Australia and New Zealand · Public discussion

US: QR ban?

Started by cfsmtb · · Last activity · 11 posts · 975 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Australia and New Zealand
Published
21 October 2006
Last activity
22 October 2006
Original author
cfsmtb
Posts
11
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
975
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–11 of 11
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Almost newsworthy or a load of bollox?

    ************

    Bike block: Officials want to ban quick-release wheels
    http://www.nj.com/news/gloucester/local/index.ssf?/base/news-4/116132655142200.xml&coll=8
    Friday, October 20, 2006

    TRENTON - South Jersey legislators want bike makers to move forward with what they say is an inexpensive change that would protect riders from scars, broken bones and other severe injuries.

    Legislation whose sponsors include Assembly members Paul Moriarty, D-4 of Washington Township, and David Mayer, D-4 of Gloucester Township, would ban the sale of bicycles for children and adults with "quick-release" front-wheel systems, unless those systems include a safety mechanism preventing the wheel from coming off in use.

    The measure was unanimously voted out of the Consumer Affairs Committee on Thursday and would next have to be posted in the full Assembly for a vote. The bill was first released by the committee in March but was amended to encompass adult bikes as well as those manufactured for children.

    Mishaps involving quick release wheels may be an issue of human error that the equipment isn't helping to prevent.

    "Tragically, this technology has been shown to be quite dangerous in its current form due to the fact that they are difficult to properly attach and reattach," Moriarty said. "They may seem properly hooked on, but all too often bike riders, particularly young ones, have found out the hard way that they're not."

    The legislators say quick-release front wheels allow riders to easily remove them by hand when transporting or storing their bicycles, but can mean face-first tumbles without a safety locking device. One Boston-based designer of a fail-safe mechanism for the wheels told committee members it consisted of a few additional nuts and bolts.

    Moriarty said he became aware of the issue not through local cases but consumer reports and news stories. According to one such report, the parents of several children sued Wal-Mart over what they said was a faulty quick-release lever on the front wheel of bikes made by Dynacraft. The companies reportedly blamed human error.

    A motion for a new trial filed in California earlier this year mentions that the New Jersey Assembly had introduced a bill banning quick-release wheels.

    Quick-release wheels have been common on bicycles for 20 to 30 years, according to John Baxter, administrator of the Oregon-based United Bicycle Institute. Bicycle manufacturers typically include a retention mechanism to keep the wheel from completely falling out, Baxter said.

    "I'm sure there are some bikes out there that don't have them, but I think typically most mass-market manufacturers include them now," Baxter said. "I don't know whether that law is even necessary at this point."

    The legislation makes exceptions for professional-grade racing bicycles.

  2. A load of bollox.

    "cfsmtb" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    Almost newsworthy or a load of bollox?

    ************

    Bike block: Officials want to ban quick-release wheels
    http://tinyurl.com/y2sl48
    Friday, October 20, 2006

    TRENTON - South Jersey legislators want bike makers to move forward
    with what they say is an inexpensive change that would protect riders
    from scars, broken bones and other severe injuries.

    Legislation whose sponsors include Assembly members Paul Moriarty, D-4
    of Washington Township, and David Mayer, D-4 of Gloucester Township,
    would ban the sale of bicycles for children and adults with
    "quick-release" front-wheel systems, unless those systems include a
    safety mechanism preventing the wheel from coming off in use.

    The measure was unanimously voted out of the Consumer Affairs Committee
    on Thursday and would next have to be posted in the full Assembly for a
    vote. The bill was first released by the committee in March but was
    amended to encompass adult bikes as well as those manufactured for
    children.

    Mishaps involving quick release wheels may be an issue of human error
    that the equipment isn't helping to prevent.

    "Tragically, this technology has been shown to be quite dangerous in
    its current form due to the fact that they are difficult to properly
    attach and reattach," Moriarty said. "They may seem properly hooked on,
    but all too often bike riders, particularly young ones, have found out
    the hard way that they're not."

    The legislators say quick-release front wheels allow riders to easily
    remove them by hand when transporting or storing their bicycles, but
    can mean face-first tumbles without a safety locking device. One
    Boston-based designer of a fail-safe mechanism for the wheels told
    committee members it consisted of a few additional nuts and bolts.

    Moriarty said he became aware of the issue not through local cases but
    consumer reports and news stories. According to one such report, the
    parents of several children sued Wal-Mart over what they said was a
    faulty quick-release lever on the front wheel of bikes made by
    Dynacraft. The companies reportedly blamed human error.

    A motion for a new trial filed in California earlier this year mentions
    that the New Jersey Assembly had introduced a bill banning quick-release
    wheels.

    Quick-release wheels have been common on bicycles for 20 to 30 years,
    according to John Baxter, administrator of the Oregon-based United
    Bicycle Institute. Bicycle manufacturers typically include a retention
    mechanism to keep the wheel from completely falling out, Baxter said.

    "I'm sure there are some bikes out there that don't have them, but I
    think typically most mass-market manufacturers include them now,"
    Baxter said. "I don't know whether that law is even necessary at this
    point."

