Carrera said:America's misconception it can simply go into Iraq and impose U.S. style democracy with so many ethnic divisions in that country is as absurd as the current President himself is clueless.
.
I don't believe, for one second, that the US "rationale" for the invasion of Iraq had anything whatsoever to do with "democracy".
It was an act of imperialistic expansion - pure and simple.
Carrera said:Hmmm, more like they were doing reasonably O.K. under Saddam till Bush came in and hit them with a hammer. .
The Iraq economy under Saddam during the 1980's was highly productive economically.
The Iraqi economy approached first world performance levels.
In addition investment in infrastructure and investment in higher education would have left many first world country's in the ha'penny place.
Carrera said:Yes, but it's still early days. My argument all along has been too many countries have concluded the U.S. is a huge success story and we should all copy America. However, the problem with that view is the U.S. has only been a global power for less than 100 years, which is peanuts in historical terms. The Romans were on top for 600 years, for instance. The ancient Egyptians lasted for hundreds of years. Neither has the U.S. ever been tested as the USSR was during Germany's invasion. Would the U.S. have held together under such circumstances or would it have fragmented under pressure?
My guess is without Russia and the Bolsheviks, the U.S. would have failed to defeat ****** which would have left all of us in a pretty poor situation under Arian fascist rule.
Professor Niall Ferguson has stated that throughout history, there have been 68 empires or dynasties which had imperialistic ambitions and which sought to impose their regimes upon other sovereign entities.
From the ancient times such as the Celts through to the Romans through to the British : from Genghis Khan to Leonid Breshnev : are all accounted for within Ferguson's 68 dynasties.
All 67 of those dynasties have disappeared or have retracted to their generic territorial locations.
Ferguson argues that the USA is the 68 empire/dynasty - and that this dynasty/empire will fail to assert it's imperialistic tendencies.