mavic d521 rim cracks?

My bikeshop tells me Mavic d521 very strong long lasting rims, perfect for loaded touring and
mountanibiking. But I found a review stating the ceramic chips of very easy and cracks form around
the (single) eyelets. Does anybody have simular problems?

 

gerrit van wijk wrote:
> My bikeshop tells me Mavic d521 very strong long lasting rims, perfect for loaded touring and
> mountanibiking. But I found a review stating the ceramic chips of very easy and cracks form around
> the (single) eyelets. Does anybody have simular problems?
>

Every mavic rim I've every tried has cracked within 4k miles -- including some of theirs that are
supposed to be really strong (X219, X519, X223, X225 (Cannondale OEM)). I found that I can either
make 'em rigid and they crack at the spoke holes; or I can leave the spokes slightly looser and they
crack inside under the rim tape between spoke holes. YMMV, but I've decided stear clear of Mavics. I
weigh 225, which may make a difference . I've also been told that the anodization makes the rim
brittle and this contributes -- that I should try an unannodized rim.

David

 

"David Kunz" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> gerrit van wijk wrote:
> > My bikeshop tells me Mavic d521 very strong long lasting rims, perfect for loaded touring and
> > mountanibiking. But I found a review stating the ceramic chips of very easy and cracks form
> > around the (single) eyelets. Does anybody have simular problems?
> >
>
> Every mavic rim I've every tried has cracked within 4k miles -- including some of theirs that are
> supposed to be really strong (X219, X519, X223, X225 (Cannondale OEM)). I found that I can either
> make 'em rigid and they crack at the spoke holes; or I can leave the spokes slightly looser and
> they crack inside under the rim tape between spoke holes. YMMV, but I've decided stear clear of
> Mavics. I weigh 225, which may make a difference . I've also been told that the anodization
> makes the rim brittle and this contributes -- that I should try an unannodized rim.
>
> David

Anodizing neither strengthens or weakens a rim. I don't know why some people experienced these
eyelet cracks while others of us
(me) have not, but I'm more inclined to believe it has something to do with the heat treating or
maybe the spoke type ??

BTW, I'm 200 lbs (riding weight) and have been xc & dh'ing on same pair of anodized 521's for a
couple years; those rims have been bomb proof.
--
Slacker

 

In article <[email protected]>, [email protected] says...
> My bikeshop tells me Mavic d521 very strong long lasting rims, perfect for loaded touring and
> mountanibiking. But I found a review stating the ceramic chips of very easy and cracks form around
> the (single) eyelets. Does anybody have simular problems?
>
>
>
>

Stick to non hard anodized, steel eyeleted aluminum rims and you'll be fine. Gucci wheels don't
belong on a bike built for reliability.

--
_________________________
Chris Phillipo - Cape Breton, Nova Scotia http://www.ramsays-online.com

 

In article <[email protected]>,
[email protected] says...
>
>
> "David Kunz" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
> > gerrit van wijk wrote:
> > > My bikeshop tells me Mavic d521 very strong long lasting rims, perfect for loaded touring and
> > > mountanibiking. But I found a review stating the ceramic chips of very easy and cracks form
> > > around the (single) eyelets. Does anybody have simular problems?
> > >
> >
> > Every mavic rim I've every tried has cracked within 4k miles -- including some of theirs that
> > are supposed to be really strong (X219, X519, X223, X225 (Cannondale OEM)). I found that I can
> > either make 'em rigid and they crack at the spoke holes; or I can leave the spokes slightly
> > looser and they crack inside under the rim tape between spoke holes. YMMV, but I've decided
> > stear clear of Mavics. I weigh 225, which may make a difference . I've also been told that the
> > anodization makes the rim brittle and this contributes -- that I should try an unannodized rim.
> >
> > David
>
>
> Anodizing neither strengthens or weakens a rim. I don't know why some people experienced these
> eyelet cracks while others of us
> (me) have not, but I'm more inclined to believe it has something to do with the heat treating or
> maybe the spoke type ??
>
> BTW, I'm 200 lbs (riding weight) and have been xc & dh'ing on same pair of anodized 521's for a
> couple years; those rims have been bomb proof.
> --
> Slacker
>
>
>

I find that eyelet cracks are far more prevalent on road rider's rims. Even if they ride a mountain
bike on the road. I don't know why that is but road riding must put a consistent set of repetative
forces on the rim that causes the cracks more readily than DH or XC riding does. Or maybe it's just
that off road, rims get tacoed before they get a chance to crack at the eyelets
--
_________________________
Chris Phillipo - Cape Breton, Nova Scotia http://www.ramsays-online.com

 

On Sat, 12 Apr 2003 10:50:44 +0200, "gerrit van wijk" <[email protected]> wrote:

>My bikeshop tells me Mavic d521 very strong long lasting rims, perfect for loaded touring and
>mountanibiking. But I found a review stating the ceramic chips of very easy and cracks form around
>the (single) eyelets. Does anybody have simular problems?
>
>
>
>
>
>

I onsly ride road and XC (same bike). I think I wrecked 3 x517 ceramics (eyelet cracks). I now have
a 317 rear, since I use disks now anyway, and although the same weight, it seems a lot stronger.
Needless to say I'm not the worlds most refined cyclist.

Peter R.