General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Please help with starting raw vegan diet

Started by Ann · · Last activity · 15 posts · 388 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
5 June 2004
Last activity
6 June 2004
Original author
Ann
Posts
15
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
388
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–15 of 15
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Hello,

    I've been vegan as in no food or toiletries or anything with any
    animal products for about five years, but, it hasn't been for health
    reasons and I haven't been the healthiest eater -- my diet includes
    lots of carbs, bready things, potatoes, pasta, sugary things. I was
    recently told to switch to an all raw fruit and veggie diet to treat
    an acne problem that I've had for a long time. It sounds promising,
    and I'm hoping that it will help with a lot of other health problems
    too, but I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding *more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping because I'm
    bumbling it. Exactly what fruits and veggies and how many? Where
    should I get them, supermarket or health food store? Should they be
    organic? How should I wash them, eg I read about soaking
    non-pealables for 15 min. in a sink full of water mixed with a little
    peroxide.

    I also have a dilemma because I also want to try the "Master Cleanse"
    and I'm probably going to try a treatment for chronic systemic candida
    infection -- what do I do first? Can I do the cleanse and start the
    treatment at the same time?

    Please help!!

    Ann

  2. (Ann) said:

    Hello,

    I've been vegan as in no food or toiletries or anything with any
    animal products for about five years, but, it hasn't been for health
    reasons and I haven't been the healthiest eater -- my diet includes
    lots of carbs, bready things, potatoes, pasta, sugary things. I was
    recently told to switch to an all raw fruit and veggie diet to treat
    an acne problem that I've had for a long time. It sounds promising,
    and I'm hoping that it will help with a lot of other health problems
    too, but I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding *more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping because I'm
    bumbling it. Exactly what fruits and veggies and how many?

    Why do you think that eating exclusively fruits and vegetables is
    going to help with your health problems??? It is important to get
    adequate amounts of protein and good fat in your diet and this may be
    a problem if you limit intake to only fruits and vegetables. I know of
    no scientific evidence that such a diet is healthy or will help
    specific health problems.

    Quoted message said:

    Where
    should I get them, supermarket or health food store? Should they be
    organic? How should I wash them, eg I read about soaking
    non-pealables for 15 min. in a sink full of water mixed with a little
    peroxide.

    Eating lots of fruits and vegetables is likely good for you. If you
    can get organic then all the better. Always wash your fruits and
    vegetables with fresh water. But remember to eat enough protein and
    good fats.

    Quoted message said:


    I also have a dilemma because I also want to try the "Master Cleanse"
    and I'm probably going to try a treatment for chronic systemic candida
    infection -- what do I do first?

    What makes you think you have chronic systemic candidiasis?? Who made
    the diagnosis and how was the diagnosis made?? Systemic candida is
    usually seen in immunocompomised individuals. Systemic candida is
    often falsely diagnosed by alternative medicine practitioners. Proper
    treatment always starts with proper diagnosis.

    Quoted message said:

    Can I do the cleanse and start the
    treatment at the same time?

    I question the health benefits of anything that you are considering.

    I recommend first validating the diagnosis by seeing a qualified
    health professional. Find out on what basis the diagnosis was made.

    I suggest you get a balanced diet with whole grains, fruits,
    vegetables and adequate protein and good fats while avoiding consuming
    too many calories. Also, unless you have a medical contraindication,
    to get exercise (strength, endurance and flexibility training).

    Quoted message said:


    Please help!!

    Do you notice that you often worry excessively about your health??

    Aloha,

    Rich

    Quoted message said:


    Ann

    -------------------------------------------------
    -------------------------------------------------

    The best defense to logic is ignorance

  3. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Ann said:

    I also have a dilemma because I also want to try the "Master Cleanse"
    and I'm probably going to try a treatment for chronic systemic candida
    infection -- what do I do first? Can I do the cleanse and start the
    treatment at the same time?

    I would strongly advise you to avoid the candida treatments at all.

    Although there most certainly is a disease called "systemic
    candidiasis" which is awful and can be fatal, it's also quite
    unmistakeable and usually found only in immunocompromised persons.

    A trip to your doctor to find out whether you really have any sort of
    candida problem would be much more appropriate.

    -- David Wright :: alphabeta at prodigy.net
    These are my opinions only, but they're almost always correct.
    "If I have not seen as far as others, it is because giants
    were standing on my shoulders." (Hal Abelson, MIT)

  4. Ann said:

    I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding *more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping because
    I'm bumbling it.

