There's way too much information in the OP for me to climb the tree, let alone go out on a limb.
Being a 2009, at the newest, with a $1740 MSRP this carbon wonder is yesterday's news. Time has marched on and technology has improved. Seeing that 2009 was the last Blue Book value listed, even that mint, almost no-miles example would be worth around $600 on my Craigslist, I'm in agreement with Froze. An average example of this model would be under $500.