Road Cycling · Public discussion

Does a trike put me on a collision course with traffic?

Started by ComandanteBanana · · Last activity · 241 posts · 6,161 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
31 March 2008
Last activity
15 April 2008
Original author
ComandanteBanana
Posts
241
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
6,161
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 241
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off the
    beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    vehicle.

    What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    WHY THE BANANA REVOLUTION?
    http://webspawner.com/users/bananarevolution

  2. Where I live, Long Island, New York, you'd barely get out of your garage on
    the trike without someone trying to run you off the road. When I ran my
    bike recycling program a few years ago, I had the opportunities to test ride
    a few trikes AND a quad. I thought riding the quad on the main street
    running through my town might raise some awareness of alternate
    transportation options, so off I went...only to return ten minutes later
    having been honked off the road and forced onto the sidewalk more than a
    dozen times.

    I guess the answer to your question is largely dependent on where you live
    and what the attitude toward cyclists is in that area.

  3. Papa Tom said:

    Where I live, Long Island, New York, you'd barely get out of your garage on
    the trike without someone trying to run you off the road.  When I ran my
    bike recycling program a few years ago, I had the opportunities to test ride
    a few trikes AND a quad.  I thought riding the quad on the main street
    running through my town might raise some awareness of alternate
    transportation options, so off I went...only to return ten minutes later
    having been honked off the road and forced onto the sidewalk more than a
    dozen times.

    I guess the answer to your question is largely dependent on where you live
    and what the attitude toward cyclists is in that area.

    It sounds like where I live...

    But what would happen if I step off my door and into the three lane
    road, where the marked speed is 30MPH, but the real speeds are closer
    to 50MPH? Would I be able to stand my ground or just give in to the
    law of the jungle?

  4. "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off the
    beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    vehicle.

    What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    I've ridden my recumbent trike in real live traffic on many occasions I
    always live to tell about it. I take the lane when needed, too.

    It's about attitude and if you ain't got none, ride something else.

  5. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    >Would I be able to stand my ground or just give in to the law of the
    >jungle?<<<<

    The speed limit on the road I described is 30mph. It has two schools and a
    20mph speed limit in front of each. It also has a huge curve and a
    grade-level railroad crossing at the end of a mile-long straightaway.
    Still, the average speed driven on that road is 45, regardless of who is
    walking or biking along the shoulder. If your town is like mine, my guess
    is that you'd have to move AT LEAST 30mph on your trike (yeah, RIGHT!) or be
    physically driven off the road.

  6. Roger Zoul said:

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off the
    beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    vehicle.

    Quoted message said:

    What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    I've ridden my recumbent trike in real live traffic on many occasions I
    always live to tell about it.  I take the lane when needed, too.

    It's about attitude and if you ain't got none, ride something else.

    Yeah, but if I'm riding a bike in traffic, I'm giving my back to the
    enemy...

    Whether I survive or not has little to with attitude, and a lot to
    with their clemency.

  7. Papa Tom said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    >>Would I be able to stand my ground or just give in to the law of the
    >>jungle?<<<<

    The speed limit on the road I described is 30mph.  It has two schools and a
    20mph speed limit in front of each.  It also has a huge curve and a
    grade-level railroad crossing at the end of a mile-long straightaway.
    Still, the average speed driven on that road is 45, regardless of who is
    walking or biking along the shoulder.  If your town is like mine, my guess
    is that you'd have to move AT LEAST 30mph on your trike (yeah, RIGHT!) or be
    physically driven off the road.

    It sounds like a good reason for NONVIOLENT RESISTANCE. They push me
    and I won't budge.

  8. I'm not one who believes "resistance" will ever work.

    There's something about bicyclists that people just don't like. Perhaps
    it's just jealousy. When the road was ruled by horse-drawn wagons, they
    cursed at us and threw sticks at our spokes because we were moving too fast.
    Now they do the same thing because we move too slowly.

