In article <
[email protected]>, jamtmp <
[email protected]> wrote:
> David <
[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:<261120031421186361%
[email protected]>...
>
> > Do you find it uncomfortable (neck and back side) riding on drops or is it just because of
> > safety issues??
>
> I currently ride a Bianchi road bike and never ride on drops. There are 2 reasons.
>
> The first is I find it extremely uncomfortable, far too cramped/too low. I suspect, however, that
> the bike wasn't fitted so well in the first place. I did choose the wrong LBS and was too much in
> a hurry. Now, after 2 years of using this bike occasionally, I start to think of a more
> comfortable bike that could replace both this Bianchi and my commuting hybrid: a touring bike ?
>
Any bike with the proper frame size can be made comfortable if you go through a professional fitter.
A fitter is like a custom tailor, measuring the body geometry to get a sense of what frame size,
stem length, stem rise, crank length and seat height would be ideal for your body size, comfort,
performance and riding style.
You think that by buying a touring bike, it will solve those 2 problems.. While I think you may be
on to something since a touring bike gives you slightly more upright position than say a racing
bike, your commuting hybrid setup should be similar to a typical stock touring bike. If you are
feeling uncomfortable on the hybrid too, then I am suspecting more than just a simple solution of
buying another bike.
My advise would be to seek out a bicycle fitter in your area who is willing to help you do a quick
measurement of your body (bring your most uncomfortable bike with you ofcourse) and determine what's
wrong with your bikes' geometry. If the drop bars are too cramped, this can be easily solved with
wider drop bars, which are available. True touring bikes should come with wider drops. If the bars
are set too low, maybe a combination of a shorter and higher rise stem would help. These solutions
are just examples of what you can do with your current bikes to make them more comfortable. You
should at least see someone or even pay someone to make your bikes comfy..
> The second reason is that in this position I have real difficulties reaching the brakes. I could
> make them reachable by tilting the handlebars forward/down, but then the position I use most, with
> hands resting on the top of the brakes, would become less comfortable. By the way, these are
> Campagnolo, and the Shimano levers seem (?) not to require that long fingers.
>
Also a few Shimano levers has an adjustable reach, which I think is a special version of the Ultegra
and the 8 speed Sora.
It is interesting to note that drop bars come in various sizes in width and length (reach between
the end tip of the flat bar where it curves in to the hood to the bend down curve to the drop where
the shifter hood resides). Again, these are fixable by a professional fitter. In fact, both my road
and touring bikes met the same fate as you did. I bought them because they were cheap and dealt with
the wrong shops. Finally, I broke down and went to a professional fitter who educated me a lot about
proper bike fitting. After changing the drop bars, stem length and rise PLUS crank length and added
shims on my cleats to solve my knee problems, both my bikes are perfect! I can ride centuries with
very very little to no neck and back pain and my overall performance and efficiency has gained,
because I can use the drops whenever the situation warrants. The only saving grace was that I lucked
out on both bike frames being the right sizes for me. My fitter told me that, some other people who
came to see him were not that lucky. Too large of a frame size will force you to use the shortest
stem and the highest rise. That's not good for steering performance.
> From reading the posts in this thread (thanks everybody) I understand I would probably use this
> lower position more often on a touring bike, as probably the handlebars would be higher in the
> first place.
>
> Jacques
Not necessarily.. You should have no problems using the drops on either a touring bike or road bike.
Some people set their drops lower intentionally as that's what they prefer on touring bikes. I have
them lower on the road bike (more aerodynamic) and slightly higher on my touring bike to give me a
more upright riding position. It is simply my riding preference, but not being able to ride on drops
sounds to me that you may have some issues with your cockpit fitting rather than the bikes you own.
Hope this helps.