10 speed front derailleur w/9-speed chain

[hawkk]

I am currently putting together a list of components for a frame. I
want to stay with 9-speed due to the fact I can use an SRAM chain that
can be removed by hand and cleaned easily. I want to use Shimano front
derailleur FD-6600. Will there be a compatibility issue between this
derailleur and the 9-speed chain? I'll be using STI 9-speed shifters.

Thanks

 

[Qui si parla Campagnolo]

hawkk wrote:
> I am currently putting together a list of components for a frame. I
> want to stay with 9-speed due to the fact I can use an SRAM chain that
> can be removed by hand and cleaned easily. I want to use Shimano front
> derailleur FD-6600. Will there be a compatibility issue between this
> derailleur and the 9-speed chain? I'll be using STI 9-speed shifters.
>
> Thanks

First, many 10s links to be iused with 10s chains ala Sram, Wipperman
chain and link, for instance, for 10s.

Second, 9s shimano FD work well with 10s shifters but not the other way
around. Your best performance would come with a shimano 9s FD, ala
6500. Not because of the chain but because of the arm length,
dimensions of the FD, that changed with shimano 10s. What you will find
that the travel of the 10s FD is not far enough with 9s. It will rub in
small ring, big cog combo and big ring and small cog combo...

 

[[email protected]]

hawkk wrote:
> want to stay with 9-speed due to the fact I can use an SRAM chain that
> can be removed by hand and cleaned easily.

There are 10 speed chains that can be removed by hand.

I just installed a KMC 10 speed chain using thier "Missing Link". They
say it's reusable, just don't use an old one with a new chain. It looks
pretty similar to the SRAM link, so should be alright I guess.

Anyway, I would think the narrower cage of the 10s front derailleur
would need trimming more often if you used it with a 9s chain. I
haven't tried it so I could be wrong, but even with a 10s chain my
FD-6600 needs more trimming than any of my 9s front derailleurs ever
did.

 

[Chris Z The Wheelman]

I have stubbornly stuck with seven speeds on my bikes, seeing no need
for more cogs than is necessary. The LX front derailer on my MTB is
rated as a a nine speed, and it shifts fine. just be sure the lever and
mech. ar matched.

Be warned though, that if you use an indexed front lever with only two
clicks (no fine adjustments), setting it will be finicky at best, as the
fit is tight. Or do what I did. Scour the back room of your LBS and see
if they have any old style friction shifters. These will allow you to
fine tune for chain deflection.

- -
Comments and opinions compliments of,
"Your Friendly Neighborhood Wheelman"

My web Site:
http://geocities.com/czcorner

To E-mail me:
ChrisZCorner "at" webtv "dot" net