General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Arby's substitute

Started by Al Fansome · · Last activity · 59 posts · 2,015 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
16 October 2007
Last activity
19 October 2007
Original author
Al Fansome
Posts
59
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
2,015
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 21–40 of 59
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. On Oct 16, 6:55 am, Melba's Jammin' <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    George said:
    Blinky the Shark said:

    Al Fansome wrote:
    > Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    > similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Why the scare quotes? That's not beef?

    Quoted message said:

    Because it is a manufactured product and not beef. Roast beef would be a
    roasted piece of beef.

    It could also be a piece of roasted beef.

    Not at Arby's it couldn't.

    Quoted message said:

    --
    -Barb, Mother Superior, HOSSSPoJ

    --Bryan

  2. Sqwertz said:


    Al Fansome said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    Carl Buddig sandwich meats. Those $.50 packets hung on the wall
    above the cheese.

    http://www.buddig.com/home.html

    -sw

    OOOPS <G> I wondered why google didn't give me a response when I used
    "buttig meat" (or meats) as keywords 😉 Figures I spelled it
    incorrectly. I'd already responded about "Buttig"[sp] before I read
    your post, Steve.

    Sky

    --
    Ultra Ultimate Kitchen Rule - Use the Timer!
    Ultimate Kitchen Rule -- Cook's Choice

  3. Sqwertz said:


    Al Fansome said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    Carl Buddig sandwich meats. Those $.50 packets hung on the wall
    above the cheese.

    http://www.buddig.com/home.html

    -sw

    OOOPS <G> I wondered why google didn't give me a response when I used
    "buttig meat" (or meats) as keywords 😉 Figures I spelled it
    incorrectly. I'd already responded about "Buttig"[sp] before I read
    your post, Steve.

    Sky

    --
    Ultra Ultimate Kitchen Rule - Use the Timer!
    Ultimate Kitchen Rule -- Cook's Choice

  4. jmcquown said:
    Sky said:
    Al Fansome said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that
    would be similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?


    Hmmm . . . I tried to google for "buttig meat", but I didn't get the
    information I'd hoped for. I probably spelled it incorrectly. The
    "Buttig Meats" I know about come in a plastic bag in the prepackaged
    coldcuts section at the grocery store.

    Sky


    That's because it's Buddig! LOL Lovely (snork) processed pressed meat
    parts.

    Jill


    That makes it sound crappy. You forgot to mention the up to 30%
    "enhancemnt solution" which is added...

  5. jmcquown said:
    Sky said:
    Al Fansome said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that
    would be similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?


    Hmmm . . . I tried to google for "buttig meat", but I didn't get the
    information I'd hoped for. I probably spelled it incorrectly. The
    "Buttig Meats" I know about come in a plastic bag in the prepackaged
    coldcuts section at the grocery store.

    Sky


    That's because it's Buddig! LOL Lovely (snork) processed pressed meat
    parts.

    Jill


    That makes it sound crappy. You forgot to mention the up to 30%
    "enhancemnt solution" which is added...

  6. raymond said:
    Al Fansome said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    Actually, you don't have to buy them because they'll usually give them
    to you free. Ask your grocer for "cardboard boxes" and take them home
    and cut pieces to the size you want.

    That seems like the wrong texture. On second thought I'll bet it would
    work if it was soaked in the "enhancement solution" .

  7. raymond said:
    Al Fansome said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    Actually, you don't have to buy them because they'll usually give them
    to you free. Ask your grocer for "cardboard boxes" and take them home
    and cut pieces to the size you want.

    That seems like the wrong texture. On second thought I'll bet it would
    work if it was soaked in the "enhancement solution" .

  8. The message <[email hidden]>
    from "Michael \"Dog3\"" <[email hidden]> contains these words:

    UGH... beef chunks... wonder which cut of beef

    Quoted message said:

    it is...

    Google "mechanically separated meat", and "advanced meat recovery".

