cycling_jedi said:
People ride MTB over Roadies for the same reason they drive Hummers over family sedans.....
They look cooler and tougher... a status symbol.
The irony is that the majority of people that own a mtb with nice shocks and expensive features will never ride it off road as they are intended just as the people who drive Hummers will never drive them off road, or even in inclement weather, as they were intended.
A few years ago, I read in Bicycling magazine (it might have been the now-defunct Bicycle Guide) some interesting stats about what kind of bikes people ride. While I can't remember the exact stats, I remember that something like 70 percent of the bikes sold in the USA are mountain bikes, and that the majority of people who ride mountain bikes never or rarely ride them off road.
I once worked with a guy who rode a mountain bike exclusively (I'm strictly a roadie), and he claimed that he could keep up with me on the road if he rode his mountain bike and I rode my road bike. At that time, I wasn't a regular rider, but I decided to prove a point to him (in a friendly way; we got along real well together). We went on a road ride one day, and he learned that mountain bikes were not the equal of road bikes on paved roads. I easily outrode him (coasting downhill was an eye-opener for him), even though he rode far more frequently at that time than I did; he was in better shape than me. He simply could not easily keep up with me, and we both agreed the difference was the bike.
I don't like 'em. Compared to road bikes, MTBs are heavy and inefficient and are not the best choice for road riding. While "a Jeep can go anywhere," if the road is your route for getting there, then a road bike is a better choice.
MTBs appear to be the SUV of the bike world, and in the USA at least, people like their SUVs. It doesn't seem to matter that on the road, a road bike will get you there faster and more efficiently than an MTB, or that MTBs are not necessarily safer than road bikes (safety on a bike is what you make it). Americans like their beefy vehicles, and an MTB is just another beefy vehicle; it suggests strength and power, and that's what Americans like. MTBs aren't necessarily cheaper than road bikes, and most MTB owners don't take full advantage of their off-road versatility. The real practical value of an MTB only comes through on non-paved surfaces, like gravel roads and dirt trails, where a road bike should not venture. If most people don't ride their MTBs off the road, they won't really get their money's worth out of their MTBs, so they might as well buy a road bike (even a heavy tourer is better than the lightest MTB).
I don't like MTBs because for me they have no value. But who am I to fault the guy on an MTB riding on city streets? At least he's out there on a bike of some kind and not sitting there with a beer in one hand, a pot belly between his head and feet, and the TV tuned to a football game where he decries the guy who fumbled the ball, who at least is out there playing the game and not sitting on the couch ... .
MTB or road bike, it's better to ride than to not ride.
Happy riding, whatever you ride
Scott