I have had a couple Reynolds forks. Nice forks, but I tend to dislike their compression plugs. They are heavy, offer little support and strip easily. I have used an FSA carbon model with some luck, but currently use an aluminum sleeve epoxied in there. Much lighter, stiff and offers a little insurance against my overagressive wrenching. The epoxying process is a little frustrating, but after a few tries, I have a nice set up (on my Reynolds fork). If you do go with another bunge, be aware that they can be inside-diameter specific. Reynolds id's tend to be a bit larger than other forks I've used.
FWIW, the best set up IMHO is the Cannondale SI system which involves a starnut in the steerer and a top cap with a long sleeve that offers support. It's light, strong and never slips.