General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Butter doesn't taste buttery

Started by Email address hidden · · Last activity · 31 posts · 948 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
11 April 2006
Last activity
21 April 2006
Original author
Email address hidden
Posts
31
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
948
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 31
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Is there something wrong with the butter in supermarkets?
    It pretty much just tastes like a slab of nearly tastelss fat and the
    color is almost pure white.
    There's very much a lack of buttery flavor and yellow color.
    What's up with that?
    Margarine tastes more buttery than the butter.
    Do you have to churn your own butter at home to get the real deal?
    If I'm going to pay $4 for 4 sticks of butter, I should get something
    that tastes good and buttery, not just solidified milk fat.

  2. [email hidden] hitched up their panties and posted
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    Is there something wrong with the butter in supermarkets?
    It pretty much just tastes like a slab of nearly tastelss fat and the
    color is almost pure white.
    There's very much a lack of buttery flavor and yellow color.
    What's up with that?
    Margarine tastes more buttery than the butter.
    Do you have to churn your own butter at home to get the real deal?
    If I'm going to pay $4 for 4 sticks of butter, I should get something
    that tastes good and buttery, not just solidified milk fat.

    I do not seem to find that problem in St. Louis. The butter is... well
    butter and tastes buttery. The margarine is good also. I use the heart
    healthy spreads and they are okay also. Last time I bought butter here it
    was $2.89 a pound for Land O Lakes but it was on sale.

    Michael

    --
    "The most remarkable thing about my mother is that for thirty years she
    served the family nothing but leftovers. The original meal has never been
    found."

    --Calvin Trillin

  3. Quoted message said:

    Is there something wrong with the butter in supermarkets?
    It pretty much just tastes like a slab of nearly tastelss fat and the
    color is almost pure white.
    There's very much a lack of buttery flavor and yellow color.
    What's up with that?
    Margarine tastes more buttery than the butter.
    Do you have to churn your own butter at home to get the real deal?
    If I'm going to pay $4 for 4 sticks of butter, I should get something
    that tastes good and buttery, not just solidified milk fat.

    ever notice how bananas don't taste like banana candy?

    --
    ..:Heather:.
    www.velvet-c.com
    Step off, beyotches, I'm the roflpimp!

  4. Quoted message said:

    Is there something wrong with the butter in supermarkets?
    It pretty much just tastes like a slab of nearly tastelss fat and the
    color is almost pure white.
    There's very much a lack of buttery flavor and yellow color.
    What's up with that?

    The USDA has recently outlawed the use of artificially
    butter-flavored grain for dairy cows.

    Now the diaries are in a bind since they can't get any
    naturally-derived butter flavor. Apparently all the butter flavor
    has been bred out of the cows over the last few decades as a
    result of feedlot efficient programs and "innovations".

    The Meat Lobby really backed themselves into a corner this time.
    Butter here in Texas has reached an all-time low at $2.35/lb in an
    attempt to keep the masses appeased while they devise a solution
    for the problem.

    -sw

  5. Quoted message said:


    Is there something wrong with the butter in supermarkets?
    It pretty much just tastes like a slab of nearly tastelss
    fat and the color is almost pure white.
    There's very much a lack of buttery flavor and yellow color.
    What's up with that?

    If this is something you noticed recently,
    and over a relatively short period of time,
    it could be agnosia (loss of some of your
    ability to sense smell, possibly specific
    to certain smells but not all smells).

    This is a very unusual symptom, and often
    it is a sign of a brain tumor. (Of course,
    if you've had a recent sharp blow to the head,
    there's no reason to speculate about scary
    certain-to-die scenarios like that one.)

    Cerebral aneurysm is another possibility.
    Google that (+ agnosia), and make your own
    informed judgement about whether you need
    medical attention. (You need treatment
    immediately, if that's what it is.)

    Do you eat beef?

    Hope this helps! :-)

  6. Are you saying that you need to have grass-fed cows in order to get
    good tasting butter?

  7. Steve Wertz said:

    Now the diaries are in a bind since they can't get any
    naturally-derived butter flavor.

    Say that line 5 times. BTW, just exactly is butter flavor

    Quoted message said:

    Butter here in Texas has reached an all-time low at $2.35/lb in an
    attempt to keep the masses appeased.....

    Have 'em sell it in CA where the price is typically $5+ lb. OTOH, our
    butter actually tastes like butter.

    nb

  8. Quoted message said:

    Is there something wrong with the butter in supermarkets?
    It pretty much just tastes like a slab of nearly tastelss fat and the
    color is almost pure white.
    There's very much a lack of buttery flavor and yellow color.
    What's up with that?
    Margarine tastes more buttery than the butter.
    Do you have to churn your own butter at home to get the real deal?
    If I'm going to pay $4 for 4 sticks of butter, I should get something
    that tastes good and buttery, not just solidified milk fat.

