General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Re: Paleo diet -- one month results

Started by jbuch · · Last activity · 5 posts · 316 views

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
22 August 2004
Last activity
27 August 2004
Original author
jbuch
Posts
5
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
316
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–5 of 5
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Congratulations on the diet change that eliminated you obsession with
    food, and the need to exercise willpower.

    Some of this seeming success could be just the change. Kind of like how
    a vacation can make you feel so good.

    Please report back on this topic each month, expecially the elimination
    of the need to exercise will power.

    SIgnificant point, that elimination of need to use will power.

    Jim

    Ignoramus15381 said:

    As you might know, I lost 50 lbs by "eating less" and exercising.
    Almost a year ago I reached normal weight, the anniversary is on Sep
    10.

    I ate less, reduced carbs some, but not radically.

    Despite the fact that I maintained my weight loss steadily and even
    lost a bit more, I felt hungry most of the day and got some food
    obsessions, thinking a bit too much about food, which are, actually,
    mental signs of starvation. (I can post a great text about that that
    describes starvation related mental symptoms).

    My main food desires were meaty, fatty things. That's even though I
    was eating plenty of meat and fat.

    So I was going by willpower, but started realizing that I cannot do
    that for life and that, sooner or later, I would invent some
    rationalization for giving up.

    At some point, I read about paleo diet, read one book, and decided to
    try it. The idea of a paleo diet is to eat an approximation of how,
    supposedly, people ate up to 10,000 years ago, as hunter
    gatherers, which is eating meat and fish, vegetables, fruits and
    nuts. No grains, legumes, milk products, sugar.

    So, I went on it a month ago, giving myself a month to see how it
    works. I eat pretty much as much as I want, but only of what is
    allowed.

    The result is, I am no longer hungry and no longer think too much
    about food. It just comes naturally to me that I eat as much as I
    need, without a big conscious effort, portion weighing etc.

    In that month, I gained about 0.07 lbs, which is obviously a
    nonconsequential amount, not statistically significant.

    So, so far, this diet is a winnder for me. I no longer need to
    exercise my willpower on a daily basis. Especially because all those
    foods are what I like, whereas grain products etc, I used to eat
    because I considered them "healthy" and "prudent".

    I want to thank, specifically, Cubit and Jenny for steering my mind
    towards realizing that my hunger was due to me eating my morning bread
    and too many junk carbs.

    I will test my blood lipids after a while, as part of my physical, and
    see how they change.

    For breakfast tomorrow, I am going to eat a stewed squirrel.

    i

    --
    ................................

    Keepsake gift for young girls.
    Unique and personal one-of-a-kind.
    Builds strong minds 12 ways.
    Guaranteed satisfaction
    - courteous money back
    - keep bonus gifts

    http://www.alicebook.com

  2. jbuch said:

    Please report back on this topic each month, expecially the elimination
    of the need to exercise will power.

    SIgnificant point, that elimination of need to use will power.

    Hmm, I've been on low-carb for 6 months now, with great results, and
    I'm surprised to hear someone mention this with so much emphasis. I
    haven't had this problem at all since starting low carb (omg, on the
    low fat that caused this weight gain, it was a constant problem.) I'm
    not on Atkins, though; I'm on Anti-X, from the Jack Chellam book,
    "Syndrome X."

    Basically the diet is a lot like what the original poster described:
    you can eat as much as you desire of many foods, mostly vegetables,
    and don't eat other foods at all. Although the book referred to Paleo
    Diets a few times, I don't think it's considered one, since it allows
    dairy, asks that you try to limit animal fat to a reasonable amount,
    and not overdose on protein (some of those points being criticisms
    I've heard of Atkins.)

