Neuvation R28 aero review



bobbyOCR

New Member
Aug 31, 2005
1,357
0
0
33
Sogood'll be happy to hear this, so here we go....

The first thing I noticed upon taking them out of the box was 'wow, the stickers look even worse in person', so they were halved before anything else happened.
The overall looks are very nice. They are very shiny, nice bladed spokes and nice decals (after halving them in number). Upon closer inspection, you begin to realise why they only costed $330AUD.
The hubs are the most simple mechanism (albeit extremely effective) you could use. The hub shell, a straight alloy axle (one groove on each side to hold an o-ring, maybe a stopper for each bearing but I didn't go that far), two cartridge bearings and two dustcaps. The dustcaps are just that, nothing more. They do use sealed cartridge bearings though, but I would reserve this for nice days. The dustcaps are very simple conical-ish pieces of aluminium. They have an o-ring on the inner face to hold it in place and a grub-screw to secure them to the axle. They primarily serve as a safeguard for the bearings and to space out the axle enough to fit in the forks. The rear is a little more complex, though, using cones to preload the bearings.

The spokes are very nice wide blades, but none of this fatness like ksyriums, they are nice and thin. The J-bends are very thick, so hopefully they should be a little more durable.
The nipples are just regular nipples. I think its brass all round.
The rim is something else. The joint is painfully obvious, but could be hidden a little better with some filler and paint, or just filler. The special part of this rim is the braking surface. While the sleeve is quite obvious, this braking surface sits about 1mm off the rim. You'll never wear this out. It has also been very VERY well machined. The regular micro-grooves are present, but it is dead smooth. The rim joint is impossible to distinguish. The front wheel also spins forever and is laced 1 cross.

The rear is nice too. The flanges are quite narrowly spaced and its only laced 1 cross too :eek:. We'll see what the stiffness is like tomorrow. The freehub body is very well machined, clever, but not very nicely finished. This doesn't matter cause its under a cassette. It has extra material where the theoretically most used cogs are (around the 16-21 depending on what cassette you are using) I presume this is to stop the cogs 'biting' in that area. The rest is fairly straightforward there, still needs the 1mm spacer for 10 speed. It does have a clever little grease port (I assume) which was used pretty quickly with some fine fishing-reel grease which is good for freehubs. It needed it. It seems the bearings on the rear will take a little while to break in. It is more complex with better seals than the front hub. As I said, its only laced 1cross with 20 spokes, despite the fact that the flanges are not low by any means.

I will post pics of the bare wheels, mounted wheels and details tomorrow, along with a ride report.
 
After just under 100km, I can say they are a 'solid' wheelset. I was pleasantly surprised with the ride quality. They were very comfortable. The stiffness isn't anything to get excited about, but it is still better than you'd expect from the cost of the wheels and the design. They were responsive enough uphill, and roll beautifully downhill. I will not say they are any 'faster' than Shimano R500, but they wear you out slower and make you feel like you have the 'edge'. They are still true, which is good, since many wheels (that I've tried) initially come out of true as the spokes settle, but then are fine. The bearings still sound smmmooooootth, and feel smooth too. The braking isn't all that great, Shimano's rims stop a little quicker, but once its worn in I hope it will be better. Oh yeah, and the freehub makes a nice clicking noise.
 
100_0052.jpg

The rear
100_0057.jpg

The front
100_0060.jpg

The dead obvious rim joint. they could have done that a little better. No brake grabbing though.
100_0059.jpg

The front hub. Note the grub screw on the dust cap. Laser etched logo on a highly polished machined hubshell.
100_0055.jpg

The rear freehub. Note the grease port.
100_0054.jpg

The rear flanges and shiny hubshell.

100_0063.jpg

The wheels mounted to the BMC. (that massive spacer stack will 'disappear' in less than a week. New deda newton stuff)
 
bobbyOCR said:
100_0063.jpg

The wheels mounted to the BMC. (that massive spacer stack will 'disappear' in less than a week. New deda newton stuff)
Very nice and thanks for the report!

That last photo, took me a while to realise the bike was hanging on the wall. I thought your use of that BBB wall hanger on the floor was an interesting idea until...

So what's your latest bike weight? Did the Neuvation take that 8.4kg down a notch again? ;)
 
sogood said:
Very nice and thanks for the report!

That last photo, took me a while to realise the bike was hanging on the wall. I thought your use of that BBB wall hanger on the floor was an interesting idea until...

So what's your latest bike weight? Did the Neuvation take that 8.4kg down a notch again? ;)
The 8.4kg is with the nuevations. If I were to change groupset to record it would drop a kilo from 105. It is dropping because a KCNC TI lite straight seatpost is on order (bike fit issues, short femurs) which will drop at least 150g. Under 8 here I come.

And its not BBB. Probably sourced from the same factory though. Its a bikeforce in house brand.
 
bobbyOCR said:
The 8.4kg is with the nuevations. If I were to change groupset to record it would drop a kilo from 105. It is dropping because a KCNC TI lite straight seatpost is on order (bike fit issues, short femurs) which will drop at least 150g. Under 8 here I come.

And its not BBB. Probably sourced from the same factory though. Its a bikeforce in house brand.

