We all have different experiences and favorites, and there are lots of good tires out there. I've found that the Conti GP 4000s are almost bulletproof for me, with long life and great puncture resistance so I can actually wear them out. I've been buying them for about the last 10 years now. They have a top rep with many of the serious, high-mileage riders and racers here. Last year I was working the Cat I/II/Pro State Road race, and noticed that at least half the field seemed to be on GP4000s. Pricey but worth it IMO. I tend to be a cheapskate, but not when it comes to tires.....of all the things that affect safety, handling and ride comfort on our bikes, I'd say tires are the most important.
I had "bad luck" with Michelin ProRace tires about 10 years ago, but I believe there current range of tires is much improved. Like the other major brands, they offer a range of tires, so pick carefully based on the characteristics you need or prefer. Michelin has charts on their website which show the mix of grip, life, and puncture resistance that their various tires offer.
The Rubino Pros have a number of fans here too. I'd certainly recommend them. The fastest and best-riding race tire I've used is the Vittoria Open Corsa CX, but between punctures, cuts and fast wear, couldn't keep them on the bike for long. Best life I got on the rear was less than 2000 miles. They are super-thin, more like a flat piece of tape when you take them out of the box. The warning on the box says that they are race tires, not made to handle road debris or gravel. A pricey tire that only lasts for 1500 miles, or cuts on the front even sooner makes for a very expensive tire.
Compare the mileage you get from any tire to the cost, and you may find that using a high-quality expensive tire really doesn't cost any more.