which compact? (on a budget)

[roadhog]

I've decided to go compact (50/34). Currently running full ultegra 9 speed setup with a 53/39.

My funds are somewhat limited and I'd like to keep it under $200 so I know my choices might be limited. Is it possible to get at least a 105-quality comparable crankset? I'm not loyal to any brand but of course need it to be compatible with my current setup. I don't have a good handle for the quality of different versions offered by different brands (shimano, FSA, Truvativ, etc.).

Also, will I need a new front derailleur?

Thanks.

 

[daveryanwyoming]

I....Is it possible to get at least a 105-quality comparable crankset?...

Sure, these are at least 105 quality: http://www.excelsports.com/new.asp?...pact+Crankset&vendorCode=FSA&major=1&minor=13

 

[John M]

I've decided to go compact (50/34). Currently running full ultegra 9 speed setup with a 53/39.

My funds are somewhat limited and I'd like to keep it under $200 so I know my choices might be limited. Is it possible to get at least a 105-quality comparable crankset? I'm not loyal to any brand but of course need it to be compatible with my current setup. I don't have a good handle for the quality of different versions offered by different brands (shimano, FSA, Truvativ, etc.).

Also, will I need a new front derailleur?

Thanks.

Lots of FSA and Truvativ in that price range. Also good deals on 2006 model square-taper Campagnolo cranksets are available. It works fine in the Shimano drivetrain. Centaur or Veloce compact + BB will be less than $150, maybe less than $125 if you really shop around.

 

[timpand]

I've had good luck with a pair of stronglight cranks.

http://www.stronglight.com/stronglight/page.php?nom=produit&keyProd=impactcompact

I would recomend a compact front der, but you may want to try it first with your normal double front der.

 

[the pistol]

I have a slightly used 50/36 Truvativ GXP Elita setup with bottom bracket. Only about 125 miles on it. Switched to a 53/39 for the flats here in Florida. Cranks are 172.5mm. One odd thing though, on the inside of the 36 it says "ten speed only" I'm not sure but I would think it would work on a 9 speed. Can anyone shed some light on this? I'll let it go for $85 shipped within the 48 states. Good luck on your build.

 

[nerdag]

One odd thing though, on the inside of the 36 it says "ten speed only" I'm not sure but I would think it would work on a 9 speed. Can anyone shed some light on this?

It doesn't work with 9s - I've tried. When changing up to the 50 from the 36, a 9s chain will skate over the teeth of the 50.

I swapped the cranks onto a 10s bike I have, and no such problems.

n

 

[the pistol]

thanks for the information Nerdag, I knew somebody would have the skinny. Still available though but Only for a 10 Spd.