Commuted 200+ miles per week for ten years. Schwalbe Marathon Plus' were my choice after much investigation. I'd buy them in 3s as the rears wore @ 2x the fronts.
Conservatively, I commuted 80,000+ miles in that span. Used Schwalbe Durano Supremes in wet weather. ONE flat. Lucky? Certainly. At the same time I had a road bike with 110 psi airless, too. They slow one by 2-3 mph. Excellent training tires, though. Gave the bike and tires to a close cycling friend. He still has the bike. Wore the tires out. lol
I use SMPs on ALL my bikes. Except my winter mtb. On that I have Nokia studded. Truthfully, I believe my last flat was about 6 years ago. I have an mtb close purpose utility, cyclo cross long purpose utility, touring bike, fixed gear conversion fun bike and the aforementioned winter mtb.
Living car-free requires a higher level of gear hence the expensive tires. I use a trailer for grocery shopping. It has 20 inch SMPS on it.
NOTHING other than airless are puncture proof, but for wear rate against flat rate I'll hang my hat on SMPs.