in article
[email protected], levelwave at
[email protected] wrote on 12/7/03 2:28 PM:
> Sheryl Rosen wrote:
>
>> He's telling a story. We weren't there, he was. He is describing the scene. A good story teller
>> provides details so that you can visualize it the way he witnessed it. Ever read Hemingway?
>> Faulkner? It takes them 3 paragraphs to describe the evening air. But when you finish reading
>> those 3 paragraphs, you can almost SMELL it, they described it so vividly.
>>
>> By providing the detail that they were elderly, chinese ladies, you immediately get a visual in
>> your mind. If he had just said "two people", the story wouldn't have been as interesting to read.
>
>
> Thank you Sheryl. You just proved my point. Now where were you when I was getting flamed for this
> *exact* same thing?
>
> A few months ago I started my story with "An elderly black lady in a wheel chair" to "describe the
> scene" just as Mark did... and I got Flamed pretty bad... I guess it's OK to mention their race if
> it's Chinese and not Black... too funny...
>
> ~john!
>
>
>
People are far too sensitive about these things. I was having a conversation with a black woman I
have known since 1982. She asked me to describe someone I had talked to. She knew several of the
people there, and wanted to know who helped me....2 were black, one was white. All were men. I had
spoken with one of the black men...didn't get his name. Both the white man and one of the black men
were bald. One of the black men was darker skinned than the other. So here's the thing...I couldn't
say "the bald guy helped me", because there were two of them. I had to tell her it was one of the
two black men. But I was uncomfortable saying he was black. I didn't want her to think I fixated on
that. But the fact is, because I didn't want to seem fixated on it, I WAS fixated on it! There was
no way for me to describe this man to her without getting into a detailed description of the color
of this man's skin!
So, I finally asked her the question that's always burned in my mind: With such an obvious point of
distinction, the color of a person's skin or the shape of their eyes, is it ok to use that as part
of their description? I mean, it's a fact: "He is black, but lighter skinned..." "She looks
Asian..." I mean, you use someone's hair color as a descriptor because it's plain and obvious,
right? Her answer was "Of course it is!"
So, from then on, I always just describe people as they are. Guess what? They know they are black.
They know they are fat. They know they are short, they know they are tall. Whatever they are, that's
what they are. However they look, that's how they look. It's obvious to everyone, and it's ok to
mention if you are trying to describe them.
Of course, context is everything. If you say he's a "filthy, stinking .....(fill in the blank)"
well, that's not socially acceptable, that's mean.