Cletus Lee <
[email protected]> wrote in message
news:<
[email protected]>...
> In article <
[email protected]>,
[email protected] says...
> > I am looking at SKS, Rans and Planet Bike fenders. Any comments good or bad on any of these
> > models?
>
> I think RANS (old style), and I know Lightning and HP Velotechnic are SKS/ESGE fenders. I prefer
> the HP Velotechnik because they come with mudflaps. Others have given good reviews of the Planet
> Bike fenders.
>
> The HP Velotechnik are cheaper than RANS and Lightning by far.
I had Planet Bike fenders on my Rotator Tiger (dual 406 tires). I have the RANS fenders on my Rocket
(again, dual 406 tires). Perhaps because the RANS fenders are made for their bikes while the Planet
Bikes are used for a variety of bikes, but I think the RANS fenders fit a little better. The Planet
Bikes seemed a little too long and therefore didn't look as "tailored" as the RANS. But both did
their job. As to the Planet bike "mudflap" if you like the style fine. I didn't think they made any
difference in terms of utility.
Mike S. St. Louis, Mo.
Barcroft Virginia Barcroft Columbia RANS Rocket