    But how can anyone help you when you haven't told us
    even the most basic information about your particular
    health conditions? For example, you haven't mentioned
    your blood type. What's right for a type O is completely
    different from what is needed by an AB. Type O in general
    are people descended from agrarian farmers, and for them
    a high-carb, grain-based diet is near optimal. On the other
    hand, type AB are people descended from hunters and
    fishermen, so a high-protein diet rich in fish oils is usually
    best. Type A should be eating lots of tomatoes, garlic, pasta
    and olive oil, while type B are shiftless people of no account
    who are best avoided.

    Also, it is not possible to make blanket recommendations
    based just on general factors without taking into account
    your unique personal traits. For example, a squat, swarthy
    type O is much more like a type A, and would benefit from
    a diet which includes type A foods -- in this case replacing
    the bread-and-butter diet of a typical type O with more
    olive oil and pasta. You can't expect to get these personal
    dietary recommendations through the Internet. You need
    to consult with a professional iridologist specializing in
    nutritional profiling. And of course, because of the
    depletion of agricultural soils by a century of chemical
    farming, you'll need dietary supplements containing essential
    nutrients such as tecnazene and quintozene.

    Right now, you're completely adrift. If you don't get help
    right away, you could be setting yourself up for a lifetime
    of malaise, low-energy, and chronic pain. For all you
    know, the root cause of your problems could be unrelated
    to diet -- you might have an electrical imbalance or you
    could be poisoned by a magnetic field. Have you tried
    reversing the direction in which you sleep, for example,
    so that your head is toward the north (if it was toward
    the south)? There are so many factors involved that
    no one person could be expected to be familiar with all
    of them. At the least, you'll need comprehensive diagnosis
    by a board-certified iridologist, chiropractor, and
    homeopathic physician. Even then, you'll need to treat
    their advice with caution, because of the variable quality
    of alternative medical education in this country. The
    average chiropractor only gets ONE HOUR of course
    study in iridology in his/her educational curriculum! Can
    you believe it! It's a scandal, I tell ya. Hope this helps :-)

  5. [email hidden] (Ann) wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    I've been vegan as in no food or toiletries or anything with any
    animal products for about five years, but, it hasn't been for health
    reasons and I haven't been the healthiest eater -- my diet includes
    lots of carbs, bready things, potatoes, pasta, sugary things. I was
    recently told to switch to an all raw fruit and veggie diet to treat
    an acne problem that I've had for a long time. It sounds promising,
    and I'm hoping that it will help with a lot of other health problems
    too, but I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding *more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping because I'm
    bumbling it. Exactly what fruits and veggies and how many? Where
    should I get them, supermarket or health food store? Should they be
    organic? How should I wash them, eg I read about soaking
    non-pealables for 15 min. in a sink full of water mixed with a little
    peroxide.

    You might want to take a look at Tom Billings' site,
    http://www.beyondveg.com, for a discussion of some of the pitfalls of raw
    vegan, particularly fruitarian, diets (Billings is a vegetarian who used to
    be a raw vegan).

  6. "Ann" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hello,

    I've been vegan as in no food or toiletries or anything with any
    animal products for about five years,


    =======
    But I see it's really all about 'looks' and 'feelinge' as evidenced by your
    usenet posting. Not eating animals is not the same as not causing their
    death and suffering. Afterall, usenet is not cruelty-free, but here you
    are...

    but, it hasn't been for health

    Quoted message said:

    reasons and I haven't been the healthiest eater -- my diet includes
    lots of carbs, bready things, potatoes, pasta, sugary things. I was
    recently told to switch to an all raw fruit and veggie diet to treat
    an acne problem that I've had for a long time. It sounds promising,
    and I'm hoping that it will help with a lot of other health problems
    too, but I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding *more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping because I'm
    bumbling it. Exactly what fruits and veggies and how many? Where
    should I get them, supermarket or health food store? Should they be
    organic? How should I wash them, eg I read about soaking
    non-pealables for 15 min. in a sink full of water mixed with a little
    peroxide.

    I also have a dilemma because I also want to try the "Master Cleanse"
    and I'm probably going to try a treatment for chronic systemic candida
    infection -- what do I do first? Can I do the cleanse and start the
    treatment at the same time?

    Please help!!