    Janet

  9. George said:
    jmcquown said:
    Sky said:

    Al Fansome wrote:
    > Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that
    > would be similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?
    Hmmm . . . I tried to google for "buttig meat", but I didn't get the
    information I'd hoped for. I probably spelled it incorrectly. The
    "Buttig Meats" I know about come in a plastic bag in the prepackaged
    coldcuts section at the grocery store.

    Sky


    That's because it's Buddig! LOL Lovely (snork) processed pressed
    meat parts.

    Jill


    That makes it sound crappy. You forgot to mention the up to 30%
    "enhancemnt solution" which is added...

    Ohhhh! That makes me feel sooo much better 😉 Actually, when I was in my
    early 20's I'd buy the Carl Buddig stuff because I was broke and it was
    cheap. I think it was 4 for a dollar back then. But then, I also bought
    5/$1 Kroger brand chicken pot pies.

    Would those frozen Steak-Um things substitute for Arby's beef? Do they even
    still sell Steak-Um's?

    Jill

  10. Al Fansome said:


    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    Isn't it amazing how they get the colour just right. From a distance it
    looks like beef. Up close it looks like dyed balogna. Is the average
    consumer so foolish that they would rather save a few pennies and get faux
    roast beef than to pay a little extra and get real beef?

  11. In article <[email hidden]>,

    George said:
    Melba's Jammin said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Because it is a manufactured product and not beef. Roast beef would be a
    roasted piece of beef.

    It could also be a piece of roasted beef.

    Sure, but Arbys hasn't had real meat for years. I remember when I was in
    college there was a nearby Arbys where you could see them slicing real
    meat which kids who worked there said was real meat roasted in the
    store. Some time after that they began using space meat. Even their
    "horsey sauce" can't be called horseradish sauce because apparently
    there is some space product which is cheaper and can be stored for 20
    years which doesn't contain horseradish.

    I was referring to "Roast beef would be a roasted piece of beef. "
    Roast beef could also be a slice of roasted beef. Aw, never mind. "-)
    I think it's maybe Arby's sweet sour sauce that has no recognizable food
    item listed in the ingredients. Like fruit juice (thickened for 'sauce'
    consistency). Scary, really.
    --
    -Barb, Mother Superior, HOSSSPoJ
    Notes about our first 11 meals in Tuscany have been posted to
    http://www.jamlady.eboard.com; 10-16-2007

  12. Dave Smith said:
    Al Fansome said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    Isn't it amazing how they get the colour just right. From a distance it
    looks like beef. Up close it looks like dyed balogna. Is the average
    consumer so foolish that they would rather save a few pennies and get faux
    roast beef than to pay a little extra and get real beef?

    Sure, Walmart has taught everyone that the only thing that can ever
    matter is price but fortunately they might be loosing their grip:

    http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Investing/Extra/TheEndOfTheWalMartEra.aspx?page=1

  13. jmcquown said:
    Quoted message said:

    That makes it sound crappy. You forgot to mention the up to 30%
    "enhancemnt solution" which is added...

    Ohhhh! That makes me feel sooo much better 😉 Actually, when I was in my
    early 20's I'd buy the Carl Buddig stuff because I was broke and it was
    cheap. I think it was 4 for a dollar back then. But then, I also bought
    5/$1 Kroger brand chicken pot pies.

    Would those frozen Steak-Um things substitute for Arby's beef? Do they even
    still sell Steak-Um's?

    Jill


    Depends, if they are a quality version they are simply thinly sliced
    meat and wouldn't qualify.

    My buddy has a commercial refrigeration business and I get to see
    various process lines including meat packing.

    There is a local plant that makes a "Steak-um" type product. They run
    one version under their own name which is made from real meat that they
    trim on site, freeze, slice and package.

    They make another version for the big box mart and famous industrial
    restaurants that is sliced from blocks of pink looking material. A few
    days before processing they pull the blocks out of the low temp freezer
    and put them into a cooler that is just below freezing to warm up. I
    asked about the pink color and they said they buy the blocks from some
    other processor and it has hearts and other byproducts mixed in.

