... It was 32° when I started riding this afternoon in the sun and my hands froze WITH wool glove liners inside these worthless excuses for cycling gloves. And no, my hands were not sweating.
Every time I turned into the head wind I could feel...or maybe NOT FEEL...my fingers going numb. Every time I turned out of the wind I regained some feeling in my numb fingers.
My rating: SAVE YOUR MONEY! Go to Wally World or Tractor Supply or Menards and buy 5 pairs of decent winter gloves for the same money. The big box store gloves work as well or better than these.
I'm all-in on sourcing some
alternative-to-REI/etc. clothing at Wally World ...
FWIW. Of course,
cold hands are not an isolated phenomenon unique to riders in Ohio ...
To momentarily return the thread to discussing alternatives to the non-functioning Specialized Element 2.0 gloves ...
I found that FOR ME at temps from 25º-&-higher keeping my hands warm is to simply wear a pair of old style, crocheted-back cycling gloves (
it's the type I prefer to wear during the Summer, too ...) UNDER a pair of
happens-to-be-but-any-equivalent-will-do (
e.g., "leather palmed" for gripping "traction") Pearl Izumi knit gloves.
Yeah, it's probably counter-intuitive that a pair of knit gloves work ... undoubtedly, it is the ADDITIONAL layer which the crocheted cycling gloves add which is the reason why it seems to work -- that is, the crocheted cycling gloves provide the beneficial boundary layer of warm air akin to the once-common fishnet undergarments which were once commonly used by Winter backpackers/campers/etc.
If biting WIND continues to be an issue, then a pair of comparatively clumsy "WIND MITTENS" (
made with 60/40, 65/35, or Supplex ... GoreTex is probably too stiff and will undoubtedly become annoying after a few miles) which XC skiers use would be the added layer which I recommend you try ...
Shifting & Braking with Campagnolo shifters should not be too adversely impacted by the Wind Mittens ....
Try them with your bike mounted on your trainer to assess the limitations.
To state the obvious,
a warm head == warm feet AND hands ...
So, if you aren't already wearing a balaclava under your helmet, consider one.
BTW. I also wear a pair of cheap shop goggles (
the type with the face-fitting vinyl cowl) because cold wind on MY eyes not only makes my eyes tear but seems to exacerbate the sensation which the cold wind imparts. If "style" is important OR you already have a pair of downhill ski goggles, then consider trying those OR some other type of goggles.