    Ann

  7. Quoted message said:

    Subject: Please help with starting raw vegan diet
    From: [email hidden] (Ann)
    Date: 6/5/2004 11:45 AM Pacific Standard Time
    Message-id: <[email hidden]>

    Hello,

    I've been vegan as in no food or toiletries or anything with any
    animal products for about five years, but, it hasn't been for health
    reasons and I haven't been the healthiest eater -- my diet includes
    lots of carbs, bready things, potatoes, pasta, sugary things. I was
    recently told to switch to an all raw fruit and veggie diet to treat
    an acne problem that I've had for a long time. It sounds promising,
    and I'm hoping that it will help with a lot of other health problems
    too, but I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding *more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping because I'm
    bumbling it. Exactly what fruits and veggies and how many? Where
    should I get them, supermarket or health food store? Should they be
    organic? How should I wash them, eg I read about soaking
    non-pealables for 15 min. in a sink full of water mixed with a little
    peroxide.

    I also have a dilemma because I also want to try the "Master Cleanse"
    and I'm probably going to try a treatment for chronic systemic candida
    infection -- what do I do first? Can I do the cleanse and start the
    treatment at the same time?

    Please help!!

    Ann

    You can do your own research. You will also be questioned and the badgering
    will begin, because the *gang* also denies candida and doing any cleansing.

    See a good alternative practitioner. Your questions wil be answered.

    As for cleaning fruits and veggies, soak in hot water for one minute, no
    longer, drain and wipe with paper towel, repeat a second time.

    I can tell you I have been on the South Beach diet for about a month. NO SUGAR
    does wonders for the body.

    Good Luck, and ignore the many questions as you will be put on trial here by
    the *gang* who could care less about YOU, they just have an insane need to be
    right.

    Jan

  8. Quoted message said:

    Subject: Re: Please help with starting raw vegan diet
    From: [email hidden] (David Wright)
    Date: 6/5/2004 12:41 PM Pacific Standard Time
    Message-id: <[email hidden]>

    Right on CUE.

    DENIAL.

    See your doctor.

    ALL WRONG ADVICE.

    Please understand the *gang* is a part of organized medicine who deny most all
    alternative.

    Jan

    <snip bad advice form David Wright, *gang* member.

  9. Quoted message said:

    Subject: Re: Please help with starting raw vegan diet
    From: Eric Bohlman [email hidden]
    Date: 6/5/2004 2:35 PM Pacific Standard Time
    Message-id: <[email hidden]>

    [email hidden] (Ann) wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    I've been vegan as in no food or toiletries or anything with any
    animal products for about five years, but, it hasn't been for health
    reasons and I haven't been the healthiest eater -- my diet includes
    lots of carbs, bready things, potatoes, pasta, sugary things. I was
    recently told to switch to an all raw fruit and veggie diet to treat
    an acne problem that I've had for a long time. It sounds promising,
    and I'm hoping that it will help with a lot of other health problems
    too, but I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding *more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping because I'm
    bumbling it. Exactly what fruits and veggies and how many? Where
    should I get them, supermarket or health food store? Should they be
    organic? How should I wash them, eg I read about soaking
    non-pealables for 15 min. in a sink full of water mixed with a little
    peroxide.

    You might want to take a look at Tom Billings' site,
    http://www.beyondveg.com, for a discussion of some of the pitfalls of raw
    vegan, particularly fruitarian, diets (Billings is a vegetarian who used to
    be a raw vegan).

    Or you might want to take a look at this.

    http://www.hacres.com/

    Jan

  10. "Mark Thorson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Ann said:

    I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding *more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping because
    I'm bumbling it.

    But how can anyone help you when you haven't told us
    even the most basic information about your particular
    health conditions? For example, you haven't mentioned
    your blood type. What's right for a type O is completely
    different from what is needed by an AB. Type O in general
    are people descended from agrarian farmers, and for them
    a high-carb, grain-based diet is near optimal. On the other
    hand, type AB are people descended from hunters and
    fishermen, so a high-protein diet rich in fish oils is usually
    best. Type A should be eating lots of tomatoes, garlic, pasta
    and olive oil, while type B are shiftless people of no account
    who are best avoided.

    There's no evidence whatsoever for that "eat right for your type" BS.

    quackwatch.orgd'adamo.html

    Please stop peddling snake oil.

    Quoted message said:

    Also, it is not possible to make blanket recommendations
    based just on general factors without taking into account
    your unique personal traits. For example, a squat, swarthy
    type O is much more like a type A, and would benefit from
    a diet which includes type A foods -- in this case replacing
    the bread-and-butter diet of a typical type O with more
    olive oil and pasta. You can't expect to get these personal
    dietary recommendations through the Internet. You need
    to consult with a professional iridologist specializing in
    nutritional profiling. And of course, because of the
    depletion of agricultural soils by a century of chemical
    farming, you'll need dietary supplements containing essential
    nutrients such as tecnazene and quintozene.

