A reader asked:
> >>> local bike shops sell Shimano sis shift cable housing at $4.5/foot and generic shift cable
> >>> housing at $1.5/foot. much appreciate advice on whether one would notice the difference in
> >>> shifting between Shimano and generic.
And Jobst responded:
> >> With shift cables attached to the handlebar and closely spaced gears, length change of
> >> conventional control cable housing has caused problems for MTB's where large changes in
> >> shift-cable bend-radius occurs. I doubt that there is an advantage for road bicycles. Since it
> >> contains less steel (but is stiffer) it might be lighter.
>
> >> Don't overlook the following:
>
> >>
http://draco.acs.uci.edu/rbfaq/FAQ/8f.2.html
I (
[email protected]) penned:
> > Jobst, I did not understand that at all. "contains less steel"?? Which one? Shimano gear casing
> > or CC gear casing?
<
[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> The FAQ item explains that the SIS shift cable housing has low helix stainless wires instead of
> being a steel coil, conventional in Bowden control cables. The SIS cable housing is mainly plastic
> with longitudinal wires with a helix similar to that of the cable. Cables must be wound in a helix
> or the outside strands would fail under load because they take a longer path. The helix makes all
> strands pass through inside and outside of bends, maintaining constant length and stress. The SIS
> housing does the same.
(am)> > I use both Shimano gear casing and CC Cable gear casing ( and Campagnolo
> > gear casing too!) I use a lot of it in all three brands.
> > I don't believe there is any more or less steel in any brand of gear
casing
> > currently produced.
(jb)> If you review the FAQ item, I think it will clarify the issue.
(am)> > As a matter of fact, I bet you could not tell a length of Shimano
> > gear casing from a length of CC Cable brand gear casing once you cut out the section with the
> > name hot-stamped in. (Campagnolo is very slightly thinner OD).
(jb)> I don't know what a CC cable is.
(am)> > I just cut open a piece of each brand and the strands are the same size
> > (.5mm) and the strand count (19) is identical.
(jb)> Well! A brake cable housing has only one strand that is wound
> circularly about a mandrel. It is solid steel, the better ones are made of rectangular
> (trapezoidal when straight) wire.
Ahhh, We have spoken past each other. I was replying to the question about Shimano vs. "generic"
gear casing. You were talking about the difference between gear casing and brake casing, an
important thing but tangetial here.
--
Andrew Muzi
http://www.yellowjersey.org Open every day since 1 April 1971