    Perhaps when gas is $10 a gallon, drivers will start to see us in a
    different light. Right now, keep your trike off the road - or face having
    to pry it out of the grill of some jerk's Hummer.

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Roger Zoul said:

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off the
    beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    vehicle.

    Quoted message said:

    What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    I've ridden my recumbent trike in real live traffic on many occasions I
    always live to tell about it. I take the lane when needed, too.

    It's about attitude and if you ain't got none, ride something else.

    Yeah, but if I'm riding a bike in traffic, I'm giving my back to the
    enemy...

    Whether I survive or not has little to with attitude, and a lot to
    with their clemency.

  9. Papa Tom said:

    I'm not one who believes "resistance" will ever work.

    There's something about bicyclists that people just don't like.  Perhaps
    it's just jealousy.  When the road was ruled by horse-drawn wagons, they
    cursed at us and threw sticks at our spokes because we were moving too fast.
    Now they do the same thing because we move too slowly.

    Perhaps when gas is $10 a gallon, drivers will start to see us in a
    different light.  Right now, keep your trike off the road - or face having
    to pry it out of the grill of some jerk's Hummer.

    Man, this is eerie. That's exactly what I thought.

    But I think it also has to do with HATE. Yeah, they hate that other
    people remain free and healthy while they remain enslaved to their
    thirsty vehicles. They think, "Hey, if I paid 50 grands for my Hummer,
    no one on a bike will slow me down." And they just try to squeeze that
    oversized vehicle and a bike on the same lane...

    One day, though, the stupid dinosaurs will become extinct, and the
    small furry animals will reclaim the earth. Brain is better than size,
    right?

  10. "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Roger Zoul said:

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off the
    beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    vehicle.

    Quoted message said:

    What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    I've ridden my recumbent trike in real live traffic on many occasions I
    always live to tell about it. I take the lane when needed, too.

    It's about attitude and if you ain't got none, ride something else.

    :>Yeah, but if I'm riding a bike in traffic, I'm giving my back to the
    :>enemy...

    :>Whether I survive or not has little to with attitude, and a lot to
    :>with their clemency.

    I think it's clearly about your attitude toward what you think may happen
    vs. what will happen. You're assuming drivers will run you down. Perhaps
    you live some place where cyclists get run down as a matter of sport, on a
    daily basis, anytime they share the road with traffic. Why don't you tell
    us about where you live and how many cyclists are killed there per year?

  11. Quoted message said:


    Perhaps when gas is $10 a gallon, drivers will start to see us in a
    different light.

    Don't hold your breath on that. It's up to $8.50/gallon equivalent here
    (UK) and it hasn't made any real difference to attitudes. The vast majority
    of drivers are as careful as they ever were and there's a very small, but
    persistent, number of complete idiots.

    --

    Nigel

  12. On Mar 31, 12:00 pm, ComandanteBanana <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off the
    beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    vehicle.

    What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    WHY THE BANANA REVOLUTION?http://webspawner.com/users/bananarevolution

    I've never had this happen when I rode a bicycle. It seems as though
    riding a trike is such a dangerous thing. I wonder why this is?

    Are people easily distracted by it?

    Cullen

  13. Roger Zoul said:

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    news:[email hidden]...

    Roger Zoul said:

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    Quoted message said:

    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off the
    beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    vehicle.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    Quoted message said:

    I've ridden my recumbent trike in real live traffic on many occasions I
    always live to tell about it. I take the lane when needed, too.

    Quoted message said:

    It's about attitude and if you ain't got none, ride something else.

    :>Yeah, but if I'm riding a bike in traffic, I'm giving my back to the
    :>enemy...

    :>Whether I survive or not has little to with attitude, and a lot to
    :>with their clemency.

