M
marc
Guest
Matt B wrote:
> marc wrote:
>> Matt B wrote:
>>> marc wrote:
>>>> Matt B wrote:
>>>>> Paul Boyd wrote:
>>>>>> Noel said the following on 04/09/2007 08:49:
>>>>>>
>>>>>>> I wonder if this was the same rider who was in one of the local
>>>>>>> papers
>>>>>>> around Redhill/Reigate? She was describing how some drivers
>>>>>>> actually hoot
>>>>>>> and rev their engines to get the horses out of the way and drive
>>>>>>> past
>>>>>>> shouting and signalling abuse. Worse, one driver actually used
>>>>>>> his car to
>>>>>>> push the horse out of the way!
>>>>>>
>>>>>> That's quite unbelievable!
>>>>>
>>>>> Are you not familiar with human nature? ;-)
>>>>>
>>>>>> What the hell has happened to people to make them so selfish and
>>>>>> arrogant?
>>>>>
>>>>> The root is often their bitterness at being required to pay such a
>>>>> heavy tax burden to use the road - especially compared to
>>>>> non-motorised road users.
>>>>
>>>> How does a driver manage to work out at a glance how much tax a
>>>> non-motorised road user has paid compared to them?
>>>
>>> He doesn't, but that's not the point - is it. He can, however, be
>>> sure, that certain users have paid nothing specifically to be allowed
>>> to use the road by their present mode.
>>
>> Yes, himself and every other road user.
>
> No, he's a motorist, remember?
I remember but he has"paid nothing specifically to be allowed
to use the road by their present mode." just like every other road user.
>
>> As far as I am aware apart from road tolls there are no fees to use
>> the road apart from non hypothecated general taxation.
>
> In the UK you have to pay Vehicle Excise Duty (VED) on most types of
> motor vehicle manufactured since about 1973, to legally use them, or
> keep them, on the public road.
No you pay VED to keep a motorvehicle on the road, not to use the road.
If you have two vehicles you pay two VED duties, not one road use levy.
This tax raised about £5 billion last year.
>
> In the UK you also have to pay fuel duty on most types of hydrocarbon
> fuel, if it is used to power a normal road vehicle, to legally use that
> vehicle on the public road.
So you are paying a fuel duty, just like lots of other duties, none of
these duties, including fuel duty is a payment to use the road.
This tax raised about £30 billion last
> year. This'll make you laugh - they charge VAT on the duty, and that
> alone (ignoring the VAT also paid on the fuel itself) raised about £5
> billion last year!
>
> Your confusion, as does that of many drivers, arises from the fact that
> although those taxes have to be paid to legally use the road, they are
> _not_ hypothecated.
No it's not my confusion, the taxes and duties were not to use the road.
>
> In a large area of central London, the users of most types of
> conventionally powered motor vehicles _also_ have to pay another tax, on
> top of all the others, the innapropriately named "Congestion Charge".
> This could add up to more than £2000 for a year. This tax raised more
> than £120 million last year.
That's a charge to enter an area, not to use the road.
>
> In an increasing number of towns and cities around the UK, users of
> motor vehicles also have to pay another tax if they park their vehicles
> at the side of the public road. This tax raised more than £1 billion
> last year for local authorities.
If you store your boat when you are not using it you pay a charge, but
it's not a tax to use the river, equally parking charges are not taxes
to use roads.
>
> So there we have about £41 billion worth of tax raised purely from
> motorists to allow them to use the road.
No those taxes and duties are, to allow them to keep a car, a tax on
fuel for that car, a charge to enter an area, a charge to store the car
( so saving fuel) none of these are payments to use the road.
That doesn't include the
> lesser, other taxes, disguised as charges and fees, such as registration
> fees,
Not a charge to use the road
MOT fees,
Not a charge to use the road
insurance premium tax,
Not a charge to use the road
etc., which also need to be paid
> to be road-legal, or VAT (except on fuel duty).
Still not a charge to use the road
So we arrive back where we started. A motorist who "paid nothing
specifically to be allowed
to use the road by their present mode."
who is getting so wound up by others who "paid nothing specifically to
be allowed
to use the road by their present mode." that he has to get agressive.
