Which bicycle saddle best for 'impotence' risk?



J

Jack Blake

Guest
Just saw this in Reuters today. Any ideas on how to fight this alleged
impotence risk? Saddles? Suspension seat posts?


<<article below>>
Long-Distance Cyclists Face Impotence Risk

Thu Aug 26, 1:39 PM ET


By Amy Norton

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Saddle pressure can cause temporary
erection difficulties for men who take part in long distance cycling
events, but bike adjustments may decrease the risk, a study suggests.

However, bicycle seats with "cutouts" designed to relieve the pressure
that may contribute to impotence could actually put certain men at
greater risk for the problem.

Researchers found that among 463 men who'd taken part in long-distance
cycling events, just over four percent developed short-lived erectile
dysfunction (ED) within the following week. And while many of those
who reported using a cutout saddle were at lower risk of temporary ED,
others -- namely, those who felt numbness in the groin during the ride
-- were more likely to develop ED if they used a cutout seat.


The researchers also found a greater impotence risk among men who used
a mountain bike for the road race, and those with handlebars higher
than the saddle.


The findings are published in The Journal of Urology.


Although the study found only associations between certain bike
characteristics and temporary ED -- and not definitive cause-effect
relationships -- it "seems reasonable" for men to make some simple
biking adjustments if they're concerned, lead study author Dr. Joseph
R. Dettori told Reuters Health.


That means sticking with a road bike on normal terrain, keeping
handlebar height lower than the saddle and, for men who feel numbness
while riding, using a saddle with no cutout.


Although men in the study were in long-distance recreational events,
lasting for a week in many cases, less avid bicyclists could follow
those guidelines as well, according to Dettori, who is with Olympic
Research in Steilacoom, Washington.


He said the real concern is that repeated episodes of "microtrauma" to
the nerves and blood vessels will eventually promote chronic ED.


The reasons for the associations found in the study are not fully
clear. Dettori said he and his colleagues speculate that cutout
saddles do not fit the anatomy of all men, and may actually put
"select individuals" at greater risk of temporary impotence.


As for the other findings, a lower handlebar height brings the torso
forward, and may help relieve pressure on the groin area. Similarly,
mountain bikes may cause men to have a more upright posture, which
could explain the association with ED, according to Dettori.


However, he noted, it's also possible that men who used mountain bikes
for a road event were less experienced riders, and may not have been
as skilled in "unloading" their weight from the saddle when pedaling.


Since biking is good exercise, men should not take the findings as a
warning to give up the activity, according to Dettori. Instead, he
said, the results suggest some modifications that could help men "keep
on cycling."


SOURCE: The Journal of Urology, August 2004.
 
"Brendon M. Troy" <[email protected]> wrote in message news:<[email protected]>...
> "Jack Blake" <[email protected]> wrote
> > Just saw this in Reuters today. Any ideas on how to fight this alleged
> > impotence risk? Saddles? Suspension seat posts?

> <snip another article>
>
> It's not about the saddle. I'll preempt Mike J by linking to his site's
> excellent page on the subject:
>
> http://www.chainreaction.com/saddles.htm
>
> and a page he links to from there with more specifics:
>
> http://bicyclehabitat.com/site/page.cfm?PageID=97
>

Here's a couple of more links to read:

http://www.rivendellbicycles.com/html/101_saddles.html

http://www.rivendellbicycles.com/html/rr_comfposition.html

and don't forget Sheldon Brown's article on saddles:

http://www.sheldonbrown.com/saddles.html

Of course, if none of the above is not convincing, then get a "real
man" saddle (ain't for you girly men!):

http://www.sheldonbrown.com/real-man.html
 
"Jack Blake" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Just saw this in Reuters today. Any ideas on how to fight this alleged
> impotence risk? Saddles? Suspension seat posts?


Snipping and emphasizing:

"Researchers found that among 463 men who'd taken part in LONG-DISTANCE
cycling events, just over FOUR PERCENT developed SHORT-LIVED erectile
dysfunction (ED)"

It's not really a problem, it certainly doesn't amount to an "impotence risk".

"He said the real concern is that repeated episodes of "microtrauma" to
the nerves and blood vessels will eventually promote chronic ED."

Speculation, pure speculation.
 

Similar threads

R
Replies
28
Views
2K
Road Cycling
John Thompson
J