I had a set of custom wheels built for me by Mike Garcia at Oddsandendos.com. I wanted sturdy, but
relatively light (who doesn't). He suggested 24 spoke Ringle front hub -- radially laced. He said
Ringle was the only hub he knew of that was warranted for radial lacing.
I got these wheels in late January. Last night I did a roller workout. An hour in, POW. The flange
on the front wheel snapped. I was very lucky not to lose control and I was also very lucky I wasn't
on some fast descent or something. I figured it was just a popped spoke, but the first dangling
spoke I saw wasn't broken anywhere. Then I saw another one that wasn't broken, either. Then I
spotted a piece of hub flange on the floor.
So I called Mike Garcia today and told him about it. Naturally, I'll be sending the wheel back to
him. He said he was really surprised 'cuz these hubs are commonly used on mtb wheels and should hold
up to any road application. He also said that, with only a 24-spoke drilling, there's more material
left in the flange and so the failure is even more surprising.
Surprising or not ... it happened and I'm not too happy about it.
Bob C.
"Sheldon Brown" <
[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Jeff S. wrote:
>
> > I'm interested in building up a new set of wheels where the front wheel
(28
> > hole) is laced radially. What is the strongest/best hub for this application, w/o voiding a
> > warranty?
> >
> > I'm thinking of a Sun 'Sun of Bubba' hub but availability/distribution appears to be a major
> > drawback.
>
> Flange weaknes is also an even more major drawback on CNC machined hubs like the Sun/Ringlé
> units. I special ordered some of these a while ago for a customer who wanted a trendy color,
> laced 'em up 3 cross, both front and rear got busted flanges. These would be even less likely to
> survive radial racing.
>
> For radial lacing, you should use a hub with a forged body, such as Shimano or Campagnolo (at
> least the Italian Campagnolo ones...not sure about the Taiwanese models.)
>
> Use butted spokes and don't get carried away with spoke tension. Might want to go with a thread
> adhesive for this specific application.
>
> Sheldon "I Like The Look" Brown +-------------------------------------------------------+
> | Le beau est aussi utile que l'utile --Victor Hugo | (The beautiful is as useful as the
> | useful) |
> +-------------------------------------------------------+ Harris Cyclery, West Newton,
> Massachusetts Phone 617-244-9772 FAX 617-244-1041
http://harriscyclery.com Hard-to-find parts
> shipped Worldwide
http://captainbike.com http://sheldonbrown.com