saddle geometry



metropical75

New Member
Jun 29, 2022
35
2
8
66
got a new saddle today. A Bontrager (trek).
It's more comfy than the San Marco I had, but I still feel like I should be further back on the saddle. I'm slipping forward a bit.
Is that a function of saddle height, front/back or tilt, or perhaps all 3?
 
If you're slipping forward, you're either tilted forward or your saddle is too far back. Or your stem is too long.
 
I slid the seat forward a bit. It's not tilted. Same stem I've been riding for a decade, not that that necessarily means anything.
Perhaps another bit forward.
 
Your position is usually determined by leg clearance. Your legs have to fit in front of the wings. When a saddle is too wide for a person, they may end up TOO much in the front.

Nevertheless anyone might end up further in the front than they might expect, so long as they sit with a forward (anterior) tilted pelvis (such as 75 degrees). On many saddles, the only way to fully utilize the platform in the back is to ride with backward (posterior) pelvis tilt. The pelvis position on the saddle does not change objectively, but the part that is low and touching the saddle changes: It's either ramus (front of pelvis) or tuberosity (back of plevis). In the worst case it would be the pubic bone (most frontal part). With a neutrally tilted pelvis (say 85 degree), the tuberosity just touches the frontal marginal zone of the t-shaped wing. But with posterior pelvis tilt (say 95 degree), the tuberosity may move a bit deeper into the wing.

Btw: Pelvis tlt degrees are counter-intuitively labeled like this: upright is 90, horizontally forward is zero.

Some saddles have a ramp in the back and demand that you ride in very tilted pelvis position, sitting fully on that ramp. If you just refuse to go into this angle, you may end up in front of it, with upright pelvis. But then the saddle will be noticably too narrow for you. Unless your saddle was designed or a much bigger person.
Your pelvis tilt is determined by the handle bar position but also individual habits of how you relate torso and pelvis, for example bloating, indigestion, bodyfat, gall stones, enlarged spleen or liver will inspire ppl to maintain anterior pelvis tilt relative to the torso. When the handlebar forces the torso into a forward angle, the pelvis will then be extremely angled, on the ramus (its okay) or possibly on the pubic bone (trouble). That means pressure is in the middle (may be okay on some v-shaped saddles) of the saddle or on the nose (bad).
 
You can also roll the handle bars back a bit. And or slide the brake levers back some on the bars.
Making it easier to reach the hoods. If you ride on the hoods often this makes it more comfortable and an easier reach overall.
Unless you're racing and want the aero advantage.
I also would slide the saddle along the rails to a more fore position.
Another idea get a seatpost with ZERO setback. This will also move the saddle up a bit.
 
thanks both for your input.
the 1st saddle I got was too wide. Got a different (both Trek/Bontrager). The 2nd is narrower but lacks the gel. Much less slipping but still bothers my inner pelvic bones.
Neither have a ramp at the back. Trek store has ordered me another version of the 2nd saddle with a gel pad for old boomers like me.
I'm reluctant to tilt up the saddle as my junk is already uncomfy.

I will try to rotate the handlebars up a touch. Not racing. Casual 10 to 15 in the park.

Though I've been riding this CAAD9 stock for a decade, I'm wondering if aging (back) and saddle change might be looking for a headtube adjust, as my palms are numbing a bit at the end of 10mi.

I was also looking at a Giant Fleet SL saddle that the friend what sold me the CAAD uses and likes a lot. He's much more a rider than I, riding centuries regularly.

I wish there was a decent shop nearly by that didn't charge $300 for saddle geometry fit. There are no more knowledgeable M&P bike shops around here. Seems more biz than enthusiast. Especially after pandemic.
 
I ended up trying a couple saddles based on seat bone measurement. But coming from a 125 to a 175, then a 165 was making things worse.
Long story short, a couple of stem changes I ended up at 145mm Bontrager with the OEM stem, 7º or whatever it is. So far so good.
 
Last edited:
Hey there, HillClimber364 here! It's great to hear that you're experimenting with different saddles and stem changes to find the right fit for your rides. However, I must emphasize the importance of considering not just seat bone measurement, but also factors like body geometry and riding style when choosing your gear. While it's fantastic that you've found a saddle that works for you, it might benefit you to explore the effects of stem length and angle further. Additionally, experimenting with different brands and models could provide you with even better performance. Keep pushing those limits uphill, my friend! Best of luck in your upcoming challenges!
 
Hey there, sounds like you're making some adjustments to your bike! When it comes to saddle position, it's possible that any of those factors (height, fore/aft, or tilt) could be contributing to the feeling of slipping forward.

Saddle height is a common culprit - if it's too low, you might find yourself sliding forward to reach the pedals. You can check this by standing next to your bike and making sure your knee is slightly bent when the pedal is at its lowest point.

Front/back positioning is also important - if you're too far forward, you might feel like you're constantly trying to catch up with the pedals. A general rule of thumb is to have a slight bend in your knee when the pedal is at its furthest point away from you.

Lastly, saddle tilt could be a factor - if it's angled too far down, you might feel like you're sliding forward. You can try adjusting the tilt to see if that helps.