  14. Michael 'Dog3 said:

    "Dave Bugg" <[email hidden]> dropped this
    news:[email hidden]: in rec.food.cooking

    Quoted message said:
    Al Fansome said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that
    would be similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    From the Arby's website, under "printable ingredients list"
    Roast Beef:
    Trimmed Boneless Beef Chunks (Minimum 70%) Combined With Chopped Beef
    For a Maximum of 12% Fat. Contains up to 9.0% of a Self-Basting
    Solution of Water, Salt, Sodium Phosphate.

    I didn't bother going to the site to check it out. The self basting
    solution is what I thought. UGH... beef chunks... wonder which cut of
    beef it is...

    ROTFLOL!!! That made me think of the Jack-In-The-Box commercial where the
    executives are sniggering at colleagues saying "angus burgers".
    --
    Dave
    www.davebbq.com

  15. One time on Usenet said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    I haven't had an Arby's roast beef in a loooong time, but IIRC, it's
    the same texture as Buddig meats:

    http://www.buddig.com/original_cb.html

    HTH...

    --
    Jani in WA

  16. One time on Usenet said:
    Al Fansome said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    Carl Buddig sandwich meats. Those $.50 packets hung on the wall
    above the cheese.

    http://www.buddig.com/home.html

    Hey, that's what I told him. Get out of my mind!! ;-)

    --
    Jani in WA

  17. Little Malice said:


    One time on Usenet said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    I haven't had an Arby's roast beef in a loooong time, but IIRC, it's
    the same texture as Buddig meats:

    I have hd it twice on one occasion..... the first time and the last time. I
    thought it was disgusting. There was an Arbys on the same block as our
    office. It was next to a strip mall with a German deli where I could get a
    real roast beef sandwich and a soft drink for less than the Arbys "beef"
    sandwich. If the deli sandwich was not enough you could buy a second one,
    and the two of them were still cheaper than one at Arbys.

  18. George said:


    Quoted message said:

    Isn't it amazing how they get the colour just right. From a distance it
    looks like beef. Up close it looks like dyed balogna. Is the average
    consumer so foolish that they would rather save a few pennies and get faux
    roast beef than to pay a little extra and get real beef?

    Sure, Walmart has taught everyone that the only thing that can ever
    matter is price but fortunately they might be loosing their grip:

    That explains their poor selection. They can get things cheaper if buy one
    thing, one style in bulk than if they offer a selection. I am happy to hear
    that more and more people are refusing to shop there. My brother used to
    shop there once in a while, but now he just goes in there to check their
    prices and then goes to places that promise to match the lowest price so he
    gets things in other stores at Walmart prices.

  19. One time on Usenet said:
    Little Malice said:

    One time on Usenet, Al Fansome <[email hidden]> said:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Is there a product that is sold in the average supermarket that would be
    similar to the "beef" in an Arby's roast beef sandwich?

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I haven't had an Arby's roast beef in a loooong time, but IIRC, it's
    the same texture as Buddig meats:

    Quoted message said:

    I have hd it twice on one occasion..... the first time and the last time. I
    thought it was disgusting.

    I thought that too, but I was trying to be considerate of the OP's
    feelings. I'm weird that way.

    Quoted message said:

    There was an Arbys on the same block as our
    office. It was next to a strip mall with a German deli where I could get a
    real roast beef sandwich and a soft drink for less than the Arbys "beef"
    sandwich. If the deli sandwich was not enough you could buy a second one,
    and the two of them were still cheaper than one at Arbys.

    One thing I do like at Arby's (unless they've changed in the past
    year) is their chicken breast sandwich. It's actually a chicken
    breast. Probably full of brining solution, but I like them anyway...

    --
    Jani in WA

  20. Little Malice said:


    One thing I do like at Arby's (unless they've changed in the past
    year) is their chicken breast sandwich. It's actually a chicken
    breast. Probably full of brining solution, but I like them anyway...

    --
    Jani in WA

    Me too. If spouse gets the Arby's "beeph" sandwich, I might get the
    chicken or chicken cordon bleu sandwich. They're actually not too bad!

    Sky, who's admittedly a very picky eater 😉

    --
    Ultra Ultimate Kitchen Rule - Use the Timer!
    Ultimate Kitchen Rule -- Cook's Choice

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.