> marc wrote:
>> Matt B wrote:
>>> marc wrote:
>>>> Matt B wrote:
>>>>> Paul Boyd wrote:
>>>>>> Noel said the following on 04/09/2007 08:49:
>>>>>>
>>>>>>> I wonder if this was the same rider who was in one of the local
>>>>>>> papers
>>>>>>> around Redhill/Reigate? She was describing how some drivers
>>>>>>> actually hoot
>>>>>>> and rev their engines to get the horses out of the way and drive
>>>>>>> past
>>>>>>> shouting and signalling abuse. Worse, one driver actually used
>>>>>>> his car to
>>>>>>> push the horse out of the way!
>>>>>>
>>>>>> That's quite unbelievable!
>>>>>
>>>>> Are you not familiar with human nature? ;-)
>>>>>
>>>>>> What the hell has happened to people to make them so selfish and
>>>>>> arrogant?
>>>>>
>>>>> The root is often their bitterness at being required to pay such a
>>>>> heavy tax burden to use the road - especially compared to
>>>>> non-motorised road users.
>>>>
>>>> How does a driver manage to work out at a glance how much tax a
>>>> non-motorised road user has paid compared to them?
>>>
>>> He doesn't, but that's not the point - is it. He can, however, be
>>> sure, that certain users have paid nothing specifically to be allowed
>>> to use the road by their present mode.
>>
>> Yes, himself and every other road user.
>
> No, he's a motorist, remember?
I remember but he has"paid nothing specifically to be allowed
to use the road by their present mode." just like every other road user.
>
>> As far as I am aware apart from road tolls there are no fees to use
>> the road apart from non hypothecated general taxation.
>
> In the UK you have to pay Vehicle Excise Duty (VED) on most types of
> motor vehicle manufactured since about 1973, to legally use them, or
> keep them, on the public road.
No you pay VED to keep a motorvehicle on the road, not to use the road.
If you have two vehicles you pay two VED duties, not one road use levy.
This tax raised about £5 billion last year.
>
> In the UK you also have to pay fuel duty on most types of hydrocarbon
> fuel, if it is used to power a normal road vehicle, to legally use that
> vehicle on the public road.
So you are paying a fuel duty, just like lots of other duties, none of
these duties, including fuel duty is a payment to use the road.
This tax raised about £30 billion last
> year. This'll make you laugh - they charge VAT on the duty, and that
> alone (ignoring the VAT also paid on the fuel itself) raised about £5
> billion last year!
>
> Your confusion, as does that of many drivers, arises from the fact that
> although those taxes have to be paid to legally use the road, they are
> _not_ hypothecated.
No it's not my confusion, the taxes and duties were not to use the road.
>
> In a large area of central London, the users of most types of
> conventionally powered motor vehicles _also_ have to pay another tax, on
> top of all the others, the innapropriately named "Congestion Charge".
> This could add up to more than £2000 for a year. This tax raised more
> than £120 million last year.
That's a charge to enter an area, not to use the road.
>
> In an increasing number of towns and cities around the UK, users of
> motor vehicles also have to pay another tax if they park their vehicles
> at the side of the public road. This tax raised more than £1 billion
> last year for local authorities.
If you store your boat when you are not using it you pay a charge, but
it's not a tax to use the river, equally parking charges are not taxes
to use roads.
>
> So there we have about £41 billion worth of tax raised purely from
> motorists to allow them to use the road.
No those taxes and duties are, to allow them to keep a car, a tax on
fuel for that car, a charge to enter an area, a charge to store the car
( so saving fuel) none of these are payments to use the road.
That doesn't include the
> lesser, other taxes, disguised as charges and fees, such as registration
> fees,
Not a charge to use the road
MOT fees,
Not a charge to use the road
insurance premium tax,
Not a charge to use the road
etc., which also need to be paid
> to be road-legal, or VAT (except on fuel duty).
Still not a charge to use the road
So we arrive back where we started. A motorist who "paid nothing
specifically to be allowed
to use the road by their present mode."
who is getting so wound up by others who "paid nothing specifically to
be allowed
to use the road by their present mode." that he has to get agressive.