Originally posted by Espada9
Have to agree with George on this one, the newer frame materials are very strong and durable, plenty of testing goes into a tubeset before its used to build a frame (and carry the badge of the frame builder).
My Orbea frame (Altec 2 Aluminum) is plenty strong enough for my 245 pound bulk (the forks are older profile carbon and they flex like aldente pasta).
A quality frame builder like Merckx would never put their name (and reputation) on a frame built with material that wouldn’t hold up to the average joe racer (regardless weather he weighs 135 of 260).
Iweigh in at 130kg, i think that is about 280 pound. My cheap as Asti one piece carbon lasted 5 years before it got "sloppy". My new carbon Giant doesnt seem to mind my fat backside to much either. Im a sprinter so work bikes harf, alloy I find strong as hell but to harsh, but Steel? I can change gear on most steel bikes just by kicking hard out of the saddle (Im not known for my smooth style though!). Quess everyone has an opinion on this, but thats my experiance anyhow