Tiagra Gears



redbankuk

New Member
Sep 5, 2004
8
0
1
On my Specialized Sirrus I have 700*28 tyres, a compact double 50/34 Shimano Deore (31.8 clamp bottom pull derailleur) and a SRAM PG-850, 8-speed, 12x26t Shimano Tiagra.

Am I right in thinking this gives me 111.5" to 35" gears ?

Will my Tiagra rear mech cope with an SRAM PG-850 11-28, 11-30 or even better for my knees an 11-32 ?
 
Should have mentioned that I am 56 and get knee twinges so uphill a 32 on the back means I can twiddle away and make it up.
Previously I had 48-38-28 12-26, so a compact double is new for me and just wonder if Tiagra will cope with such a wide range or will I have to change the rear mech to a long cage
 
You'll probably need a new rear derailleur.

A short cage Tiagra will only wrap up 29 links of chain slack. Your 50/34 crankset takes up 16 teeth so that only leaves 13 teeth for the cassette. Anything wider in range than a 12/25 cassette is likely to be an issue. You can cheat a little bit by sizing the chain for the big/big combination and not using the little/little but, since you're looking for quite a bit more range than that, I doubt it will work.

The second issue is big cog capability. Shimano says a Tiagra derailleur won't work with cogs larger than 27 teeth before the upper pulley will start rubbing the cog. You can usually cheat a bit on that by dialing in the "B" adjustment screw on the derailleur mount. I wouldn't bet on that working all of the way up to 32 teeth, but it might.

You say that you'd like to use a cassette with a 32 tooth cog. Since you are probably going to have to replace your rear derailleur anyway, why don't you buy a Deore rear derailleur? That will handle up to a 34 rear cog and wrap up all of the chain slack without having to cheat on Shimano's specs. It'll shift fine with your Tiagra shifters.

One other thing that I'd suggest doing before you spend any money is to calculate all 18 gear ratios that you are considering. Besides the high and low ratio, think about where the overlap hits where you shift from the big to small chainring.
 
Thanks Retro, food for thought there. I think you are right about the need for a long cage rear mech.