    Iridology is also a load of complete and utter [censored].

    http://skepdic.com/iridol.html

    Do you want to help this guy or make him go broke giving all his money to
    money grubbing con artists?

    Quoted message said:

    Right now, you're completely adrift.

    And you're not helping one bit.

    Quoted message said:

    If you don't get help
    right away, you could be setting yourself up for a lifetime
    of malaise, low-energy, and chronic pain. For all you
    know, the root cause of your problems could be unrelated
    to diet -- you might have an electrical imbalance or you
    could be poisoned by a magnetic field.

    LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Call Alex Chiu to the Emergency room, call Alex Chiu!
    STAT!

    Quoted message said:

    Have you tried
    reversing the direction in which you sleep, for example,
    so that your head is toward the north (if it was toward
    the south)? There are so many factors involved that
    no one person could be expected to be familiar with all
    of them. At the least, you'll need comprehensive diagnosis
    by a board-certified iridologist,

    Quack

    Quoted message said:

    chiropractor,

    Quack

    Quoted message said:

    and
    homeopathic physician.

    Homeopathy is the worst of all. The dilutions are so great, often times,
    that not a single molecule of the so called therapeutic ingredient is left
    in a dose. Ever hear of Avogadro's number?

    Quoted message said:

    Even then, you'll need to treat
    their advice with caution, because of the variable quality
    of alternative medical education in this country.

    How about he go to a doctor who has had scientific training and
    evidence-based methodologies?

    Quoted message said:

    The
    average chiropractor only gets ONE HOUR of course
    study in iridology in his/her educational curriculum! Can
    you believe it! It's a scandal, I tell ya. Hope this helps :-)

    Chiropractic and Iridology are both scams and the fact that you idiots have
    duped so many people into forking over the dough for them is a scandal!

    -Rubystars

  11. "Ann" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hello,

    I've been vegan as in no food or toiletries or anything with any
    animal products for about five years, but, it hasn't been for health
    reasons and I haven't been the healthiest eater -- my diet includes
    lots of carbs, bready things, potatoes, pasta, sugary >things.

    Carbs are good for you, as part of a balanced diet. Just cut down on the
    sugary things.

    Quoted message said:

    I was
    recently told to switch to an all raw fruit and veggie diet to treat
    an acne problem that I've had for a long time.

    What you eat really doesn't have as much effect on acne as some people
    think. It should only hurt you if you have an allergy to one particular
    food.

    http://www.skincarephysicians.com/acnenet/myths.html

    "Myth #2: Acne is caused by diet. Extensive scientific studies have not
    found a connection between diet and acne. In other words, food does not
    cause acne. Not chocolate. Not french fries. Not pizza. Nonetheless, some
    people insist that certain foods affect their acne. In that case, avoid
    those foods. Besides, eating a balanced diet always makes sense. However,
    according to the scientific evidence, if acne is being treated properly,
    there's no need to worry about food affecting the acne."

    Quoted message said:

    It sounds promising,

    Don't bother.

    Quoted message said:

    and I'm hoping that it will help with a lot of other health >problems
    too,

    Ask a doctor (a mainstream one) what to do about improving your health. See
    a real dermatologist about your acne.

    Quoted message said:

    but I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding >*more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping >because I'm
    bumbling it.

    Then stay far far away from "Alternative" practitioners. Whoever told you to
    go on a strict diet to avoid acne has probably completely ignored the
    scientific studies which have shown little to no linkage between acne and
    diet.

    Quoted message said:

    Exactly what fruits and veggies and how many?

    Why the heck are you getting medical advice on a newsgroup anyway? If
    someone told you to go on a strict diet of sour cherries and plain eggplant,
    would you do it? Where does the madness end? I'm not saying you're mad, just
    that you need to take more of a common sense approach to these things.

    Diets can improve heatlh sometimes, but it seems like you're obssessing too
    much about what you eat and not giving enough energy toward other, more
    important things.

    Quoted message said:

    Where
    should I get them, supermarket or health food store?

    There's no really substantial health benefits regarding organic vs.
    non-organic, so don't pay the extra money.

    Quoted message said:

    Should they be
    organic?

    Unecessary.

    Quoted message said:

    How should I wash them, eg I read about soaking
    non-pealables for 15 min. in a sink full of water mixed with a little
    peroxide.

    Don't drink peroxide! It can be very dangerous and eat away things.
    Surprisingly a lot of pseudoscientists including Kent Hovind are promoting
    this, but it's really quite dangerous.

