G
Gawnsoft
Guest
On Sat, 26 Jun 2004 13:28:08 +0100, "Tony Raven"
<[email protected]> wrote (more or less):
>Gawnsoft wrote:
>>
>> Kelven invented '/the/ binnacle which' compensated for the effect of
>> the ships metal hull.
>>
>> No other binnacle has done that sort of compensation before.
>>
>> His was not one of many competing designs.
>
>I go with "a binnacle". Its "Kelvin invented a (type of) binnacle which...."
>or "Kelvin invented the magnetically compensated binnacle" You can only use
>the definite article with the specific binnacle he invented whereas you should
>use the indefinite article in the former because the binnacle is not a
>specific binnacle
Using 'the' and 'which' together automatically makes it specific.
>and has to be qualified by the clause which defines what
>type of binnacle it is he invented.
>
>uk.rec.cycling.grammar anyone?
>
>Tony
>
--
Cheers,
Euan
Gawnsoft: http://www.gawnsoft.co.sr
Symbian/Epoc wiki: http://html.dnsalias.net:1122
Smalltalk links (harvested from comp.lang.smalltalk) http://html.dnsalias.net/gawnsoft/smalltalk
<[email protected]> wrote (more or less):
>Gawnsoft wrote:
>>
>> Kelven invented '/the/ binnacle which' compensated for the effect of
>> the ships metal hull.
>>
>> No other binnacle has done that sort of compensation before.
>>
>> His was not one of many competing designs.
>
>I go with "a binnacle". Its "Kelvin invented a (type of) binnacle which...."
>or "Kelvin invented the magnetically compensated binnacle" You can only use
>the definite article with the specific binnacle he invented whereas you should
>use the indefinite article in the former because the binnacle is not a
>specific binnacle
Using 'the' and 'which' together automatically makes it specific.
>and has to be qualified by the clause which defines what
>type of binnacle it is he invented.
>
>uk.rec.cycling.grammar anyone?
>
>Tony
>
--
Cheers,
Euan
Gawnsoft: http://www.gawnsoft.co.sr
Symbian/Epoc wiki: http://html.dnsalias.net:1122
Smalltalk links (harvested from comp.lang.smalltalk) http://html.dnsalias.net/gawnsoft/smalltalk