Qui si parla Campagnolo said:Quoted message said:All this b.s. is a good reason why the new Trek Madone frame, with it
"integrated bottom bracket" and the ability to install cartridges by
hand directly in the frame, without tools, not to mention cups or any
bb at all, makes a ton of sense.
Yep, as long as youi have a outboard bearing type crank...Lots of DA,
Ultegra, Campag, FSA, Truvativ, etc., non outboard bearing cranks
that cannot be installed.
That's a non sequitur. If you have a new Madone, or a new Madone
frame, you have a new crank, which will be outboard bearing. And,
you are not limited to a particular brand.
As to servicing outboard bearing bbs: I posted my low tech version
of removing and installing bearing cartridges from and into the cups.
Enduro sells tools which work better than my feeble jury rigging:
http://www.cyclingnews.com/tech.php?id=tech/2007/reviews/enduro_bearing_tool
For a mere $112 I can own this tool:
http://www.bikemannetwork.com/biking/p/TL8901
Explain to me again why Trek's innovation of eliminating the cups -
indeed, the bottom bracket - the multiple tools, the hassle, the
expense, the weight for god's sake - is a bad idea?
You install the bearings by hand and the crank with one freaking allen
wrench. Period.
Why would I want any frame which has threads and requires a bottom
bracket, a crankset, and a bunch of tools? Not to mention having to
get the threads faced if I want an outboard bearing crank.
Maybe as a bike shop owner you have a vested interest in preventing us
amateurs from wrenching our own bikes?