In message <[email hidden]>, andrew
<[email hidden]> writes
Quoted message said:I'm thinking of getting a coouple of these they look ideal for commuting,
small, light, bright & easily removable.
Commuting where? do you need to see or be seen.
Quoted message said:Any suggestions / experience of them?
No, but an EL200 which is probably similar in output
<http://www.cateye.com/en/products/viewProduct.php?modelId=20&catId=7&sub
CatId=2>
In terms of being seen they are ok, but no where near as good as my 3w
dynamo powered lamp. In terms of being useful for seeing by - pretty
useless really. I use mine as a secondary/standlight/emergency backup -
I wouldn't want to use it as my sole lighting on regular basis.
My thoughts on the EL400. I don't like built in mounting straps/clips -
more time consuming to fit, and sooner or later they stop working
properly, I try to avoid AAA batteries where I can - don't last as long,
comparatively more expensive than AA. It has some nice features/gimmicks
- depending on your POV - but it would not make a good commuting lamp
IMO.
Personally I don't think on the whole LEDS are quite there yet for front
lamps (leastways for what you buy of the shelf), good enough for
ocasional/backup use but for regular use such as commuting a
incandescent are still the way to go. Either rechargeable systems or
dynamo powered.
The only LED worth considering really would be the EL-500 9or maybe the
older EL300) , which the Cateye website claims puts out 1000 candlepower
(they give 90 for the EL400) and to have passed BS and German lighting
standards
About GBP 40 from cycleexpress
--
Chris French, Leeds