    This is my opinion only. We use butter either salted or unsalted. We
    do not use margarine for any reason. We hate going to a restaurant and
    getting margarine on our toast for breakfast. It is always sent back.
    For us, margaine tastes like motor oil or worse. As mentioned we use
    two types of butter. The unsalted butter is best for baking and tastes
    somewhat sweet. Sometimes we make this ourselves from heavy cream. It
    is very good infused with herbs for different uses. The salted butter
    is used for buttering breads or on top of veggies. As far as costs, I'm
    in Canada so pay about $3.50 per lb of butter in the store.

  9. The Bubbo said:
    Quoted message said:

    Is there something wrong with the butter in supermarkets?
    It pretty much just tastes like a slab of nearly tastelss fat and the
    color is almost pure white.
    There's very much a lack of buttery flavor and yellow color.
    What's up with that?
    Margarine tastes more buttery than the butter.
    Do you have to churn your own butter at home to get the real deal?
    If I'm going to pay $4 for 4 sticks of butter, I should get something
    that tastes good and buttery, not just solidified milk fat.

    ever notice how bananas don't taste like banana candy?


    But, banana popsicles sorta taste like bananas and the look sorta like
    bananas and they are yellos 😉

  10. Quoted message said:

    Are you saying that you need to have grass-fed cows in order to get
    good tasting butter?

    Not unless it's butter-flavored grass.

    I don't think you'll find many dairies in the US grass-feeding
    milkers. You'd have to round them all up to milk them.

    -sw

  11. ~patches~ said:

    But, banana popsicles sorta taste like bananas and the look sorta like
    bananas and they are yellos 😉

    Speaking of bananas... Be sure to take your meds tonight.

    -sw

  12. Steve Wertz said:
    ~patches~ said:

    But, banana popsicles sorta taste like bananas and the look sorta like
    bananas and they are yellos 😉

    Speaking of bananas... Be sure to take your meds tonight.

    -sw

    What is it with you and meds? You have a serious problem or are a true
    druggie. I thought you had me killfiled?

  13. ~patches~ said:
    Steve Wertz said:
    ~patches~ said:

    But, banana popsicles sorta taste like bananas and the look sorta like
    bananas and they are yellos 😉

    Speaking of bananas... Be sure to take your meds tonight.

    What is it with you and meds?

    I hardly ever use the "meds" line. The bananas thing was too
    good to pass up since I just used it on you in another thread, and
    here you are, posting about bananas already.

    Was it with your newsreader that it likes to insert another blank
    line after each one it sees? Has it gone bananas, too?

    Being the kind poster <cough> I am, I usually remove them. But I
    only have so much kindness and I'd hate to use it all up on you.

    -sw

  14. ~patches~ said:
    Quoted message said:

    Is there something wrong with the butter in supermarkets?
    It pretty much just tastes like a slab of nearly tastelss fat and the
    color is almost pure white.
    There's very much a lack of buttery flavor and yellow color.
    What's up with that?
    Margarine tastes more buttery than the butter.
    Do you have to churn your own butter at home to get the real deal?
    If I'm going to pay $4 for 4 sticks of butter, I should get something
    that tastes good and buttery, not just solidified milk fat.

    This is my opinion only. We use butter either salted or unsalted. We
    do not use margarine for any reason. We hate going to a restaurant
    and getting margarine on our toast for breakfast. It is always sent
    back. For us, margaine tastes like motor oil or worse. As mentioned
    we use two types of butter. The unsalted butter is best for baking
    and tastes somewhat sweet. Sometimes we make this ourselves from
    heavy cream. It is very good infused with herbs for different uses. The
    salted butter is used for buttering breads or on top of veggies. As far as
    costs, I'm in Canada so pay about $3.50 per lb of butter in
    the store.

    I am totally with you on the margarin 'opinion'.
    The flavour of butter is directly related to the food the cow eats.
    Tasteless butter is the product of processed hi gain amimal feed (note -
    feed - not food).
    I find that the taste of butter in Honduras is much richer. This would be
    because the dairy cows there are pastured in the 'old fashioned' way - no
    processed feed.

    Ken.

    --
    Volunteer your idle computer time for cancer research
    http//www.grid.org/download/gold/download.htm
    Return address courtesy of Spammotel http://www.spammotel.com/

  15. "~patches~" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Is there something wrong with the butter in supermarkets?
    It pretty much just tastes like a slab of nearly tastelss fat and the
    color is almost pure white.
    There's very much a lack of buttery flavor and yellow color.
    What's up with that?
    Margarine tastes more buttery than the butter.
    Do you have to churn your own butter at home to get the real deal?
    If I'm going to pay $4 for 4 sticks of butter, I should get something
    that tastes good and buttery, not just solidified milk fat.