    I think it's clearly about your attitude toward what you think may happen
    vs. what will happen.  You're assuming drivers will run you down.  Perhaps
    you live some place where cyclists get run down as a matter of sport, on a
    daily basis, anytime they share the road with traffic.  Why don't you tell
    us about where you live and how many cyclists are killed there per year?- Hide quoted text -

    - Show quoted text -

    I don't know how many are killed a year, but I've seen a beautiful
    lady on a scooter get crushed by a car running a red light right
    before my eyes. And out of the few cyclists who dare ride this road,
    never ever seen a trike. All you see is a few hardcore riders ride it
    early on weekends.

    By the way I do live in Miami Beach, USA.

  14. Quoted post said:

    On Mar 31, 12:00 pm, ComandanteBanana <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off the
    beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    vehicle.

    Quoted message said:

    What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    Quoted message said:

    WHY THE BANANA REVOLUTION?http://webspawner.com/users/bananarevolution

    I've never had this happen when I rode a bicycle. It seems as though
    riding a trike is such a dangerous thing. I wonder why this is?

    Are people easily distracted by it?

    Cullen

    I think the cute factor may actually deter people from aggressive
    behavior, but I'd be worried about the SPEED DIFFERENTIAL being too
    great, particularly when they are on the phone.

  15. "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Roger Zoul said:

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    news:[email hidden]...

    Roger Zoul said:

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    Quoted message said:

    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off the
    beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    vehicle.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    Quoted message said:

    I've ridden my recumbent trike in real live traffic on many occasions I
    always live to tell about it. I take the lane when needed, too.

    Quoted message said:

    It's about attitude and if you ain't got none, ride something else.

    :>Yeah, but if I'm riding a bike in traffic, I'm giving my back to the
    :>enemy...

    :>Whether I survive or not has little to with attitude, and a lot to
    :>with their clemency.

    I think it's clearly about your attitude toward what you think may happen
    vs. what will happen. You're assuming drivers will run you down. Perhaps
    you live some place where cyclists get run down as a matter of sport, on a
    daily basis, anytime they share the road with traffic. Why don't you tell
    us about where you live and how many cyclists are killed there per year?-
    Hide quoted text -

    - Show quoted text -

    :>I don't know how many are killed a year, but I've seen a beautiful
    :>lady on a scooter get crushed by a car running a red light right
    :>before my eyes. And out of the few cyclists who dare ride this road,
    :>never ever seen a trike. All you see is a few hardcore riders ride it
    :>early on weekends.

    :>By the way I do live in Miami Beach, USA.

    Sad about the lady...

    Even here, there are roads that I choose not to ride on. But at the same
    time, there seem to be plenty roads that I can ride on. If your view of
    cycling means you go everywhere you need or want to go by trike/bike, then
    perhaps that is a serious concern. As a recreational rider, I look at
    cycling from a different POV.

  16. Nigel Randell' nigel_randell@_1.web said:
    Quoted message said:

    Perhaps when gas is $10 a gallon, drivers will start to see us in a
    different light.

    Don't hold your breath on that. It's up to $8.50/gallon equivalent here
    (UK) and it hasn't made any real difference to attitudes. The vast majority
    of drivers are as careful as they ever were and there's a very small, but
    persistent, number of complete idiots.

    --

    Nigel

    I've been there. It was my observation that on the whole the freaking
    idiots over there are much nicer than the freaking idiots over here,
    but I was pretty much just about town and not out in the country.
    Freaking idiots abound, to paraphrase a long dead leader of the
    USofAliens; God must love them as he made so many of 'em.

    Over there I frequently saw bicyclists wearing normal clothes, over
    here the assumption is that unless they're wearing spandex they must
    be an undocumented worker. I guess maybe there is a immigration
    problem there too? I did note a French language channel on the tele.

  17. Vito said:
    Quoted message said:

    But I think it also has to do with HATE. Yeah, they hate that other
    people remain free and healthy ....

    Free and healthy my ass! What we hate is groups of cyclists bored with the
    many bikes and trails people like me paid for who ride 3 or 4 abreast at 20
    mph blocking a 55mph highway. That's why "jousting" is so popular - y'know
    a couple good old boys in the back of a pickup with 2x4s looking for
    cyclists to put in the ditch. So much for free and healthy ....

