"Charlie Pendejo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted message said:Tony said:Isn't 8 weeks a wee too long for speedwork though?
Is that a trick question?
Nope, just a less uniformed one 😉
Quoted message said:Answer: it depends, heavily.
Specifically, on whom you ask, in the context of what overall program,
and what you're calling "speedwork".Though tfactor clearly ran harder than tempo effort, his stated intent
was T(empo) pace. One could run tempo stuff the whole year round.
(And strides. I suspect just doing tempos and stridey/reppy/hilly/
fartleky short fast bits year round would keep many of us around 96%
of our ultimate peak condition...)
You're probably right, but it would quickly wear me out.
Quoted message said:Donovan, last I recall him speaking at length of his training, was
doing the same tough weekly track session ad infinitum with continual
improvement. In Noakes you'll see some legends employed little or no
periodization. Frank Shorter comes to mind as one who ran essentially
the same week all the time.
Yea I remember that too, but I also remember him attributing his best race
times with high mileage in addition to those 5k DeCastella workouts.
Quoted message said:Daniels' programs, at least in the first edition of _DRF_, consist of
four phases each lasting six weeks. First phase is base; next three
incorporate a mix of workouts with the primary focus typically
shifting from faster reps to VO2max intervals to tempo runs. And in
the text (Daniels actually does relate a number of ideas, once you get
beyond the rows and columns of digits) he implies the timing isn't set
in stone but more of an optimal compromise: 6 weeks = you squeeze 90%
of the juice from each workout type / physiological subsystem; shorter
= less juice, longer = diminishing returns. I can claim direct
experience with Daniels (1).Lydiard has you running base (aka conditioning or marathon
conditioning) "as long as possible" before shorter race prep/peaking
phases: hills, anaerobic, sharpening. From reading, it seems the
timing is more critical in this peaking program and trying to extend
one of these phases much beyond 4 weeks or whatever would throw you
off considerably.
I think this approach makes the most sense for me personally.
Quoted message said:(1) Having followed his 10k training pretty faithfully last spring, I
think *for me* *at my stage of development* those eighteen weeks did
indeed seem "a wee too long". I saw a big jump around the end of
phase 2 (first phase of workouts, emphasizing short reps) - sub-65 at
Philthy ten miler - and then little to no race-proven improvements
from the last two, three months of the program. Though all those
workouts may have set me up well for the marathon training which
followed.I don't see myself going back for another season of Daniels, but also
kinda suspect that I'd have seen more benefit further into the season
had I gone in with a stronger base and/or twenty years younger.
Interesting, thanks Charlie. We have examples in rec.running, like Mark H.,
of those who go hard all year. We've also got those who follow programs
pretty closely, like Phil M. When I was in my late teens early 20s, I
trained by feel: run pretty much every day, go hard when I felt good, go
easy when I was tired. But I know I wasted some effort in training by going
too hard, but when you're young, you bounce back quicker.
(And now, a side trip into memory lane...)
Now I never go all out in training. Back in the day, I would do it because
it was fun. I was just thinking about this last week when I ran a section of
old trail that I used to run back in the 80s. I still don't know how I
managed that 3+ mile 1100' climb very rough hiking trail section in 26 min
back then, when it took me 43 mins last week as part of my long run, and
when about 33 minutes was my best very hard effort when in pretty decent
shape 8 years ago. The answer is I was both young and also a different
runner with much more power (and abandon) back then. Even 5 years or so
after my PR on that trail I was an entirely different runner and, though
lighter and fitter in most ways, I could only manage 31 mins there. By that
time all the soccer conditioning and vast sprinting reserves I'd developed
in my youth were pretty much gone.
-Tony