    This is my opinion only. We use butter either salted or unsalted. We
    do not use margarine for any reason. We hate going to a restaurant and
    getting margarine on our toast for breakfast. It is always sent back.
    For us, margaine tastes like motor oil or worse. As mentioned we use
    two types of butter. The unsalted butter is best for baking and tastes
    somewhat sweet. Sometimes we make this ourselves from heavy cream. It
    is very good infused with herbs for different uses. The salted butter
    is used for buttering breads or on top of veggies. As far as costs, I'm
    in Canada so pay about $3.50 per lb of butter in the store.

    I agree; you will never find margarine in my house. Any product that is
    naturally a liquid, gets added chemicals to make it a butter-flavored
    cream-colored solid, just doesn't appeal to me. The only "benefit" a stick
    of margarine has over a stick of butter is that it spreads more easily on a
    piece of bread. Then again, you can always get whipped butter.

    kili

  16. In article <[email hidden]>,
    [email hidden] says...

    Quoted message said:

    I don't think you'll find many dairies in the US grass-feeding
    milkers. You'd have to round them all up to milk them.


    That is how it works in other countries.
    Cows go out in the morning.
    The pens get cleaned, the cows eat grass and hay.
    The cows come in for milking
    The cows go out for grass and hay.
    The cows come in at night. It is what dairy farmers do.
    --
    Carl Robson
    Car PC Build starts again. http://smallr.com/rz
    Homepage: http://www.bouncing-czechs.com

  17. "NeedforSwede2" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,
    [email hidden] says...

    Quoted message said:

    I don't think you'll find many dairies in the US grass-feeding
    milkers. You'd have to round them all up to milk them.


    That is how it works in other countries.
    Cows go out in the morning.
    The pens get cleaned, the cows eat grass and hay.
    The cows come in for milking
    The cows go out for grass and hay.
    The cows come in at night. It is what dairy farmers do.
    --
    Carl Robson

    I recall it that the cows come in for milking around 4pm, then they stayed
    in eating hay at the stall for the night. Must be a memory lapse.
    Dee Dee
    Dee Dee

  18. In article <[email hidden]>, [email hidden]
    says...

    Quoted message said:


    "NeedforSwede2" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,
    [email hidden] says...

    Quoted message said:

    I don't think you'll find many dairies in the US grass-feeding
    milkers. You'd have to round them all up to milk them.


    That is how it works in other countries.
    Cows go out in the morning.
    The pens get cleaned, the cows eat grass and hay.
    The cows come in for milking
    The cows go out for grass and hay.
    The cows come in at night. It is what dairy farmers do.
    --
    Carl Robson

    I recall it that the cows come in for milking around 4pm, then they stayed
    in eating hay at the stall for the night. Must be a memory lapse.
    Dee Dee
    Dee Dee


    Maybe right. Been a while (about 6-7 years) since I lived in the sticks.
    But I don't think it would be legal (humane laws) to keep them in all
    day.
    --
    Carl Robson
    Car PC Build starts again. http://smallr.com/rz
    Homepage: http://www.bouncing-czechs.com

  19. Michael 'Dog3' Lonergan said:

    [email hidden] hitched up their panties and posted
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    Is there something wrong with the butter in supermarkets?
    It pretty much just tastes like a slab of nearly tastelss fat and the
    color is almost pure white.
    There's very much a lack of buttery flavor and yellow color.
    What's up with that?
    Margarine tastes more buttery than the butter.
    Do you have to churn your own butter at home to get the real deal?
    If I'm going to pay $4 for 4 sticks of butter, I should get something
    that tastes good and buttery, not just solidified milk fat.

    Butter IS milk fat. Maybe you could leave it out of the fridge for
    about ten days.
    The fact that you even know what the margarine tastes like tells me
    you're a pig, and should just be slopped. The sentence,"Margarine
    tastes more buttery than the butter," is what I've come to expect from
    this NG, but still.

    Quoted message said:

    I do not seem to find that problem in St. Louis. The butter is... well
    butter and tastes buttery. The margarine is good also. I use the heart
    healthy spreads and they are okay also. Last time I bought butter here it
    was $2.89 a pound for Land O Lakes but it was on sale.

    "Healthy spreads" might well be healthy, but they are no substitute for
    butter. Margarine is [censored]. Note: In StL, Schnuck's has LoL butter on
    sale for $2/# this week, so time to stock up.

    Quoted message said:


    Michael


    --Bryan

  20. scott123 said:

    Supermarket butter, for the most part, is inedible. I've taste tested
    just about every brand available. The only brand that is consistency
    decent is Land O' Lakes. For my area (NE US), that's the best. If
    you're willing to pay a little bit more, the European butters are an

    In Davis, CA, the superkarkets had good butter such as Challenge, The
    Danish Creamery.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.