    The legislation makes exceptions for professional-grade racing
    bicycles.

    --
    cfsmtb

  3. Paulus said:

    A load of bollox.

    Methinks Messrs Mayer and Moriarty are tilting at windmills.

  4. What are the odds that pretty much every instance of a wheel coming off
    happened as a result of someone not knowing how to use a QR? I've heard of
    instances of people just using the QR lever as a handle to screw it up as
    hard as they can but not flipping it over to lock it.

  5. Resound said:

    What are the odds that pretty much every instance of a wheel coming off
    happened as a result of someone not knowing how to use a QR? I've heard of
    instances of people just using the QR lever as a handle to screw it up as
    hard as they can but not flipping it over to lock it.

    I'm impressed that you've only heard about it. I've stopped people and
    fixed their QR during MTB races because I didn't want to hear about some
    poor kid getting ambo'd out (plus the helicopter cost would probably end
    up being worn by the organiser, at least indirectly).

    Then again I've also spotted undone climbing harnesses from around 20m
    away. Some things you get really good at noticing if you're getting paid
    to do so.

    --
    Dave Hughes | [email hidden]
    Careful. We don't want to learn from this. -- Calvin

  6. Dave Hughes said:

    I'm impressed that you've only heard about it. I've stopped people and
    fixed their QR during MTB races because I didn't want to hear about some
    poor kid getting ambo'd out

    Yes I've had similar instances, especially with newbies met on our club's
    rides, or while touring in various country towns and suburbs. But I still
    don't see what the deal is with this US legislation proposal. Virtually
    every bike sold comes equipped with great big lawyer lips, such that even if
    the QR is undone, the wheel will stay in place - just rattles a lot. That's
    how I've picked up a couple - a guy comes up on a ride "I've got this funny
    rattling noise on my bike. Can you work out what it is?" Sheesh!!

    I think the whole US case is a beat up by some legislators who haven't had
    enough 'brownie points' for their next election, so they decide to target a
    minority group, the bike industry and cyclists. Losers.

    --
    Cheers
    Peter

    ~~~ ~ _@
    ~~ ~ _- \,
    ~~ (*)/ (*)

  7. Resound said:

    What are the odds that pretty much every instance of a wheel coming off
    happened as a result of someone not knowing how to use a QR? I've heard of
    instances of people just using the QR lever as a handle to screw it up as
    hard as they can but not flipping it over to lock it.

    a natural extension of 'lawyer lugs' perhaps??? 😠
    I see thru their plot. Next it will be to weld all hubs solid so that those_dangerous_wheels can't go round!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  8. flyingdutch said:


    I see thru their plot. Next it will be to weld all hubs solid so that those_dangerous_wheels can't go round!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Well if you knew about older bikes, they actually did once. Have one old "Hartley" frame in the garage awaiting restoration that has no dropouts on the front forks.

  9. flyingdutch said:

    a natural extension of 'lawyer lugs' perhaps??? 😠
    I see thru their plot. Next it will be to weld all hubs solid so that those_dangerous_wheels can't go round!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    ANother one out of the get sued for looking at some-one the wrong way, prehaps ?? I know I myself almost got caught out not long after I got my first road bike, got back home and thought the front wheel felt a bit funny, look down and the see the quick release latch not looking right.

    I'm over in Boston at the moment, a lot of bikes around, particularly in the "University" spots, and more single speed/fixed speed bikes you can poke a stick at. Helmets are virtually non-existent and as for obey road rules.... geesh im surprised there are not cyclists being wiped out every minute. But certainly no car horns and abuse.

  10. Resound said -

    Quoted message said:

    What are the odds that pretty much every instance of a wheel coming off
    happened as a result of someone not knowing how to use a QR? >

    One morning in our bunch whilst slowing and turning at Waterfall (a fast
    flat ride in Sydney) a guy reached down to test what he thought were loose
    front wheel bearings and found to his horror he had riden 40k with the front
    QR completely undone.

    Hangover, early start, running late, distracted whilst getting ready and
    the hell with usual checks and but for the grace it could have really
    spoiled everyone's morning.

    There's that line about genius being really lmited but human stupidity being
    not so confined - and its not hard to see how [censored] happens.

    Legislation and more bolts are however unlikely to fix that condition
    anytime soon.

    best, Andrew

  11. In aus.bicycle on Mon, 23 Oct 2006 07:00:16 +1000

    Andrew Price said:

    One morning in our bunch whilst slowing and turning at Waterfall (a fast
    flat ride in Sydney) a guy reached down to test what he thought were loose
    front wheel bearings and found to his horror he had riden 40k with the front
    QR completely undone.

    Hangover, early start, running late, distracted whilst getting ready and
    the hell with usual checks and but for the grace it could have really
    spoiled everyone's morning.

    I wonder if having one side of the lever in flouro colours might be a
    good aid? TO help with that kind of thing anyway. Something to catch
    the eye, a "hmm, hang on".

    I've ridden for some time with the axle nut of the motorcycle loose
    and slowly working its way off, so it ain't just QRs....

    Zebee

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.