[email protected] (Mr. Knowitall) wrote in message
news:<
[email protected]>...
> I'm getting a FS mountain bike and would like to collect some opinions. It's pretty much down to a
> Giant NRS 2 or a Trek Fuel 90 (non-disk).
>
> Which frame is better at reducing bob? Sid Race (Giant) or Fox Float R (Trek)? Skarab (Giant) or
> Duke XC (Trek)? What about the mechanical disks (Avid) on the NRS? I rode it and I though they
> sucked but I've read that you have to break them in before they really start to bite.
>
> Any input would be much appreciated! Which one would you get? Or, if you have one of them, do you
> have any complaints?
>
> Thanks, Jason
Your really do need to break those discs in before you notice a difference. I have Avid mechanical
discs on my Giant Rainier and for about the first month, I couldn't see what all the excitement was
about. The only difference I noticed was that I could ride through mud and water without brake fade,
which alone was nice. I took the Rainier into a different Giant shop in town, because I was
displeased with the shop that I bought it from, and had a few cogs replaced. The mechanic mentioned
he would go over the brakes and everything else for me. It turns out that the original shop didn't
have the discs set up properly to begin with (not being a gearhead, I can't really tell you what was
wrong with their set up). They went over the bike once and he said I'd notice a huge difference. Two
rides went by and still nothing all that great, but all at once, WOW, what a difference. So there's
two points for you to consider; give the brakes a chance, and the great customer service Giant
dealers offer you. Honestly, since I didn't buy that bike there, I don't feel they really needed to
go over it like they did, but they did, no questions asked, and would not accept any money for it.
The Giant NRS 2 is probably one of Giants most popular models, and from hanging around the shop the
past three years, I'd say if you have the opportunity to get one now, get it, because they typically
run out of them by mid summer and have to look across the country to TRY to find one for you. I've
test rode two NRS bikes for 8-10 mile rides and can say, as many others will tell you, the NRS
system really works to eliminate bob. I will also tell you I recently attended a bike festival where
Gary Fisher and Trek bikes had demo machines to try out, and I saw no less then 3 Trek Fuels off the
trail with chain suck problems, which I have heard is common in Trek and Fisher bikes. 3 isn't many,
but it's the first time I've seen that many people off the trail with the same problem.