Carrera said:The trouble is if you compare the history of Europe and the U.S. over the last few centuries with the Islamic world, then the latter comes off a great deal worse. The trouble with the Islamic World is it has been stuck in a time warp for centuries and although Bin Laden and co may denounce the West, they also rely on the West for the most basic technologies.
What I mean is that if global progress had kept track with the Islamic World there would have been no lunar landings, no aviation, no telecommunications, possibly no electricity or even motor cars.
The failures of western socieities are numerous and make grim reading just as gladiatorial games and hedonism in the Greco/Roman world might make you shudder somewhat. But I do agree with the Italian politician who stated the Islamic World has failed to progress in the same way western civilization managed to do (in the long run).
There's a very bad side of the U.S. and Europe that leaves a lot to be desired but also a lot of positive developments, whereas Middle Eastern societies simply haven't budged and have failed to capitalise on their vast resources. I don't know why Persia and Mesopotania fell so much from their former glory as global superpowers but suspect religion lies at the heart of it all.
Well let's look at "progress".
For me, the great thinkers and innovators have come from Europe, like Newton, DeVinci etc.
The enlightenment was fuelled by the French.
The Renaissance was fuelled by the Italians.
The Industrial Revolution was fuelled by the British.
These episodes have been the great leap forward.
I agree that the Islamic world appears to have stopped.
But look at how advanced the Islamic world was at one point - they had a better understanding of medicine, they devised Algebra, they devised the written language in Mesopotamia, their engineering was years ahead of Europe up to 16th century (see the water systems of Southern Spain for example).
The Nazi's developed the technology of space travel - they're rocket technology was utilised by the Merkins to fuel the US space program