Hahahahahahaha. Ahhahahahahahahaaha.
I fell into the same damn trap when my father and I both bought C40s last year. We ended up springing for the insanely expensive Colnago carbon seatpost (I found it "cheap" for about $200 after tax!). To boot, the Colnago ain't the lightest around (OK, fine), and the clamping is a PITA to adjust the tilt unless you have some magic freaky teensy wrench I've never been able to locate in my tool box!
We went with the Colnago, rather than the shim method because:
1) We were stupid
2) We thought that keeping it all Colnago would be cool/good (i.e., see #1 above)
3) Both my LBSs told me the shim is a pain, and not anywhere near as solid as using the right post
4) It would've taken a week to get the shim anyway
5) The shim from Trialtir would've been about $30!!!!
If you are fussy, and want the 'official' product, get the Colnago.
If you are just a tad less fussy, and don't mind giving away $30 for a 60 cent piece of aluminum (or whatever it is), then get the shim from Trialtir (or have your dealer order it).
If you are purely sensible, then buy whatever shim you can find!