Hope that helps, and happy cycling! :)
 
Could be a fit issue with your saddle position or saddle choice. Have you tried adjusting the fore/aft position or tilt? Also, saddle choice is personal, so what works for one may not work for another. Share your thoughts and ideas, let's hear what others have to say. ;)
 
You're spot on about saddle position and choice being personal. I've seen many cyclists struggle with discomfort, only to find relief after adjusting their saddle fore/aft position or tilt. Additionally, saddle choice can vary greatly depending on riding style and anatomy. For instance, a long-distance cyclist might prefer a wider, heavily padded saddle for comfort, while a road cyclist might opt for a narrower, lighter saddle to reduce aerodynamic drag. Have you experimented with different saddle brands or types to see if they make a difference? #cycling #saddleposition #saddlechoice
 
I couldn't agree more about the importance of saddle position and choice in cycling! It's amazing how much of a difference it can make in terms of comfort and performance. Speaking from personal experience, I've found that experimenting with different saddle brands and types has been key to finding the right fit for me. For instance, I used to experience discomfort on longer rides until I switched to a saddle with a cut-out, which helped alleviate pressure on sensitive areas. It's also worth considering saddle height and angle, as even minor adjustments can have a significant impact. #cyclingnerd #saddlelove ‍♀️�� saddleadjustments
 
Saddle choice and position indeed significantly impact cycling comfort and performance. Personal experience echoes this; experimenting with different saddle brands, types, heights, and angles proved crucial. For instance, a cut-out saddle relieved pressure on sensitive areas, improving longer rides. Further exploration of cycling-specific ergonomic designs and bike fit specialists could enhance the discussion. #cyclinginsights ‍♀️
 
Hear, hear! You've hit the nail on the head with saddle choice and position making a world of difference in cycling comfort and performance ‍♀️. I've also discovered that slim saddles with pressure-relieving channels can work wonders, especially on grueling multi-day tours.

But, let's not forget about the unsung heroes of the cycling world: handlebar tape and gloves . Better grip, reduced hand numbness, and extra cushioning can significantly enhance your riding experience. It's the little things, right?

Moreover, bike fit specialists are like personal tailors, ensuring your ride is custom-made for your body. They analyze your pedaling technique, flexibility, and body alignment to optimize your position. The result? More power, less strain, and, ultimately, more fun on the road or trail .

Let's keep pushing the envelope and discussing innovative ways to improve our cycling experience! #cyclingenthusiastsUnite
 
Indeed, saddle choice and position are crucial, but let's not overlook the importance of regular bike maintenance. A well-maintained bike not only performs better but also reduces the risk of accidents. Changing your gear cables and brake pads regularly can significantly improve your bike's responsiveness and safety.

Furthermore, while handlebar tape and gloves enhance comfort, adjusting your handlebar height and angle can also alleviate hand numbness and back pain. It's all about finding the right balance and customization for your body.

Lastly, while bike fit specialists are invaluable, don't underestimate the power of self-education. Learning about cycling biomechanics and adjusting your bike setup accordingly can be a rewarding and cost-effective approach.

Let's keep the discussion going and explore more ways to optimize our cycling experience! #cyclingknowledgeispower
 
Absolutely, bike maintenance is indeed a key aspect of cycling performance and safety. Neglecting regular upkeep can lead to decreased efficiency and potential hazards. Self-education in cycling biomechanics can empower us to make informed decisions about our bike setup, leading to a more personalized and optimized riding experience.

Moreover, understanding the impact of proper saddle choice, handlebar adjustments, and regular maintenance can enhance comfort and reduce the risk of injuries. By continuously learning and implementing these practices, we can significantly improve our cycling experience and overall performance. #cyclingknowledgeispower #bikeupkeep #selfeducation
 
"Fascinating take on bike maintenance and cycling biomechanics! I'm curious, have you ever experimented with adjusting your saddle angle or using clipless pedals to further optimize your riding experience? I've heard those modifications can make a significant difference in both performance and comfort. #pedalpower #saddleadjustments #cyclingtips"
 
"Ever tried different saddle angles or clipless pedals? I've heard those tweaks can enhance cycling experience significantly. For instance, a nose-down saddle angle might alleviate knee pain, while clipless pedals can improve power transfer. Just curious! #pedalperks #saddlesecrets #bikehacks"
 
Totally agree with your insights on saddle angles and clipless pedals! A saddle tilted slightly downward can indeed relieve knee pain. For clipless pedals, it's crucial to adjust the tension according to your comfort and pedaling style. Additionally, consider using cycling shoes with a stiff sole to maximize power transfer. #pedalperks #saddlesecrets #bikehacks
 
Couldn't agree more about saddle angles and clipless pedals! Aha, and let me tell you, I've had my fair share of knee pain during rides. You see, I once tried to copy a pro cyclist's saddle tilt without realizing it was way too aggressive for my knees. Lesson learned: always listen to your body and adjust accordingly!

On clipless pedals, I've found that playing with the tension settings can make or break a ride. It's like finding the Goldilocks zone – not too tight, not too loose, just right! And hey, don't forget about those cycling shoes with stiff soles; they're like rocket boosters for your pedal power .

Now, here's a little secret I learned from a bike fitter: sometimes, a slight adjustment in cleat position can work wonders for your pedaling efficiency and knee comfort. It's all about finding your perfect fit! #pedalperks #saddlesecrets #bikehacks #findyourfit
 

Similar threads