    Well, I 'm not talking about those hardcore cyclists, but about the
    little guy doing the right thing by riding a bike around. And while
    jousting is not done with 2x4s, it can easily be accomplished with the
    bumpers.

    Drivers envy motorcyclists because they remain free, and hate cyclists
    because they are healthy and free --and slow them down.

  18. Roger Zoul said:

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    news:[email hidden]...

    Roger Zoul said:

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    Quoted message said:

    news:[email hidden]...
    On Mar 31, 2:26 pm, "Roger Zoul" <[email hidden]> wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    "ComandanteBanana" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    news:[email hidden]....

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off the
    > beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    > TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    > put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    > can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    > the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    > sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    > vehicle.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    > tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I've ridden my recumbent trike in real live traffic on many occasions I
    always live to tell about it. I take the lane when needed, too.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    It's about attitude and if you ain't got none, ride something else.

    Quoted message said:

    :>Yeah, but if I'm riding a bike in traffic, I'm giving my back to the
    :>enemy...

    Quoted message said:

    :>Whether I survive or not has little to with attitude, and a lot to
    :>with their clemency.

    Quoted message said:

    I think it's clearly about your attitude toward what you think may happen
    vs. what will happen. You're assuming drivers will run you down. Perhaps
    you live some place where cyclists get run down as a matter of sport, ona
    daily basis, anytime they share the road with traffic. Why don't you tell
    us about where you live and how many cyclists are killed there per year?-
    Hide quoted text -

    Quoted message said:

    - Show quoted text -

    :>I don't know how many are killed a year, but I've seen a beautiful
    :>lady on a scooter get crushed by a car running a red light right
    :>before my eyes. And out of the few cyclists who dare ride this road,
    :>never ever seen a trike. All you see is a few hardcore riders ride it
    :>early on weekends.

    :>By the way I do live in Miami Beach, USA.

    Sad about the lady...

    I don't know if she died or not, but she won't be as pretty as before
    if left with a limping leg.

    Quoted message said:


    Even here, there are roads that I choose not to ride on. But at the same
    time, there seem to be plenty roads that I can ride on. If your view of
    cycling means you go everywhere you need or want to go by trike/bike, then
    perhaps that is a serious concern.  As a recreational rider, I look at
    cycling from a different POV.- Hide quoted text -

    - Show quoted text -

    To me FREEDOM TO BIKE is just that. Freedom to ride when you want,
    where you want. Otherwise there's no freedom, period. You're just
    feeding the beast (wars and environmental destruction).

    I'm not opposed to driving, but most trips under 5 miles can be
    accomplished by bikes.

    http://atom.smasher.org/highway/?l1=You+are+feeding+&l2=the+Beast%21&l3=&l4=

  19. the beauty...

    http://www.schwinnbike.com/heritage/attachment.php?attachmentid=38628

    and the beast...

    http://www.marketingshift.com/images/internationalSUV-7300cxt.gif

  20. In article
    <[email hidden]>,

    ComandanteBanana said:

    Having other types of bikes in my collection, I'm about to get off
    the beaten path and get either a ROAD TANDEM BIKE or a FANCY UPRIGHT
    TRIKE. Well, I like them both but the road tandem would necessarily
    put me on the road AMONG THE BEASTS all the time, while the trike I
    can use on the back streets and on a new path being built overlooking
    the ocean (cool). But I'd be tempted to ride it on the streets
    sometimes, squarely TAKING THE LANE because then I'd be more of a
    vehicle.

    What's your thought, I'd be safer in the trike than on the road
    tandem, or should I start planning my funerals? 😉

    I see you've changed your screen name but not your behavior.

    A trike is no more of a vehicle than a bicycle. The trike riders I have
    met report that drivers give them more room on the road because they are
    an unusual veicle. Drivers may assume that the rider is infirm in some
    way, too.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.