Tom said:Chris Malcolm said:Tom said:Chris Malcolm <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:But I am a snob. Do you think I ought to pretend not to be?
Quoted message said:Why not? You did in your post to alt.support.menopause on 11 Nov 2002
where you berated "the absurd academic elitism of the education system", the
same behaviour you seem to be displaying here. Does this make you a
hypocrite as well as a snob Chris?
No, it's just poor reading comprehension skills on your part. You seem
to be unaware that there are many different kinds of snobbery.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:keeping educational casualties happy is not an efficient
way of getting a job done.
Quoted message said:Who mentioned efficiency? My point was that if someone chooses to be a
mechanic, If being a mechanic is all they ever wanted to be, in what way
does that make them a casualty? Not everyone aspires to the lofty heights
of "academic elitism"
I see what you've gone wrong. You think I meant that all mechanics
were educational casualties. That's not what I said, and it's not what
I meant.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:Quoted message said:Perhaps that "parasitic economy" exists because so many people
nowadays have no idea how a car works, so paradoxically have to
depend on those "educational casualties" to fix and service it for
them.
Modern car repair methods have been computerised and built round
replaceable
modules precisely so that educational casualties don't have too much
difficulty fixing things often enough well enough to keep cars
going.
Quoted message said:You really think that motor manufacturers build cars in a modular fashion
so that it is easier for a mechanic to fix them?
Yes I do, and it happens to be a topic I've studied in detail and
discussed with people who design car assembly lines.
Quoted message said:You don't think that maybe
the reason for modular construction might just be for the robots that build
them, and for economic reasons, so that the same module can be used in a
whole range of different vehicles belonging to the same manufacturer?.
That's a contributory reason, but it's not the only one, and that
particular purpose generates a different kind of modularity.
Quoted message said:Have
you ever had to dissasemble the entire front bumper assembly just to change
a blown headlight bulb?[1][2] In what way is that making things easier for
the "educational casualties" ?
That fact that some people do silly things doesn't mean that better
ways of doing it are not well known and well established.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:But that means things are often junked and replaced when an
intelligent mechanic could have identified and fixed the failing part
much more cheaply.
Quoted message said:Intelligent mechanic? Are these that same mechanics you keep refering to as
"educational casualties"? or are these a different breed who only work on
cars built before 1990? The ones who display "The old traditions of
intelligent expert craftsmen, apprentices, guilds, etc., (who) have been
swept away in the stampede for often useless academic glitter and
status"[3].
This is paranoia on your part. There are stupid mechanics and
intelligent mechanics, just as there are stupid plumbers and intelligent
plumbers, stupid architects and intelligent architects, etc, etc..
Quoted message said:The same useless academic glitter and status you seem to now be
so absurdly proud of
Now? You're listening to voices in your head. I haven't said a word
about academic glitter and status in this thread, let alone suggested
I have any to be proud of.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:Phew! For a moment there I thought you must be trying to be rude about
me, but since my post made it clear that I'm quite happy getting my
grimy hands inside an engine you're obviously ranting about some other
snob.
Quoted message said:I don't need to be rude to you Chris. I pity you. When someone displays
this level of snobbishness and bitterness about others,
There wasn't the slightest bitterness. You imagined that. There was
sarcasm, but I enjoy sarcasm.
Quoted message said:and feels a need to
belittle a whole range of people they have never met
Haven't you read the Which reports on garage repairs? It's a well
established fact that there are lots of clueless car mechanics out
there.
Quoted message said:I usually suspect a
deep seated unhappiness, possibly because someone thinks that they have
wasted their life in the "stampede for often useless academic glitter and
status"
Well that certainly wouldn't be me. I only entered university life at
an age when some folk are taking early retirement.
Quoted message said:If you are "quite happy getting (your) grimy hands inside an
engine" then maybe you should have been a motor mechanic instead. Who knows,
you might have been one of the good ones.
I have great respect for good mechanics and engineers and have learned
a great deal from working beside them. I can and do fix most things
mechanical, electrical, or electronic that I own.
--
Chris Malcolm [email hidden] DoD #205
IPAB, Informatics, JCMB, King's Buildings, Edinburgh, EH9 3JZ, UK
[http://www.dai.ed.ac.uk/homes/cam/]