    "Hydrogen peroxide is being promoted as a "cure-all" by several small
    nonmedical organizations.
    These organizations claim that hydrogen peroxide can cure a variety of
    ailments including cancer, AIDS, and arthritis. However, use of hydrogen
    peroxide for these purposes has resulted in deaths and serious injuries. "

    http://www.h2o2.com/h2o2update/pgarticles/human.html

    Just wash with water.

    Quoted message said:

    I also have a dilemma because I also want to try the >"Master Cleanse"

    Why do you feel a need to do that?

    Quoted message said:

    and I'm probably going to try a treatment for chronic >systemic candida
    infection -- what do I do first?

    You must have a really weak immune system if you have that! You'd better get
    a second opinion before you try to treat something you probably don't even
    have.

    Quoted message said:

    Can I do the cleanse and start the
    treatment at the same time?

    Do neither. Ask a doctor, a REAL doctor who went to medical school.

    Quoted message said:

    Please help!!

    I'm doing the best I can, please listen to what I've told you and don't put
    your health or pocketbook at risk any longer by accepting faux advice and
    faux treatments from a bunch of pseudoscientists.

    -Rubystars

  12. Mark is an idiot that mouths off about things he/she has no knowledge of.
    Never studied, never used, never known anyone who has.
    "Rubystars" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    "Mark Thorson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

  13. "Rubystars" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    "Ann" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    -Rubystars


    This looked like a troll post, so, Snippity snip

  14. Ann said:

    Hello,

    I've been vegan as in no food or toiletries or anything with any
    animal products for about five years, but, it hasn't been for health
    reasons and I haven't been the healthiest eater -- my diet includes
    lots of carbs, bready things, potatoes, pasta, sugary things. I was
    recently told to switch to an all raw fruit and veggie diet to treat
    an acne problem that I've had for a long time. It sounds promising,
    and I'm hoping that it will help with a lot of other health problems
    too, but I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding *more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping because I'm
    bumbling it. Exactly what fruits and veggies and how many? Where
    should I get them, supermarket or health food store? Should they be
    organic? How should I wash them, eg I read about soaking
    non-pealables for 15 min. in a sink full of water mixed with a little
    peroxide.

    Firstly, I'd do more in the way of nonprocessed, whole grain carbs and
    cut back on sugary stuff. I eat a mostly vegetarian diet (ovo-lacto,
    with occasional fish and poultry still) and notice a big difference when
    having less-processed grains; whole grain breads, pastas, cereals, that
    type of thing. They also taste better to me. Secondly, as for raw
    fruits and veggies...just add them to your current diet instead of
    switching completely. As good as raw fruits and veggies are, I know I'd
    miss a good barley stew <g> I prefer to buy organic when I can, as
    they just taste better to me, but that depends on the individual. Just
    wash them under running water and you should be fine.

    Quoted message said:

    I also have a dilemma because I also want to try the "Master Cleanse"
    and I'm probably going to try a treatment for chronic systemic candida
    infection -- what do I do first? Can I do the cleanse and start the
    treatment at the same time?

    I'm gonna reiterate what others have already said. Systemic candida is
    a sign of a compromised immune system, so I'd see an MD (it takes a lot
    for me to see any doctor) to confirm the diagnosis before doing
    anything. If, indeed, it is systemic candida you need to find out why
    you have it.

    Good luck!!

    Kimmer
    kimagreenfieldatyahoodotcom

  15. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Rubystars said:


    "Mark Thorson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Ann said:

    I want to do it right, not have to worry about adding *more*
    problems and getting frustrated thinking it's not helping because
    I'm bumbling it.

    But how can anyone help you when you haven't told us
    even the most basic information about your particular
    health conditions? For example, you haven't mentioned
    your blood type. What's right for a type O is completely
    different from what is needed by an AB. Type O in general
    are people descended from agrarian farmers, and for them
    a high-carb, grain-based diet is near optimal. On the other
    hand, type AB are people descended from hunters and
    fishermen, so a high-protein diet rich in fish oils is usually
    best. Type A should be eating lots of tomatoes, garlic, pasta
    and olive oil, while type B are shiftless people of no account
    who are best avoided.

    There's no evidence whatsoever for that "eat right for your type" BS.

    quackwatch.orgd'adamo.html

    Please stop peddling snake oil.

    So, Mark, do you practice "catch and release" or what?

    -- David Wright :: alphabeta at prodigy.net
    These are my opinions only, but they're almost always correct.
    "If I have not seen as far as others, it is because giants
    were standing on my shoulders." (Hal Abelson, MIT)

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.