What chainset is that? It looks like a compact shimano...?
 
take a nice long look at that nicely machined freehub body and remember it, as in less than a few thousand k's it'll be chewed.

i'm not really sure how many k's i have in mine, maybe 2000 give or take. took the cassette off to clean and service the freehub (and yes it was still on very tightly). the body was chewed enough (standard ultegra cassette) that i needed multigrips to unseat some of the individual sprockets. i've filed it down but am not holding my breath for any longevity.

which poses the question why do wheel manufacturers feel the need to save 50g on an alloy body as opposed to steel? grr.

--brett
 
I will take careful note of that. I though there was going to be some kind of issue like that. Oh well, maybe I'll be lucky.

It isn't a compact Shimano. Its a 42/39. U17rules.
 
sideshow_bob said:
take a nice long look at that nicely machined freehub body and remember it, as in less than a few thousand k's it'll be chewed.
I understand that's a problem not specific to this Neuvation wheel. And I further understand that the problem is worse with cassettes that has individual cogs while units that combine cogs on a carrier fare better. One thing I wonder though, whether the the tightness of the locking nut makes a difference.
 
Don't these wheels have high friction hubs?

How much did the bike cost total and frame and fork set?
 
As a poor college student looking for some possible post-christmas gifts to self, how would you rate these to other wheels in this price range such as the Fulcrum Racing5 or Easton Vista?
 
sogood said:
I understand that's a problem not specific to this Neuvation wheel. And I further understand that the problem is worse with cassettes that has individual cogs while units that combine cogs on a carrier fare better. One thing I wonder though, whether the the tightness of the locking nut makes a difference.

That's correct all wheels with alloy carriers will have this issue. Pretty much most Shimano and Campag cassettes have individual cogs except the top 3-4 which are often pinned. So it's not an issue limited to Neuvations, however for the sake of 50g it's simply a silly piece of engineering. I'd understand it in an ultralight set of wheels that are catering for the weight weenie crowd, and more specifically wheels that aren't generally going to be used as everyday'ers. For a mid weight set of wheels? Why?

Having said that I knew the carrier was alloy when I bought them, so *****ing about it now is a bit disingenuous.

I would think the tightness of the lockring would only be an issue if it was loose enough that there is play in the cassette. Mine had no play, and was tight enough that it took a few minutes to muscle it off.

--brett
 
Bobby, did you have trouble mounting your tires? This is a problem Neuvations are notorious for. I could not mount Conti GP4000s on my Neuvations. I barely got Hutchinson's on after an hour of using every trick in the book. I finally tried inflating the tube about five full pumps with about 12 inches of bead outside the rim and it worked miraculously.
 
1. No the hubs are beautifully simple low friction cartridge bearing jobs. No true seals except on the bearings though so thats a little problem (on the front)

2. Tyre mounting was dead easy with conti attack force.
 
sideshow_bob said:
I would think the tightness of the lockring would only be an issue if it was loose enough that there is play in the cassette. Mine had no play, and was tight enough that it took a few minutes to muscle it off.
Thanks for the comment, I guess tightening it further won't help my wheels.

BTW, are there steel freehubs to be had to mate these wheels? I thought these are brand specific ie. Only Mavic sells freehubs for their wheels.
 
sogood said:
Thanks for the comment, I guess tightening it further won't help my wheels.

BTW, are there steel freehubs to be had to mate these wheels? I thought these are brand specific ie. Only Mavic sells freehubs for their wheels.

The body is usually specific to the hub. Can you get an off brand one to fit? Maybe, you'd need to trial and error through a bunch.

Can you get a steel body for the Neuvation hubs? Not sure. Their lower end M series still use alloy bodies as well, so I'm not holding my breath.

--brett
 
I was a little sidetracked today, I just received my Velocity white Deep Vs that had been ordered a while back. Just waiting on competition or revo spokes and my Suzue Pro Max hubs. Gonna be sweet on my upcoming road fixie.
 
Had a perfect day of cycling planned today. A friend was staying down on the NSW South Coast and looking to ride in the Southern Highlands, I was able to get a late day off work, so made the drive down planning to do a 100km loop somewhere with some serious climbing. We settled on Berry to Kangaroo Valley, to Robertson and back down to Kiama. That's two 7km climbs both at around 7-8% and lots of rolling terrain.

What does this have to do with Neuvations? First climb of the day 5km out of Berry ping ... there goes a spoke. The wheel went so far out of true it was hitting the frame. Limped back to the car in Berry, drove 40km return to the closest bike shop to get a replacement spoke. Yep they take a nice easy to find J bend spoke, the hub hole however is bigger than normal so lots of dicking around ensued finding a spoke that wouldn't pull through.

Got everything sorted and eventually tackled the route we'd planned (and got roundly spanked). All I'm thankful for is the spoke didn't tank in the middle of nowhere cause there was no riding out on it.

One spoke after a few months happens, so maybe just an unlucky event. I'm going back to Cosmic Elites.

--brett
 
sideshow_bob said:
Can you get a steel body for the Neuvation hubs? Not sure. Their lower end M series still use alloy bodies as well, so I'm not holding my breath.
Just found out that Mavic Ksyrium ES's Campag compatible freehub is made of steel. How about that? :)
 
sogood said:
Just found out that Mavic Ksyrium ES's Campag compatible freehub is made of steel. How about that? :)

But isn't that 50g slowing you down on the climbs? </humor>

Like I said earlier, I completely understand in a set of ultralight wheels where they are striving to cut every gram. And in most cases these are race day only wheels. In a mid weight set of wheels there is no benefit and a pain in the ass downside when you invariably chew the body. Stupid engineering.

--brett