M
Man Over The M_un
Guest
On 14 Sep 2003 07:00:04 -0700, [email protected] (M. Schwartz) wrote:
>> >Mel, still trying to figure out why He said My God, my God, why has
>> >thou forsaken me.
>>
>> Again, not reported as His Words in every account.
>
>So, what's that supposed to mean?
Just what it says. Not every Biblical account has Christ saying "My
God, my God, why has thou forsaken me." The Latin translations alone
is in dispute; the very fact He said anything like this is in dispute.
>There is a version where He is
>speared and there is a version where spearing isn't mentioned. We have
>four people telling the story but none of them were really there.
This also is disputed but I have a tendency to agree with you.
> The
>accounts of Jesus' crucifixation as told by Mark, Matthew, Luke, and
>John are from other sources and that is probably why the accounts
>differ in some events. Did the earth part? Was he speared? Depends on
>who is telling the story. But what does it mean? The words of man? The
>words of different people relating the story to Mark, Matthew, Luke,
>and John?
It means that your Faith had best be in good order.
>And, we still have My God, my God, why has thou forsaken me? Who was
>he talking to?
To The Father. I always took this to mean He was showing His human
side wondering, under great duress, why He was chosen to suffer so.
I have, at times, when I have suffered terribly, wondered the same
myself.
Why me?
>> >Mel, still trying to figure out why He said My God, my God, why has
>> >thou forsaken me.
>>
>> Again, not reported as His Words in every account.
>
>So, what's that supposed to mean?
Just what it says. Not every Biblical account has Christ saying "My
God, my God, why has thou forsaken me." The Latin translations alone
is in dispute; the very fact He said anything like this is in dispute.
>There is a version where He is
>speared and there is a version where spearing isn't mentioned. We have
>four people telling the story but none of them were really there.
This also is disputed but I have a tendency to agree with you.
> The
>accounts of Jesus' crucifixation as told by Mark, Matthew, Luke, and
>John are from other sources and that is probably why the accounts
>differ in some events. Did the earth part? Was he speared? Depends on
>who is telling the story. But what does it mean? The words of man? The
>words of different people relating the story to Mark, Matthew, Luke,
>and John?
It means that your Faith had best be in good order.
>And, we still have My God, my God, why has thou forsaken me? Who was
>he talking to?
To The Father. I always took this to mean He was showing His human
side wondering, under great duress, why He was chosen to suffer so.
I have, at times, when I have suffered terribly, wondered the same
myself.
Why me?