    Except for a very rare chocolate or ice cream craving, which is purely
    psychological, I never feel deprived or restricted or depressed or
    need much willpower at all. I eat as much as I feel like, when I feel
    like it, which is a lot less than I used to since getting my blood
    sugar under control, so my calories are naturally reduced. I eat
    foods that make me feel satisfied without a huge portion (yeah, that
    includes having a little more fatty meats and low-carb nuts than they
    recommend, unfortunately, but it's still working for now.) I don't
    even count carbs strictly now, only at the beginning after reading
    some Atkins advice on this group, and just get a general idea that I'm
    eating about 30-50g/day (any less than that and I stop losing.) And
    I'm losing weight very, very well! In fact, I haven't been this
    happy/satisfied with my change in weight and overall satisfaction with
    my life, ummm, since I turned about 7 years old!

    I thought people on Atkins, which seem to be the majority of
    low-carbers, had the same experience? Do Atkins people need to do
    strict portion control, weighing of food, carb and calorie counting,
    etc? Do Atkins people often feel unsatisfied and need willpower to
    keep cravings under control? I've done some reading on this group
    before, and I didn't get that impression...

    See ya,

    Kristen

    --
    "Who is the patriot, I ask you? Those who wrap themselves in the flag and pledge
    allegiance to it, or those who keep the pledge and wrap themselves in what the
    flag represents?" -Ira Glasser

  3. Kristen wrote:
    :: jbuch <[email hidden]> wrote:
    ::
    ::: Please report back on this topic each month, expecially the
    ::: elimination of the need to exercise will power.
    :::
    ::: SIgnificant point, that elimination of need to use will power.
    ::
    :: Hmm, I've been on low-carb for 6 months now, with great results, and
    :: I'm surprised to hear someone mention this with so much emphasis. I
    :: haven't had this problem at all since starting low carb (omg, on the
    :: low fat that caused this weight gain, it was a constant problem.)
    :: I'm
    :: not on Atkins, though; I'm on Anti-X, from the Jack Chellam book,
    :: "Syndrome X."
    ::
    :: Basically the diet is a lot like what the original poster described:
    :: you can eat as much as you desire of many foods, mostly vegetables,
    :: and don't eat other foods at all. Although the book referred to
    :: Paleo
    :: Diets a few times, I don't think it's considered one, since it allows
    :: dairy, asks that you try to limit animal fat to a reasonable amount,
    :: and not overdose on protein (some of those points being criticisms
    :: I've heard of Atkins.)

    Nonsense criticisms. As written, Atkin is a high fat diet, while Paleo
    (Cordain's version) is a high protein diet.

    ::
    :: Except for a very rare chocolate or ice cream craving, which is
    :: purely psychological, I never feel deprived or restricted or
    :: depressed or
    :: need much willpower at all. I eat as much as I feel like, when I
    :: feel
    :: like it, which is a lot less than I used to since getting my blood
    :: sugar under control, so my calories are naturally reduced. I eat
    :: foods that make me feel satisfied without a huge portion (yeah, that
    :: includes having a little more fatty meats and low-carb nuts than they
    :: recommend, unfortunately, but it's still working for now.) I don't
    :: even count carbs strictly now, only at the beginning after reading
    :: some Atkins advice on this group, and just get a general idea that
    :: I'm
    :: eating about 30-50g/day (any less than that and I stop losing.) And
    :: I'm losing weight very, very well! In fact, I haven't been this
    :: happy/satisfied with my change in weight and overall satisfaction
    :: with
    :: my life, ummm, since I turned about 7 years old!
    ::
    :: I thought people on Atkins, which seem to be the majority of
    :: low-carbers, had the same experience?

    Yes, but the OP is (was) not on Atkins and was eating way more than 30-50g
    of carb per day, and was not trying to lose weight.

    :: Do Atkins people need to do
    :: strict portion control, weighing of food, carb and calorie counting,
    :: etc?

    It depends. A few dont' get appetite supression and have to count calories
    to make sure they don't eat too much. Also, as you get closer to normal
    weight this becomes more and more necessary. For those that have lots to
    lose, the counting any is rarely necessary if you stick to the LC foods. On
    any plan that restricts calories to produce weight loss, it becomes
    increasing harder to lose once you get close to where you need to be. My
    guess is that you'll find the same for yourself.

