B
Brimstone
Guest
JNugent wrote:
> Brimstone wrote:
>> JNugent wrote:
>>
>>> Brimstone wrote:
>>>
>>>> JNugent wrote:
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>> raisethe wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>> JNugent <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>>>>>> What do you mean, "equitable"?
>>>>>
>>>>>>>> Fairness dictated by reason and conscience.
>>>>>
>>>>>>> I see. You haven't got a supporting argument so you appeal to
>>>>>>> "reason" (that being nothing more than a restatement of your
>>>>>>> preferences).
>>>>>
>>>>>> No, you don't see. You asked me what equitable meant, and I
>>>>>> defined it for you
>>>>>
>>>>> ...in a way that is meaningless unless seen from your particular
>>>>> POV. IOW, it wasn't a definition. It was just the way you wanted
>>>>> your use of the word to be interpreted.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Which is what you asked him to do, quote JNugent, "What do you
>>>> mean, "equitable"?" and he told you what he meant. Why is that a
>>>> problem for you?
>>>
>>> It isn't.
>>
>>
>> Then why did you say it was?
>
> I didn't.
If you didn't understand what was meant then it must have been a problem
otherwise you wouldn't have needed to ask what was meant.
>>> You can go back to sleep now.
>
>> I do this in my sleep, don't you?
>
> No. But you've clarified something.
You surely don't mean that that which you write comes from a conscious mind?
> Brimstone wrote:
>> JNugent wrote:
>>
>>> Brimstone wrote:
>>>
>>>> JNugent wrote:
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>> raisethe wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>> JNugent <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>>>>>> What do you mean, "equitable"?
>>>>>
>>>>>>>> Fairness dictated by reason and conscience.
>>>>>
>>>>>>> I see. You haven't got a supporting argument so you appeal to
>>>>>>> "reason" (that being nothing more than a restatement of your
>>>>>>> preferences).
>>>>>
>>>>>> No, you don't see. You asked me what equitable meant, and I
>>>>>> defined it for you
>>>>>
>>>>> ...in a way that is meaningless unless seen from your particular
>>>>> POV. IOW, it wasn't a definition. It was just the way you wanted
>>>>> your use of the word to be interpreted.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Which is what you asked him to do, quote JNugent, "What do you
>>>> mean, "equitable"?" and he told you what he meant. Why is that a
>>>> problem for you?
>>>
>>> It isn't.
>>
>>
>> Then why did you say it was?
>
> I didn't.
If you didn't understand what was meant then it must have been a problem
otherwise you wouldn't have needed to ask what was meant.
>>> You can go back to sleep now.
>
>> I do this in my sleep, don't you?
>
> No. But you've clarified something.
You surely don't mean that that which you write comes from a conscious mind?