ive been riding for many many years as both a messenger, and as a recreational cyclist. in major cities in major traffic as well. i've never worn a helmet, and have never had a wreck bad enough to need one. my arguement on the idea of forcing someone to wear a helmet is this.
<taken from another friend>
Personally, I don't think anyone should HAVE to wear a helmet. At the very least any operator of any vehicle should have the choice. I feel there has been a 'safety-slide' since I was a kid. All of this is what makes kids soft nowadays. Bumps and bruises are part of life. I don't doubt for a second people get hurt on bikes, but for the average joe shmoe riding the cruiser, we shouldn't have to.
Riding a bike comes with what a lawyer friend called assumed risk. To argue that everyone on a bike needs a helmet is ridiculous. By the rationale that they should wear one, the logical extension would be knee pads since your knees would quite often hit the ground first. What would next if you fall? Hmm.. well let's see, elbow pads and gloves to protect your hands from road rash as you slide to a stop. Then to extend this further all bicycles will have training wheels (soon called 'safety wheels'😉 on them. We certainly can't have these dangerous things on the road (or safely paved trail) with only two wheels, what if you lost your balance?
In fact in a few years I foresee a crusade to outlaw bicycles. they will say that they are just to risky to be ridden since there just can't be a way to mount an airbag on them. This outlawing will come no doubt after the passing of the bicycle seat belt act fails to save enough lives. I mean what legislator wants to be seen as taking a stand against something that puts children in harms way? Bicycles will go the way of the easy to light Bic lighter and Lawn Darts. Enjoy them while you can.
<cut>
assumed risk. its part of life. forcing someone to wear a helmet on a bicycle would be similar to forcing a surfer to wear an anti-shark suit. should an adult ride a helmet when running? similar speed, similar distance from the ground. you might as well include a fire suit with a book of matches.
If you're planning on saying "well people drive crazy, you never know!" then my arguement is; the time spent in fining people for no helmets, should be spent on bike lanes, bike awareness, and the like.
and to add, yes i should wear a helmet. im stupid for not doing so, you're right. my arguement is that forcing one to do so OR ELSE they get punished by a fine? cummon.