    Do Atkins people often feel unsatisfied and need willpower to
    :: keep cravings under control? I've done some reading on this group
    :: before, and I didn't get that impression...

    That's cause the OP wasn't on Atkins, didn't need to lose any weight, was
    eating fast digesting carbs first thing in the am, etc.

  4. "Kristen" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hmm, I've been on low-carb for 6 months now, with great results, and
    I'm surprised to hear someone mention this with so much emphasis. I
    haven't had this problem at all since starting low carb

    Quoted message said:

    Although the book referred to Paleo
    Diets a few times, I don't think it's considered one, since it allows
    dairy, asks that you try to limit animal fat to a reasonable amount,
    and not overdose on protein (some of those points being criticisms
    I've heard of Atkins.)

    Atkins does not overdose on protein.

    Quoted message said:

    I thought people on Atkins, which seem to be the majority of
    low-carbers, had the same experience? Do Atkins people need to do
    strict portion control, weighing of food, carb and calorie counting,
    etc? Do Atkins people often feel unsatisfied and need willpower to
    keep cravings under control? I've done some reading on this group
    before, and I didn't get that impression...

    It depends on how much the person has left to lose. I think that probably
    goes for most low-carb diets. Atkins even stated in his book that once you
    no longer need to lose weight that you won't have the advantage of appetite
    suppression on your side anymore. From that point on, you will have to use
    what you've learned and made habits about food choices and portion sizes.
    Also, I've noticed that many people when they get closer to their goal
    weights have to become more strict in counting carbs and calories to get all
    the way there.

    --
    Spring
    LC since 1/1/04
    260/208/170
    http://f2.pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/sprgsnow/album?.tok=phX4sVBBuvxvs4Hs&.dir=/55b8&.src=ph
    Size: 24W / 14 / 10

  5. "Sprgtime" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    "Kristen" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hmm, I've been on low-carb for 6 months now, with great results, and
    I'm surprised to hear someone mention this with so much emphasis. I
    haven't had this problem at all since starting low carb

    Quoted message said:

    Although the book referred to Paleo
    Diets a few times, I don't think it's considered one, since it allows
    dairy, asks that you try to limit animal fat to a reasonable amount,
    and not overdose on protein (some of those points being criticisms
    I've heard of Atkins.)

    Atkins does not overdose on protein.

    Quoted message said:

    I thought people on Atkins, which seem to be the majority of
    low-carbers, had the same experience? Do Atkins people need to do
    strict portion control, weighing of food, carb and calorie counting,
    etc? Do Atkins people often feel unsatisfied and need willpower to
    keep cravings under control? I've done some reading on this group
    before, and I didn't get that impression...

    It depends on how much the person has left to lose. I think that probably
    goes for most low-carb diets. Atkins even stated in his book that once


    you

    Quoted message said:

    no longer need to lose weight that you won't have the advantage of


    appetite

    Quoted message said:

    suppression on your side anymore.

    Can you provide a reference for this?

    Since most of the people at maintenance are still eating relatively low carb
    compared to the standard north american diet and consuming little in the way
    of refined carbs they should still experience appetite suppression
    (acknowledging exceptions). One could argue that the standard north
    american diet is appetite stimulating given the role of refined carbs in
    spiking insulin. Ketosis offers greater appetite suppression than
    maintenance but maintenance should offer some suppression as well.

    Sid...

    From that point on, you will have to use

    Quoted message said:

    what you've learned and made habits about food choices and portion sizes.
    Also, I've noticed that many people when they get closer to their goal
    weights have to become more strict in counting carbs and calories to get


    all

    Quoted message said:

    the way there.

    --
    Spring
    LC since 1/1/04
    260/208/170


    http://f2.pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/sprgsnow/album?.tok=phX4sVBBuvxvs4Hs&.dir=/55b8&.src=ph

    Quoted message said:

    Size: 24W / 14 / 10

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.