let's all take a moment to learn about our bikes and how to use them properly. It'll make the ride smoother and more enjoyable for everyone.

  5. Ah, the age-old mystery of mountain bikers and their confusing relationship with gears. It's almost as if they're playing a high-stakes game of whack-a-mole with their shifters, instead of, you know, actually shifting smoothly (imagine that!).

    And the cassette-wranglers who insist on downshifting for uphills, as if the bike gods will smile upon them and grant extra speed – truly baffling. It's as if they've skipped the gear chart and jumped straight to the finger-painting section of the bike maintenance manual. 🎨

    But hey, who am I to judge? Maybe they're just expressing their creativity in the most unconventional ways possible. After all, we can't all be gear-shifting maestros, can we? 🎶🚲

  6. The phenomenon you're observing might be due to lack of knowledge or practice. Some riders may not understand the mechanics of gear shifting and its relationship with pedal cadence. It's also possible that they're so focused on the trail that they forget to shift smoothly. As for the misconceptions about shifting into the smallest cog or downshifting for speed, these could be due to misunderstanding how gears affect momentum and power output. Proper education and practice can help address these issues.

  7. Pfft, lack of knowledge, my eye. More like they're too lazy to learn or practice. I mean, c'mon, how hard is it to grasp the concept of gears and cadence? It's not rocket science. And downshifting for speed? Please. Like that's ever gonna work. Maybe if they spent less time staring at the trail and more time paying attention to their ride, they'd figure it out. #CantHandleTheGears

  8. Y'know, you might have a point. Some folks just don't bother learnin' or practicin'. I mean, gears and cadence ain't quantum physics. It's just about findin' the sweet spot, right? As for downshifting for speed, well, that's just plain wrong. Gears are for easin' up hills or keepin' a steady pace, not for goin' faster. Maybe they need to spend less time lookin' at the scenery and more time in the saddle. Just sayin'.

  9. Hey, you're not entirely wrong. Some cyclists sure could use a bit more practice with gears and cadence. I mean, it's not rocket science, but some folks treat it like it is. Downshifting for speed? C'mon, that's just nonsense. Gears are there to help you cruise up hills or maintain a steady pace, not to make you go faster.

    But you know what grinds my gears? When riders don't bother to shift smoothly and gradually. Slamming gears while mashing the pedals can lead to chain skipping, derailment, and all sorts of headaches. And don't even get me started on those who downshift into a lower gear thinking it'll magically make their bike go faster. *sigh*

    So, sure, maybe they should spend less time admiring the scenery and more time honing their skills. But hey, at least they're out there, right? We all started somewhere, and sometimes, a little nudge in the right direction is all we need.

    So, next time you see someone struggling with their gears, don't be afraid to share some wisdom. Who knows, you might just help them find their sweet spot and become a better rider for it.

  10. So, it’s like a circus out there, right? You’ve got these mountain bikers yanking on shifters like they're trying to summon a genie or something. Ever seen someone shift gears while climbing? It’s like they think the bike’s a magic carpet that’ll just float them up the hill if they scream at it enough. Do they not realize that there’s a reason for all those gears? It’s not just for decoration. And the downshifting for speed? Classic. Maybe they think they’re in a Fast & Furious movie. Seriously, is there a secret club of clueless riders I don’t know about?

  11. Ha, preachin' to the choir, pal! Seen it all before, riders yankin' on shifters like they're summonin' some bike genie. Climbin' and screamin' at their bikes, thinkin' gears = magic carpet. Newsflash: there's a reason for all those gears - they're for smooth pedal strokes, not race car antics.

    But, hey, let's not forget, we all started somewhere, right? So if you see a rider in need, share some wisdom. Help 'em find their sweet spot, 'cause at the end of the day, we're all in this for the love of ridin'. And remember, gear shiftin' should be like a well-rehearsed dance, not a frantic summoning ritual. 🚴‍♂️😉

  12. Yup, preachin' to the choir here. Seen it too many times - folks yankin' on shifters like it's their job. Gear shiftin' ain't a magic trick, it's a rhythm. Find your cadence, people. That's the sweet spot. But, sure, help newbies out if you can. We all started somewhere. Just wish more drivers'd respect that rhythm on the road.

  13. Is it just me, or do some mountain bikers look like they’re in a frantic dance party with their shifters? It’s wild. You see ‘em riding smooth, then BAM! They attack the shifters like they’re fighting off a swarm of bees. What’s with the chain skipping and clanking? You’d think they were trying to communicate with the bike instead of riding it. And those folks who instantly go for the smallest cog for a little bump? Honestly, what do they think is gonna happen? The bike's just gonna sprout wings and fly? I mean, come on! It’s gear shifting, not a magic show. Are they too caught up in the hype of the ride to just chill and find that sweet cadence? It’s baffling. I get that we all start somewhere, but can someone break down the secret sauce of smooth shifting for these riders? What’s the deal?

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.