Not according to Gordon Gekko:Originally Posted by danfoz
Quote: Gordon Gekko: The point is ladies and gentlemen that greed, for lack of a better word, is good.
But your point that pure free market is just as naive as pure socialism is well taken.
Quote: indeed derived from the undeniable sense of brotherhood conveyed in conversations I've had with young Israeli's, both men and women.
Young Israeli's yes; but there is a great deal of resentment across the broad spectrum of Israeli society between some of the hard right religious, many of who do not serve and yet push hard for settlements and other territorial issues ; and some of the more secular moderates, with a history of service and a more moderate position. Like arguments referencing Greece as being a harbinger of future problems in the US; Israel is pretty unique. It's a very tiny country with lot's of cultural, religious, and social commonalities that hold what would otherwise be a very fractious political body together. Military service is only one aspect of what creates the"brotherhood."
I do believe that a draft is good for the US. The service should represent a broad section of US society and it doesn't currently.